Political Philosophy's Methodological Moment and the Rise of Public Political Philosophy
Political Philosophy's Methodological Moment and the Rise of Public Political Philosophy
复制标题
政治哲学的方法论时刻和公共政治哲学的兴起
DOI：
10.1007/s12115-022-00710-2
复制
发表时间：
2022
期刊：
影响因子：
0.9
通讯作者：
Floyd J
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Floyd J
政治哲学正处于方法论时刻。由于长期以来对我们领域的碎片化感到沮丧，以及最近更多地参与“现实”世界的冲动，现在关于我们职业的“真实”本质的辩论激增。然而，这部新作品如何才能避免简单地在新标签下重复旧的竞争呢？关键是将所有这些所谓的方法论兴趣转变为真正新的“方法论”计划，这里的定义是对我们作为政治哲学家可用的所有不同推理方法的仔细识别和评估。这个计划将第一次澄清我们可能相互争论的所有方式，从而使我们不太可能互相说三道四，而更有可能一起富有成效地合作。
Political philosophy is having a methodological moment. Driven by long-standing frustrations at the fragmentation of our field, as well as recent urges to become more engaged with the ‘real’ world, there is now a boom in debates concerning the ‘true’ nature of our vocation. Yet how can this new work avoid simply recycling old rivalries under new labels? The key is to turn all this so-called methodological interest into a genuinely new programme of ‘methodology’, defined here as the careful identification and evaluation of all the different methods of reasoning available to us as political philosophers. This programme would clarify, for the first time, all the many ways in which we might argue with one another, thus making us less likely to talk past each another, and more likely to work fruitfully together.