Invasion Science in the Developing World: A Response to Ricciardi et al.
Invasion Science in the Developing World: A Response to Ricciardi et al.
复制标题
DOI：
10.1016/j.tree.2017.08.006
复制
发表时间：
2017-11
影响因子：
16.8
通讯作者：
R. D. Zenni;S. Ziller;Aníbal Pauchard;M. Rodríguez-Cabal;Martin A. Nuñez
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
R. D. Zenni;S. Ziller;Aníbal Pauchard;M. Rodríguez-Cabal;Martin A. Nuñez
我们的综述[1]的一个主要目标是批判性地评估神秘雌性选择（CFC）的范围和经验证据，作为遗传多样性有性生殖生物进化变化的代理人，正如Eberhard在他有影响力的专著[2]中所做的那样。这种广度排除了对单个分类群的详细讨论，我们参考了更专业的出版物[1]。我们坚持我们的一般结论，虽然CFC有可能成为一种普遍现象和强大的进化力量，但这方面的证据往往是间接的和相关的。因此，我们全心全意地支持Eberhard [3]最近呼吁通过实验证明CFC，并欢迎他的建议，利用节肢动物的奇妙多样性和众多优势来研究CFC [4]。出于同样的原因，我们谨慎推断CFC及其健身后果（例如，男性胁迫与女性控制）的基础上系统发育模式或行为观察，虽然这些信息可能是高度相关的。研究CFC及其后果需要明确证明精子使用、受精或亲子关系结果中女性驱动的交配后偏倚，以及这种偏倚与男性表型或基因型之间的因果关系[2]。这一演示已被证明具有挑战性，尽管最近的事态发展预示着未来将取得令人兴奋的进展。毫无疑问，节肢动物将继续在迅速扩大的CFC领域发挥重要作用。
A major goal of our review [1] was to critically assess the scope of and empirical evidence for cryptic female choice (CFC) as an agent of evolutionary change in phylogenetically diverse sexually reproducing organisms, as did Eberhard in his influential monograph [2]. This breadth precludes a detailed discussion of individual taxa, for which we refer to more specialised publications [1]. We stand by our general conclusion that while CFC has the potential to be a general phenomenon and a powerful evolutionary force, evidence for this has often been indirect and correlational. We therefore wholeheartedly embrace Eberhard’s [3] recent call to demonstrate CFC experimentally and welcome his suggestion to harness the wondrous diversity and numerous advantages offered by arthropods for the study of CFC [4]. By the same token, we are wary of inferring CFC and its fitness consequences (eg, male coercion versus female control) based on phylogenetic patterns or behavioural observations alone, although this information may be highly relevant. Studying CFC and its consequences requires a clear demonstration of a female-driven postmating bias in sperm use, fertilisation, or paternity outcome and a causal link between such bias and male phenotype or genotype[2]. This demonstration has proved challenging, although recent developments promise exciting progress ahead. We have no doubt that arthropods will continue to play a prominent role in the rapidly expanding field of CFC.