Comments Related to "A Comprehensive Review of the RMA APH and COMBO Rating Methodology" Final Report
Comments Related to "A Comprehensive Review of the RMA APH and COMBO Rating Methodology" Final Report
复制标题
与“RMA APH 和 COMBO 评级方法的全面审查”最终报告相关的评论
DOI：
--
复制
发表时间：
2010
期刊：
影响因子：
--
通讯作者：
R. Rejesus
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Keith H. Coble;T. Knight;B. Goodwin;Mary Frances Miller;R. Rejesus
我们很欣赏评论者A及其顾问所提出的审慎意见。我们同意，在农业经济基本结构不断演变的环境中，评级和风险计量是一项重大挑战。在对详细评论作出具体答复之前，我们想提出一些一般性意见。首先，联邦农作物保险计划的广度和种类令人印象深刻。重要的是要认识到，透明度和透明度的考虑必然要求使用一种单一的广泛的评级方法，军事革命必须在这些相当重要的限制条件下工作。尽管如此，有许多理由对收到的关于本报告的评论中提出的一些论点表示关切。
We appreciate the careful comments made by Commenter A and its consultants. We agree that rating and risk measurement in an environment where the underlying structure of the agricultural economy is constantly evolving presents important challenges. Before proceeding to specific responses to the detailed comments, we would offer a few general observations. First, the federal crop insurance program is impressive in its breadth and variety. It is important to recognize that transparency and manageability considerations necessarily demand that a single broad approach to rating be used and that the RMA must work within these rather significant constraints. That said, there are many reasons to raise concerns with some of the arguments advanced in the comments received on this report.