Syd Barrett took a left turn and never came back, Andrew Voyce did. Why?
Syd Barrett took a left turn and never came back, Andrew Voyce did. Why?
复制标题
西德·巴雷特（Syd Barrett）左转，再也没有回来，安德鲁·沃伊斯（Andrew Voyce）却回来了。
DOI：
10.1108/mhsi-06-2021-0031
复制
发表时间：
2021
影响因子：
1.2
通讯作者：
J. Carson
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Patrick J. Hopkinson;A. Voyce;J. Carson
目的
本文的目的是比较西德巴雷特音乐家的故事，与安德鲁Voyce，和他们各自的恢复旅程。
设计/方法/方式
作者使用合作的自我民族志来分享他们对Syd Barrett的看法，并将他的故事与合著者Andrew的故事进行对比。
结果
希德和安德鲁都经历了严重的精神痛苦。虽然Syd与心理健康服务的接触有限，但Andrew的接触非常广泛，有20年的入院和出院史。最后，当精神病服务机构倾听安德鲁的担忧并采取行动时，他得以进入康复之旅。
研究限制/影响
作者在关于Syd Barrett的可用信息量方面受到限制，特别是与心理健康问题有关的信息。安德鲁的故事表明，即使在多年的严重精神疾病之后，康复也是可能的。
实际影响
安德鲁的故事说明了为什么专业人士永远不应该放弃人，即使是最严重和最棘手的问题。服务能为希德做得更多吗？
社会影响
精神疾病仍然会招致巨大的耻辱。现在有一种更加开放的文化。如果社会更加开放，西德会公开自己与心理健康的斗争吗？
独创性/价值
将两个精神痛苦的故事放在一起，使作者能够探索康复的概念。
Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to compare the stories of Syd Barrett musician, with Andrew Voyce, and their respective recovery journeys.
Design/methodology/approach
The authors use collaborative autoethnography to share their own perspectives on Syd Barrett and to contrast his story with that of Andrew, a co-author.
Findings
Both Syd and Andrew experienced serious mental distress. While Syd had only limited contact with mental health services, Andrew’s contact was extensive, with a 20-year history of admissions and discharges. In the end, when the psychiatric services listened to Andrew’s concerns and acted on them, he was able to enter into the journey of recovery.
Research limitations/implications
The authors are restricted in the amount of available information on Syd Barrett, especially that related to mental health problems. The story of Andrew shows how recovery is possible even after years of serious mental illness.
Practical implications
Andrew’s story shows why professionals should never give up on people, with even the most seemingly severe and intractable problems. Could services have done more for Syd?
Social implications
Mental illness still attracts huge stigma. Today there is a much more open culture. Would Syd have come out about his own struggles with mental health had society been more open?
Originality/value
Bringing together two stories of mental distress enables the authors to explore the concept of recovery.