Political Islam observed : disciplinary perspectives
Political Islam observed : disciplinary perspectives
复制标题
政治伊斯兰观察：学科视角
DOI：
10.5860/choice.48-5961
复制
发表时间：
2010
期刊：
影响因子：
--
通讯作者：
Cemil Boyraz
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Cemil Boyraz
弗雷德里克·沃尔皮将“观察”当代政治伊斯兰的学科与它们所观察的实际个人和社区进行了比较。沃尔皮着眼于社会科学及其对“伊斯兰”主题的独特方法，展示了学科如何根据自己的主导范式分析政治伊斯兰。即使融合了专家观点，跨学科的推动也常常只会导致针对政治和公共消费的有根据的猜测。沃尔皮认为，这些范式之间的竞争掩盖了政治伊斯兰的实际动力和凝聚力。他指出了针对伊斯兰现象的学科方法的优缺点，并迈出了基于后东方主义、国际关系、宗教社会学以及民主化、多元文化主义、安全分析和全球化研究的第一步。观察政治伊斯兰
Frederic Volpi compares the academic disciplines that "observe" contemporary political Islam to the actual individuals and communities that are being observed by them. Zeroing in on the social sciences and their distinct approach to "Islamic" subject matter, Volpi shows how disciplines analyze political Islam according to their own dominant paradigms. Even with the incorporation of specialist viewpoints, the interdisciplinary drive often results in nothing more than educated guesses geared toward political and public consumption. Volpi argues that the competition between these paradigms obscures the actual dynamics and cohesiveness of political Islam. He identifies the strengths and weaknesses of disciplinary approaches toward the Islamist phenomenon and takes the first step in developing an account based on post-orientalism, international relations, the sociology of religion, and studies in democratization, multiculturalism, security analysis, and globalization. Political Islam Observed