Can the obstacles to privacy self-management be overcome? Exploring the consent intermediary approach
Can the obstacles to privacy self-management be overcome? Exploring the consent intermediary approach
复制标题
隐私自我管理的障碍能否克服？
DOI：
10.1177/2053951717721935
复制
发表时间：
2017
影响因子：
8.5
通讯作者：
Yki Kortesniemi
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Tuukka Lehtiniemi;Yki Kortesniemi
在隐私自我管理中，人们被期望对他们的个人数据的使用进行成本效益分析，只有当他们的主观利益超过成本时才同意。然而，无处不在的个人数据收集和大数据分析对成功的隐私管理提出了越来越多的挑战。许多服务和研究计划都提出了类似的解决方案，通过将同意决策整合到单个界面下，为人们提供对其数据的更多控制。我们将其命名为“同意中介”方法。在本文中，我们首先确定了八个障碍，隐私自我管理的成本效益分析的概念和实践的挑战。然后，我们分析在何种程度上同意中介可以帮助克服障碍。我们认为，简单地将同意决定下一个接口提供有限的帮助，但这种方法的潜力在于利用中介地位，提供助手的隐私管理。我们发现，有了合适的工具，一些更实际的障碍确实可以解决，而其他人仍然从根本上无法克服的个性化隐私自我管理模式。还应注意同意中介机构如何利用用户和其他服务之间的中介地位所赋予的权力。
In privacy self-management, people are expected to perform cost–benefit analysis on the use of their personal data, and only consent when their subjective benefits outweigh the costs. However, the ubiquitous collection of personal data and Big Data analytics present increasing challenges to successful privacy management. A number of services and research initiatives have proposed similar solutions to provide people with more control over their data by consolidating consent decisions under a single interface. We have named this the ‘consent intermediary’ approach. In this paper, we first identify the eight obstacles to privacy self-management which make cost–benefit analysis conceptually and practically challenging. We then analyse to which extent consent intermediaries can help overcome the obstacles. We argue that simply bringing consent decisions under one interface offers limited help, but that the potential of this approach lies in leveraging the intermediary position to provide aides for privacy management. We find that with suitable tools, some of the more practical obstacles indeed can become solvable, while others remain fundamentally insuperable within the individuated privacy self-management model. Attention should also be paid to how the consent intermediaries may take advantage of the power vested in the intermediary positions between users and other services.
DOI：
10.7146/aahcc.v1i1.21312
发表时间：
2015-01
期刊：
ArXiv
影响因子：
--
作者：
H. Haddadi;H. Howard;Amir Chaudhry;J. Crowcroft;Anil Madhavapeddy;R. Mortier
通讯作者：
H. Haddadi;H. Howard;Amir Chaudhry;J. Crowcroft;Anil Madhavapeddy;R. Mortier