Critical institutionalism : a synthesis and exploration of key themes
Critical institutionalism : a synthesis and exploration of key themes
复制标题
批判制度主义：关键主题的综合和探索
DOI：
--
复制
发表时间：
2013
期刊：
影响因子：
--
通讯作者：
F. Maganga
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Kurt Hall;F. Cleaver;T. Franks;F. Maganga
本文旨在综合学术界批评主流制度主义的关键讨论。它采用主题方法来绘制关于关键问题的辩论和共识领域。本文的第一部分简要描述了主流“集体行动”学派的崛起。然后依次检查被确定为替代批判方法核心的每个主题。这些是对“同质社区”的批评；避免政治批评（进一步分为观念政治和地方赋权政治）；以及社会学批判。本文最后反思了制度分析中新生的批判传统所面临的“使复杂性变得清晰”的挑战。
The paper aims to provide a synthesis of key discussions within scholarship that is critical of mainstream institutionalism. It adopts a thematic approach to chart debate and areas of convergence about key issues. The first section of the paper briefly charts the rise to prominence of the mainstream “collective action” school. Each of the themes identified as central to the alternative critical approach are then examined in turn. These are the ‘homogenous community’ critique; the avoidance of politics critique (further divided into ideational politics and politics of local empowerment); and the sociological critique. The paper concludes by reflecting on the challenge of ‘making complexity legible’ which faces the nascent critical tradition in institutional analysis.