'Dreamers with Shovels': Science and Technology in the New Deal Political Imagination
'Dreamers with Shovels': Science and Technology in the New Deal Political Imagination
批准号:
0135333
负责人:
Jessica Wang
金额:
$9.0万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Fixed Amount Award
财政年份:
2002
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2002-07-01 至 2006-06-30
中文摘要
项目摘要SES Proposal 0135333《手持铲子的梦想家:新政中的科技政治想象力》加州大学洛杉矶分校的Jessica Wang项目通过一系列基于传记的历史案例研究,调查了科技在美国新政时期政治思想和行动中的作用。在科学和技术研究中,许多技术官僚政治思想的观察者强调了它的霸权主义、工具主义和不民主的特征。然而,近年来,学者们认识到,尽管这种方法对理解技术社会的性质做出了很大贡献,但它需要修改和补充。对新政的研究提供了一个重要的机会,可以重新考虑普遍存在的假设,并将技术官僚政治的复杂性质作为一系列信仰和实践来审视。研究集中在三个主要主题--规划、电气化和国家建设--并讨论了在新政期间,科学和技术如何影响这些领域的决策。规划部分说明了雷克斯福德·盖伊·图格韦尔、弗雷德里克·A·德拉诺、韦斯利·C·米切尔和查尔斯·E·梅里亚姆是如何将技术官僚的意识形态转化为行动的。对于电气化,这项研究转向技术本身,并调查田纳西河谷管理局和农村电气化管理局内部在技术与人类价值观之间的适当关系以及技术发展的适当政治结构方面的冲突。关于国家建设的讨论考察了JeromeN是如何。弗兰克和威廉·M·莱瑟森利用有关科学的思想使新政国家合法化,并证明其通过20世纪30年代新的行政机构扩大国家权力是合理的。该项目的最后部分探讨了亨利·A·华莱士和大卫·E·利连塔尔的战后经历,考察了冷战带来的技术官僚政治的转变,并探讨了冷战工具主义如何取代新政时期的技术官僚自由主义。通过考察新交易商如何将科学和技术视为政治资源,该项目有助于STS内部关于技术官僚神学的性质及其政治后果的新一轮辩论。新政揭示了技术官僚政治背后的全部复杂性。一些新经销商对知识的性质采取了主观主义的信念,一些人在他们的技术进步版本中带来了怀旧的、农业的层面,大多数人认真对待专家和民主社会之间的问题关系,并为技术官僚政治能否与民主价值观保持一致的问题而苦苦挣扎。新警长们不同的思想和经验表明,技术官僚政治的形象是天真的实证主义者,致力于对技术进步的坚定信念,以及过度愿意将民主价值观从属于对专业知识的崇拜,需要改进和重新评估。该项目将加强STS目前的努力,重新调整专业知识和民主之间的关系,并探索科学技术作为政治思想和实践形式的全部意义。
英文摘要
Project AbstractSES Proposal 0135333"Dreamers with Shovels:" Science and Technology in the New Deal Political Imagination Jessica Wang, University of California, Los AngelesThe project investigates, through a series of biographically-based historical case studies,the role of science and technology in political thought and action during the New Deal period inthe United States. Within science and technology studies, many observers of technocraticpolitical thought have emphasized its hegemonic, instrumentalist, and undemocratic character.In recent years, however, scholars have recognized that while this approach has contributed muchtoward understanding the nature of technological society, it needs to be revised and augmented.A study of the New Deal provides an important opportunity to reconsider prevailing assumptionsand scrutinize the complex nature of technocratic politics as a set of beliefs and practices.The study centers on three main subjects -- planning, electrification, and state-building -- anddiscusses how science and technology affected policymaking in each of these areas during theNew Deal years. The section on planning illuminates how Rexford Guy Tugwell, Frederic A.Delano, Wesley C. Mitchell, and Charles E. Merriam sought to translate technocratic ideologyinto action. With electrification, the study turns to technology itself and investigates the conflictswithin the Tennessee Valley Authority and the Rural Electrification Administration over theproper relationship between technology and human values, and the appropriate politicalstructures for technological development. The discussion of state-building examines how JeromeN. Frank and William M. Leiserson used ideas about science to legitimize the New Deal stateand justify its expansion of state power via the new administrative agencies of the 1930s. Thefinal part of the project probes the postwar experiences of Henry A. Wallace and David E.Lilienthal, examines the transformation of technocratic politics wrought by the cold war, andexplores how cold war instrumentalism replaced the technocratic liberalism of the New Deal.By examining how the New Dealers understood science and technology as a resource forpolitics, the project contributes to a renewed debate within STS over the nature of technocraticideology and its political ramifications. The New Deal reveals the full complexity behindtechnocratic politics. Some of the New Dealers adopted subjectivist beliefs about the nature ofknowledge, some brought a nostalgic, agrarian dimension to their version of technologicalprogress, and most took seriously the problematic relationship between experts and democraticsociety and struggled over the question of whether technocratic politics could be made consistentwith democratic values. The diverse range of thought and experience among the New Dealerssuggests that an image of technocratic politics as naively positivist, dedicated to an unwaveringfaith in technological progress, and overly willing to subordinate democratic values to a cult ofexpertise requires refinement and reevaluation. The project will reinforce STS's current effortsto readdress the relationship between expertise and democracy and explore the full meaning ofscience and technology as forms of political thought and practice.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
EAGER: Collaborative Research: Enhancing Asian American and Pacific Islander Participation and Belonging in the Geosciences
-
批准号:2136193
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$0.48万
-
财政年份:2022
-
负责人:Jessica Wang
-
依托单位:
Dissertation Research: Scientists' Political Activism and the American Public during the Cold War Era, 1945-1980
-
批准号:0322983
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$0.8万
-
财政年份:2003
-
负责人:Jessica Wang
-
依托单位:
海外基金