RUI: Can Brief Social Interactions Undermine System Variable Protections Against False Eyewitness Identifications?
RUI: Can Brief Social Interactions Undermine System Variable Protections Against False Eyewitness Identifications?
批准号:
1627433
负责人:
Amy Douglass
金额:
$12.79万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016-09-15 至 2019-08-31
中文摘要
目击者鉴定研究考察了司法系统的可控方面可以在多大程度上进行修改,以减少鉴定错误,并提出了关于减少错误鉴定率的列队和照片传播的建议。然而,即使采用了建议的程序,目击者仍然能认出无辜的人。在拟议的研究中,我们探讨了这些目击者识别错误是否由短暂的社会互动形成,定义为证人与共同证人之间或证人与照片传播管理员之间在识别程序开始之前的任何信息交换。确定简短的社会互动是否以及在多大程度上影响目击证人的决定——即使使用了推荐的程序——提高了我们对目击证人如何做出决定的理解,并有助于建立一个知识库,从中产生具体的建议。这些可能包括自动的照片传播程序,从而减少或消除社会互动,以及收集记忆信息的替代方法。短暂的社会互动可能会通过操纵证人的决策标准来影响证人的选择行为,以便证人在愿意做出肯定的指认之前,需要更多(或更少)匹配嫌疑人的外表和证人的记忆。这项研究的关键特征是,我们假设决策标准是可塑的,作为短暂的社会互动的功能,甚至当推荐的程序到位时。提出了两个阶段的实验。在第一阶段,对共同证人行为的操纵进行测试,包括共同证人识别的明显容易程度和共同证人识别的速度。这一阶段的最后一个实验是测试目击者是否能准确地报告短暂的社会互动是否影响了他们的辨认决定。这是通过操纵反事实指令来实现的。在第二阶段的实验中,对照片传播管理员的操作进行了测试,包括对识别任务的难度和进行识别的压力的评论。与共同证人阶段一样,最后的实验操纵反事实指令,以确定证人是否认识到社会线索影响了他们的辨认决定。
英文摘要
Eyewitness identification research has examined the extent to which controllable aspects of the justice system can be modified to reduce identification errors and has generated recommendations for lineups and photospreads that reduce the rate of false identifications. Even when recommended procedures are used, however, eyewitnesses still identify innocent people. In the proposed research, we explore whether these eyewitness identification errors are shaped by brief social interactions, defined as any exchange of information between a witness and a co-witness or between a witness and a photospread administrator before the identification procedure begins. Determining whether and the extent to which brief social interactions affect eyewitness decisions -- even when recommended procedures are used -- advances our understanding of how eyewitness decisions are made and contributes to a knowledge base from which specific recommendations will emerge. These might include automated photospread procedures whereby social interactions are minimized or eliminated, and alternative methods of collecting memory information.Brief social interactions may affect eyewitness choosing behavior through manipulation of the witness's decision criterion so that more (or less) of a match between a suspect's appearance and the witness's memory is required by the witness before he or she is willing to make a positive identification. The critical feature of the proposed research is that we hypothesize that the decision criterion is malleable as a function of brief social interactions and even when recommended procedures are in place. Two phases of experiments are proposed. In the first phase, manipulations to co-witness behavior are tested, including the apparent ease of a co-witness's identification and the speed of a co-witness's identification. The final experiment in this phase tests if witnesses can accurately report whether brief social interactions have affected their identification decision. This is accomplished through the manipulation of counterfactual instructions. In the second phase of experiments, manipulations to photospread administrators are tested, including comments about the difficulty of the identification task and pressure to make an identification. As in the co-witness phase, the final experiment manipulates counterfactual instructions to determine whether witnesses recognize that social cues have affected their identification decision.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Collaborative Research: Video-Recording Eyewitness Identification Lineups: Testing for Unanticipated Costs and Undiscovered Benefits
-
批准号:1849411
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$13.07万
-
财政年份:2019
-
负责人:Amy Douglass
-
依托单位:
RUI: The Dynamic Interaction Between Investigator and Eyewitness: Effects on Memory Reports and Interviewer Behavior
-
批准号:0921193
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$12.89万
-
财政年份:2009
-
负责人:Amy Douglass
-
依托单位:
海外基金