Reply to comment on 'Temperature dependent optical properties of PbS nanocrystals'.
Reply to comment on 'Temperature dependent optical properties of PbS nanocrystals'.
复制标题
回复评论“PbS 纳米晶体的温度依赖性光学特性”。
DOI：
10.1088/0957-4484/24/28/288002
复制
发表时间：
2013
期刊：
影响因子：
3.5
通讯作者：
Nordin MN
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Nordin MN
We thank Ullrich et al for commenting on our paper [1] in which we referenced their work in this area [2]([28] in [1]) and are happy to offer the following response in clarification and correction. Our response is based on addressing the three points raised by Ullrich (a− c) in turn as follows:(a) Relating to the original statement in our manuscript:‘Ullrich et al [28] were able to use equation (3) to fit both PL and absorption and suggest that measurement of the absorption properties offers better agreement when S= A/{2〈 Eph〉}...’[1].In the comment provided by Ullrich et al on our paper they raise our above statement as their first point and in particular the usage of the phrase ‘when S= A/{〈 Eph〉}’in this sentence. We note that the sentence they quote from our paper actually continues to include a description of the variable ‘A’. The intention in our original paper was to recognize the two key findings summarized by Ullrich et al in their paper [2]. We wished to simply state that the quality of fit obtained by Ullrich et al to their data in [2] using equation (3) in [1] is better than that obtained using the Varshni equation (equation (2) in [1]). This is the first conclusion of Ullrich et al who state in their summary paragraph ‘Summarizing, the work promotes the use of the Fan model...’where the Fan model is identical to equation (3) in [1] if the definition S= A/{2〈 Eph〉} is used as reported in [2].
