Freedom, equality, property and Bentham: The debate over unfree labour
Freedom, equality, property and Bentham: The debate over unfree labour
复制标题
自由、平等、财产与边沁：关于不自由劳动的争论
DOI：
--
复制
发表时间：
1999
期刊：
影响因子：
--
通讯作者：
J. Rao
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
J. Rao
除了妨碍实质性立场的沟通之外，定义上的争议可能会被视为无关紧要而被忽视。在目前的情况下，这种态度似乎站不住脚，因为自由劳动力和资本主义都是流行的大词。涉及这些术语的争论反映了理论和历史解释上更深层次的差异。尽管，或者也许是因为，本书的很大一部分内容都充满了此类争议，但它做出了极其有价值的贡献，并引发了许多与劳动和阶级关系有关的实质性问题，无论是当代的还是历史的。虽然总体而言，本书中的十八个广泛的案例研究是否对争论的类别提供了有用的启发，反之亦然，但它们的集体价值超越了争论本身，意见可能会有所不同。自由和不自由的劳动力：争论仍在继续，汤姆·布拉斯和马塞尔·范德林登编辑，伯尔尼：彼得·朗，1997 年。国际和……系列中的第 5 卷
Definitional disputes may be disregarded as inconsequential aside from getting in the way of communicating substantive positions. In the present instance, such an attitude seems untenable if only because Free Labour and Capitalism are big words in wide currency. And debates involving these terms reflect deeper differences in theoretical and historical interpretation. Though, or perhaps because, a considerable part of the volume in review is energised by such disputes, it makes an eminently valuable contribution and provokes many substantive questions relating to labour and class relations, both contemporary and especially historical. While opinion may vary whether, on balance, the eighteen wide‐ranging case studies in the volume shed useful light on the categories in contention and vice versa, their collective value transcends the debates themselves. Free and Unfree Labour: The Debate Continues, edited by Tom Brass and Marcel van der Linden, Bern: Peter Lang, 1997. Volume 5 in the series International and...