Effects of methodology and stakeholder disaggregation on ecosystem service valuation
Effects of methodology and stakeholder disaggregation on ecosystem service valuation
复制标题
方法论和利益相关者分类对生态系统服务评估的影响
DOI：
10.5751/es-06811-190318
复制
发表时间：
2014
影响因子：
4.1
通讯作者：
F. Eigenbrod
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
E. Brooks;Kevin G. Smith;Robert A. Holland;G. Poppy;F. Eigenbrod
条件价值评估是生态系统服务价值评估中最常用的方法之一，因此包括对许多此类评估的参与性方法。然而，在生态系统服务评估中，包括非货币利益相关者优先事项仍然很少见，利益相关者的分解几乎不在实践中。我们研究了来自亚洲的四个站点规模的湿地生态系统服务评估，这些评估使用了来自一系列利益相关者的非货币参与性声明偏好技术，并将这些优先顺序与全球现有的最大货币评估-生态系统服务价值数据库(ESVD)-获得的优先顺序进行了比较。利益相关者评估表明，与货币评估的优先事项非常不同，但不同地点之间的优先事项大致保持一致。将受益者分到一个地点，表明利益攸关方之间的价值观存在显著差异。货币价值与政府官员和企业主持有的价值呈正相关，而与最直接依赖湿地生态系统服务的渔民和妇女呈负相关。我们的研究结果强调，生态系统服务评估，无论是货币评估还是其他评估，都必须捕捉利益相关者群体之间存在的价值多样性，以纳入场地规模管理问题，特别是与扶贫有关的问题。
Contingent valuation is one of the most commonly used methodologies utilized in ecosystem service valuation, thereby including a participatory approach to many such assessments. However, inclusion of nonmonetary stakeholder priorities is still uncommon in ecosystem service valuations and disaggregation of stakeholders is all but absent from practice. We look at four site-scale wetland ecosystem service valuations from Asia that used nonmonetary participatory stated preference techniques from a range of stakeholders, and compare these prioritizations to those obtained from the largest monetary assessments available globally, the Ecosystem Service Value Database (ESVD). Stakeholder assessment suggests very different priorities to those from monetary assessments, yet priorities between different sites remained broadly consistent. Disaggregation of beneficiaries in one site showed marked differences in values between stakeholders. Monetary values correlate positively with values held by government officers and business owners, but negatively with fishermen and women who are relying most directly on the wetland ecosystem services. Our findings emphasize that ecosystem service assessment, monetary or otherwise, must capture the diversity of values present across stakeholder groups to incorporate site scale management issues, particularly in relation to poverty alleviation.
影响因子：
5.7
作者：
Rouquette J
通讯作者：
Rouquette J
影响因子：
2.7
作者：
Daw, Tim;Brown, Katrina;Pomeroy, Robert
通讯作者：
Pomeroy, Robert