Rehabilitation, risk management and prisoners' rights
Rehabilitation, risk management and prisoners' rights
复制标题
DOI：
10.1177/1748895813502500
复制
发表时间：
2014-09-01
影响因子：
1.5
通讯作者：
Player, Elaine
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Genders, Elaine;Player, Elaine
作为英格兰和威尔士“康复革命”的一部分，针对人格障碍罪犯的监狱治疗方案的扩大引发了关于风险、权利和康复的固有概念如何被选择性地感知和使用的重大问题。目前的政策支持解决罪犯对公众造成的风险的改过自新机会，但仍然忽视改过自新方案可能对罪犯造成的伤害风险。对人格障碍囚犯的康复干预措施--民主治疗社区--固有的人身伤害风险的审查表明，在当代刑事政策中选择性地承认人权--囚犯的权利通常与资格较低的地位挂钩--产生了重要后果，既破坏了方案执行的完整性，也严重危及国家对囚犯负有的照顾义务所固有的积极义务。
The expansion of prison treatment programmes for personality disordered offenders as part of the 'Rehabilitation Revolution' in England and Wales raises significant questions about the ways in which inherent concepts of risks, rights and rehabilitation are selectively perceived and employed. Current policy supports rehabilitative opportunities that address the risks offenders pose to the public, yet remains inattentive to the risk of harm that rehabilitative programmes can pose to offenders. Examination of the risk of personal harm intrinsic to one rehabilitative intervention for personality disordered prisoners - the democratic therapeutic community - illustrates how the selective acknowledgement of human rights in contemporary penal policy, whereby prisoners' rights are routinely tied to a status of less eligibility, has important consequences that both undermine the integrity of programme delivery and seriously jeopardize the positive duties that are inherent in the duty of care owed to prisoners by the State.