Progressive Nostalgia in Novel Living Arrangements: A Counterpoint to Neo-traditional New Urbanism?
Progressive Nostalgia in Novel Living Arrangements: A Counterpoint to Neo-traditional New Urbanism?
复制标题
新颖的生活安排中渐进的怀旧之情：与新传统新都市主义的对立面？
DOI：
10.1177/0042098013478235
复制
发表时间：
2013
期刊：
影响因子：
4.7
通讯作者：
A. Bonnett
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
H. Jarvis;A. Bonnett
本文探讨了创造新的生活安排的愿望和对“更好”的过去的向往之间的关系。有人认为，与怀旧的批判性参与可以用来打开历史的持久性和模糊性的问题。本文借鉴了探索性的分析进行的三种新兴形式的住宅空间（新城市主义，家庭区和共同住房）的例子。本文试图找出矛盾和悖论，可以发现在新传统的家园和社区的物质发展。与轻视或纯粹工具性的方法相反，分析揭示了怀旧在归属和依恋的核心中的多样性和矛盾性。总而言之，其目的是扩大关于新的生活安排的辩论，并促进更大的开放和诚实，承认对过去的依恋在重新塑造城市共存的新形式中的作用。
This paper examines the relationship between a desire to create novel living arrangements and yearning for a ‘better’ past. It is argued that a critical engagement with nostalgia can be used to open up issues of historical persistence and ambiguity. The paper draws on exploratory analysis carried out on examples of three emerging forms of residential space (the new urbanism, home zones and cohousing). The paper seeks to identify the contradictions and paradoxes that can be found in the material development of neo-traditional homes and communities. In contrast to dismissive or purely instrumental approaches, the analysis reveals the diverse and ambivalent ways in which nostalgia resides at the heart of belonging and attachment. In sum, the aim is both to expand the debate on novel living arrangements and to promote greater openness and honesty in acknowledging the role of attachments to the past in refiguring new forms of urban co-existence.