Advancing quantitative intersectionality research methods: Intracategorical and intercategorical approaches to shared and differential constructs
Advancing quantitative intersectionality research methods: Intracategorical and intercategorical approaches to shared and differential constructs
复制标题
DOI：
10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.03.018
复制
发表时间：
2019-04-01
影响因子：
5.4
通讯作者：
Scheim, Ayden I.
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
Bauer, Greta R.;Scheim, Ayden I.
最近提出了一系列方法，用于将交叉性理论框架纳入定量研究方法。我们发表了两篇关于范畴间交叉性方法的文章，其中我们区分了分析研究和描述性研究，确定了因果调解分解方法作为分析范畴间交叉性的适当策略，并引入并验证了一组用于范畴间分析的主要、日常和预期歧视的三种新测量(Bauer和Scheim，2019；Scheim和Bauer，2019)。我们对Evans(2019年)；Jackson和VanderWeele(2019)；Hamois和Bastos(2019)；以及Richman和Zucker(2019)的四篇特邀评论中提出的几点做出回应。我们讨论差异结构，它代表那些只存在于特定交叉口的那些，或者对于其含义在不同的交叉口不同的那些。虽然这样的结构可以在类别内研究，但在类别间研究中，它们对可以使用的测量类型和可以进行的统计分析都施加了限制。因此，大多数定量交叉性方法的工作都集中在范畴内的测量上，而不是范畴间的分析上。我们提出了在定量交叉方法中继续发展方法的初步议程。
A range of methods have recently been proposed for incorporating intersectionality theoretical frameworks into quantitative research methodology. We published a pair of articles on methods for intercategorical intersectionality, in which we distinguished analytic from descriptive studies, identified causal mediation decomposition methods as an appropriate strategy for analytic intercategorical intersectionality, and introduced and validated a group of three new measures of major, day-to-day, and anticipated discrimination for use in inter categorical analysis (Bauer and Scheim, 2019; Scheim and Bauer, 2019). We respond to points raised in four invited commentaries on our original pair of articles by Evans (2019); Jackson and VanderWeele (2019); Hamois and Bastos (2019); and Richman and Zucker (2019). We discuss differential constructs, which represent those that exist only for those at particular intersections, or for which meanings vary across intersections. Whereas such constructs may be studied intracategorically, in intercategorical studies they place limits on both the types of measures that may be used and the statistical analyses that can be conducted. Most quantitative intersectionality methods work has therefore focused on intracategorical measures, but intercategorical analyses. We present a preliminary agenda for continued methods development in quantitative intersectionality methods.