The Phylogenetic Perspective. (Book Reviews: Phylogeny, Ecology, and Behavior. A Research Program in Comparative Biology.)
The Phylogenetic Perspective. (Book Reviews: Phylogeny, Ecology, and Behavior. A Research Program in Comparative Biology.)
复制标题
系统发育的观点。
DOI：
10.2307/1446122
复制
发表时间：
1991
期刊：
影响因子：
56.9
通讯作者：
D. A. Mclennan
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
D. Brooks;D. A. Mclennan
“这项工作的优点很多。将系统发育假说严格整合到适应、适应辐射和共同进化的研究中是绝对必要的，并且可以极大地改变我们在进化生物学中的集体“完形”。作者提出并说明了这一论点漂亮。写作往往是清晰的，例子是丰富和多样的，并置的例子从不同的生物系统有力地论证了论文的有效性。这里提供了许多新的见解，而且这项工作通常对有经验的遗传学家和天真的生态学家都是可以理解的。约瑟夫特拉维斯，佛罗里达州立大学“[“系统发育，生态学和行为”]提出了它的论点有力和令人信服的，有充分的。. . support.布鲁克斯和麦克伦南的结论与他们开始时一样，评论说进化是一个结果，而不是一个过程，它是各种过程，环境和历史相互作用的结果。进化论的解释必须考虑到所有这些组成部分，否则就是不完整的。正如达尔文对带有变异的血统的解释整合了系谱学和生态学信息一样，工作者现在也必须在他们的进化观点中纳入历史和非历史，生物和非生物的过程。马瓦利·H这本书写得很好，发人深省，我们这些在研究适应、进化生态学和共同进化时不经常转向系统发育分析的人应该读一读。Mark R. MacNair，《自然历史杂志》
"The merits of this work are many. A rigorous integration of phylogenetic hypotheses into studies of adaptation, adaptive radiation, and coevolution is absolutely necessary and can change dramatically our collective 'gestalt' about much in evolutionary biology. The authors advance and illustrate this thesis beautifully. The writing is often lucid, the examples are plentiful and diverse, and the juxtaposition of examples from different biological systems argues forcefully for the validity of the thesis. Many new insights are offered here, and the work is usually accessible to both the practiced phylogeneticist and the naive ecologist".--Joseph Travis, Florida State University "[ "Phylogeny, Ecology, and Behavior" ] presents its arguments forcefully and cogently, with ample . . .support. Brooks and McLennan conclude as they began, with the comment that evolution is a result, not a process, and that it is the result of an interaction of a variety of processes, environmental and historical. Evolutionary explanations must consider all these components, else they are incomplete. As Darwin's explanations of descent with modification integrated genealogical and ecological information, so must workers now incorporate historical and nonhistorical, and biological and nonbiological, processes in their evolutionary perspective".--Marvalee H. Wake, "Bioscience" "This book is well-written and thought-provoking, and should be read by those of us who do not routinely turn to phylogenetic analysis when investigating adaptation, evolutionary ecology and co-evolution".--Mark R. MacNair, "Journal of Natural History"