Orbiting SATURN: countering politically-charged misinformation with facts.
Orbiting SATURN: countering politically-charged misinformation with facts.
复制标题
绕土星运行：用事实反击带有政治色彩的错误信息。
DOI：
10.1162/152651604773067389
复制
发表时间：
2004
期刊：
影响因子：
--
通讯作者：
Goldberg,Linn
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Chiodo,GaryT;Moe,EstherL;Goldberg,Linn
Adil E.作者声明：Jonathan D. Moreno（2004）讨论了与人类受试者研究者和机构审查委员会（IRB）相关的一个重要而及时的问题。虽然我们同意Shamoo和Moreno对保护研究参与者儿童的关注，但我们注意到他们提出了许多事实上不正确的陈述，假设和更多的猜测。提交人引用了13篇选定的当地报纸文章，但不了解这些来源的政治背景，也不证实所引用的言论的准确性。他们没有引用任何支持社论和信件印在新闻来源。基于不准确的信息和不客观的评论和报告，Shamoo和Moreno得出结论，SATURN（使用随机通知的学生运动测试）研究是不道德的，
Adil E. Shamoo and Jonathan D. Moreno (2004) discuss an important and timely issue related to human subjects investigators and institutional review boards (IRBs). While we agree with Shamoo and Moreno’s concern for the protection of children who are research participants, we note that they present many factually incorrect statements, assumptions, and more than a modest amount of conjecture. The authors have quoted 13 selected local newspaper articles without understanding the political context of those sources or confirming the accuracy of the statements quoted. They fail to cite any of the supportive editorials and letters printed in news sources. Based upon inaccurate information and less-thanobjective commentaries and reports, Shamoo and Moreno conclude that the SATURN (Student Athletic Testing Using Random Notification) study was unethical and