Rationality environmentalised (with and beyond Michael Bonnett)
Rationality environmentalised (with and beyond Michael Bonnett)
复制标题
理性环境化（与迈克尔·博内特一起）
DOI：
10.1080/13504622.2022.2067324
复制
发表时间：
2023
影响因子：
3.2
通讯作者：
Misawa Koichiro
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Haruna Teruya;Aiko Kohara;Natsuki Yano;Haejin Kwon;Changwan Han;長廣利崇;長廣利崇;長廣利崇;髙田一宏;岡本工介;髙田一宏;諏訪晃一;高橋味央;棚田洋平;瀬戸麗;高田一宏;諏訪晃一;髙田一宏;髙田一宏;高橋味央;高橋未央;高橋未央;棚田洋平;高橋味央;高橋味央;髙田一宏;岡本工介・新谷龍太朗;瀬戸麗;松原信継;松原信継;松原信継・間宮静香・伊藤健治;松原信継;松原信継・間宮静香・伊藤健治（編著者）ほか;松原信継・間宮静香・伊藤健治;志村聡子;志村聡子;志村聡子;鈴木敦史;鈴木敦史;鈴木敦史;鈴木敦史;深作拓郎;深作拓郎;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;杉本憲子;Misawa Koichiro
迈克尔·邦奈特的《环境意识》(2021)是他在其前作《找回自然》(2004)中开创的自然现象学的令人钦佩的延伸。为了充分理解他的环境思想的精髓，我将他在自然现象学中发展出的一系列思想(如“环境意识”本身)放在更广泛的背景下，将“环境意识”定位为不仅是“找回自然”的续集，也是儿童思维的续篇(1994)。虽然我对他的思想如何演变成他的新书中阐述的环境教育哲学表示了广泛的同情，但我认为，理性的概念已经与他的环保化项目疏远了。鉴于邦尼特承认与约翰·麦克道尔对自然的重新概念化的联盟，我认为后者的观点，即人类经验在相关意义上被概念理性所弥漫，可以为将理性与邦尼特正在进行的项目相结合腾出空间；换句话说，我打赌理性应该被‘环境化’。
Michael Bonnett’s highly regardedEnvironmental Consciousness(2021) is an admirable extension of the phenomenology of nature inaugurated in his previous workRetrieving Nature(2004). To fully capture the essentials of his environmental thinking, I locate the set of ideas he has developed in his phenomenology of nature (such as ‘environmental consciousness’ itself) within a wider context, by situatingEnvironmental Consciousnessas a sequel not just toRetrieving Naturebut also toChildren’s Thinking(1994). While broadly sympathetic with how his thinking has evolved into the environmental philosophy of education articulated in his new book, I argue that the notion of rationality has been alienated from his environmentalising project. Given the alliance Bonnett acknowledges with John McDowell’s re-conceptualisation of nature, I contend that the latter’s view that human experience is pervaded by conceptual rationality in a relevant sense can make room to integrate rationality with Bonnett’s on-going project; put differently, I wager that rationality should be ‘environmentalised’.