课题基金 / 基金详情

Auditors' Judgment in a Financial Statement Audit and Professional Skepticism in Auditing

Auditors' Judgment in a Financial Statement Audit and Professional Skepticism in Auditing
审计师对财务报表审计的判断和审计中的职业怀疑
批准号:
22653053
负责人:
TOBA Yoshihide
金额:
$1.77万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
日本
项目类别:
Grant-in-Aid for Challenging Exploratory Research
财政年份:
2010
资助国家:
日本
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2010 至 2012

项目摘要

项目成果

TOBA Yoshihide的其他基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
无论是在学术上还是在实践中,越来越多的争论在国内和国际层面上提出了更多的“审计中的专业怀疑主义”。围绕独立审计师的内部和外部环境导致了对职业怀疑的侵蚀,并有可能削弱社会对审计师的信任。这种侵蚀早在上世纪90年代初就被观察到,并得到了会计行业本身的强烈认可。长期以来,专业标准一直强调在整个取证过程中保持适当程度的怀疑态度,这一过程由规划审计方案、执行程序和评估证据组成。审计师应该明白怀疑的本质是“提出问题”和“表现出质疑的心态”,但这样做似乎不足以防止由于怀疑不足而导致的审计失败。在美国、欧洲,甚至日本,会计行业目前面临的一个基本问题是审计中职业怀疑的质量。这个问题从根本上说是审计证据问题,它关系到审计人员对财务报表的怀疑程度和程度。换句话说,职业怀疑主义包含了审计师认知的以下两个方面:范围和深度。专业怀疑的范围方面涉及审计人员的断言框架,其中包括确定要审查的断言的基本性质(肯定和否定)和选择,以及如何审查和审查到什么程度。它基本上与注册会计师在开始证据收集过程之前应该(能够)采取何种方法(积极和/或消极)的认识和象征性处理方式有关,并在证据收集过程中作出反应。因此,审计中的职业怀疑在本质上是认识论的。一般来说,审计师确认的数字断言,无论是肯定的还是否定的,都反映了他们怀疑的范围。专业怀疑主义的深度方面与证据有关,对证据的能力做出评估性判断:相关性、质量(可靠性)和为审查特定断言而收集的数量。这一方面与注册会计师在特定审计环境中作出证据性判断时提出问题的倾向有关,并从根本上涉及衡量注册会计师质疑心理的深度。从这个意义上说,审计中的职业怀疑本质上是心理上的。换句话说,审计中的职业怀疑主义具有两重性,既适用于审计认知的认识论层面,也适用于审计认知的心理层面。注册会计师能否成功地履行其在财务报表审计中的鉴证职责,取决于他们能否成功地认识和行使职业怀疑的双重性质。因此,审计人员需要在这两个学科中发展技能。对职业怀疑主义的研究已经进行了一段时间,但几乎所有先前的(实证)研究都集中在第二个方面,特别是审计人员的心理特征对职业怀疑主义的影响。为什么?许多研究似乎是基于一种先入为主的观念,即只有肯定的方法(“证实断言”:确认)才能被接受为财务报表审计下的了解方式。然而,应该指出的是,在科学哲学中也认识到另一种认识方式,即消极方法(“主动寻找实质性错误陈述的消极迹象:证伪”)。在否定方法下,审计师更注重发现与否定断言相关的消极事例或迹象,从而形成合理的基础来证实其对财务报表公允列报的信念。本研究的主要目的是提出一个专业怀疑主义的概念框架,该框架充分考虑了其双重性质,以及审计文献中关于审计师与怀疑主义相关的心态的不同观点。从专业怀疑的角度来看,这一概念框架不仅可以显示当前审计实践被认为止步于何处,还可以显示审计实践可能朝哪个方向发展。少
英文摘要
An increasing number of arguments have been made on a national and an international level, both academically and practically, for more "professional skepticism in auditing." The internal and external environments surrounding independent auditors have resulted in an eroding of professional skepticism and have threatened to weaken society's trust in auditors. This erosion was observed in the early 1990s and strongly acknowledged by the accounting profession itself. Professional standards have long emphasized an appropriate degree of skepticism throughout the evidence process, which is composed of planning audit programs, performing the procedures, and evaluating the evidence. Auditors are expected to understand that the essence of skepticism is "raising a question" and "exhibiting a questioning mind," yet doing so does not seem to be enough to prevent audit failures resulting from insufficient skepticism.One of the basic issues facing the accounting profession in the US, Europe, and even … More in Japan at the moment is the quality of professional skepticism in auditing. This issue is fundamentally a matter of audit evidence and is concerned with the degree and extent to which auditors should doubt the financial statements. To put it another way, professional skepticism contains the following two facets of the auditor's cognition : the scope and depth. The scope facet of professional skepticism is concerned with the auditor's assertion-framing, which includes determining the basic nature (affirmative and negative) and selection of assertions to be scrutinized and how and to what extent. It is basically related to an auditor's way of knowing and symbolically deals with what approach (positive and/or negative) the auditor should (can) adopt initially prior to beginning the evidence gathering process, and reactively during the evidence gathering process. Thus, professional skepticism in auditing is epistemic in its nature. In general, the number assertions, positive and/or negative, the auditors recognize reflects the scope of their skepticism. The depth facet of professional skepticism is concerned with the evidence, making an evaluative judgment concerning its competence : the relevance, quality (reliability), and quantity to be collected for scrutinizing a particular assertion. This facet is related to the auditor's disposition to raise questions in making such an evidential judgment in a particular audit setting and fundamentally deals with measuring the depth of the auditor's questioning mind. In this sense, professional skepticism in auditing is psychological in nature. In other words, professional skepticism in auditing is dual in nature, applicable at both epistemic and psychological facets of audit cognition. Whether the auditors can successfully accomplish their assurance role under a financial statement audit depends on their success in recognizing and exercising the dual nature of professional skepticism. Auditors therefore need to develop skills in both disciplines. Research on professional skepticism has been in progress for some time, yet almost all prior (empirical) research on the subject has focused on the second facet, particularly on the effects of auditors' psychological traits on professional skepticism. Why? Many studies seem to have been based on a preconception that only an affirmative approach ("substantiating the assertions" : confirmation) can be accepted as the way of knowing under a financial statement audit.It should be noted, however, that another way of knowing is recognized in the philosophy of science, that is, a negative approach ("proactively looking for negative indications of material misstatements : falsification). Under a negative approach, auditors put more focus on uncovering negative instances or signs related to the negative assertions so that they can form a reasonable basis for corroborating their belief in the fair presentation of financial statements.The main objective of this research is to present a conceptual framework for professional skepticism which gives due consideration to its dual nature as well as different views recognized in the audit literature of the auditor's mindset related to skepticism. This conceptual framework can show, in terms of professional skepticism, not only where the current audit practice is considered to rest, but also in which direction the practice may be moving. Less
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
循環取引による加ト吉粉飾決算事件(上)
片吉循环交易诈骗结算案(一)
DOI: --
发表时间: 2011
期刊: 月刊 監査役
影响因子: --
作者: [明神実枝・清水信年, 吉村孝司, 鳥羽至英, 石井淳蔵, 鳥羽至英]
通讯作者: 鳥羽至英
循環取引による加ト吉粉飾決算事件(下)
片吉循环交易诈骗结算案(二)
DOI: --
发表时间: 2011
期刊: 月刊 監査役
影响因子: --
作者: [明神実枝・清水信年, 吉村孝司, 鳥羽至英, 石井淳蔵, 鳥羽至英, 阪本俊生, 吉村孝司, 上西充子(2012), 佐藤厚, 吉村孝司, 石井淳蔵, 大村英昭・井上俊, 吉村孝司, 上西充子, 鳥羽至英]
通讯作者: 鳥羽至英
Toward a Conceptual Framework of Professional Skepticism in Auditing.
走向审计专业怀疑主义的概念框架。
DOI: --
发表时间: 2011
期刊: The Waseda Business & Economics. The Graduate School of Commerce(Waseda University)
影响因子: --
作者: [上枝正幸, 上枝正幸(同志社大・田口聡志先生と共著), 高尾裕二, 高尾裕二, 高尾裕二, 上枝正幸, 上枝正幸・上条良夫, 高尾裕二, 椎葉淳・高尾裕二, 太郎丸博, 石井淳蔵, 石井淳蔵, 太郎丸博, 石井淳蔵, 佐藤一磨・梅崎修・中野貴之・上西充子, 吉村孝司, Yoshihide Toba, 太郎丸博, 横山斉理・高室裕史・水越康介, 中川知宏・林洋一郎・梅崎修, 野口道彦, 吉村孝司, 山中浩司, Yoshihide Toba]
通讯作者: Yoshihide Toba
監査の失敗と監査上の懐疑主義
审计失败和审计怀疑
DOI: --
发表时间: 2010
期刊: 商学研究科紀要(早稲田大学大学院商学研究科)
影响因子: --
作者: [明神実枝・清水信年, 吉村孝司, 鳥羽至英, 石井淳蔵, 鳥羽至英, 阪本俊生, 吉村孝司, 上西充子(2012), 佐藤厚, 吉村孝司, 石井淳蔵, 大村英昭・井上俊, 吉村孝司, 上西充子, 鳥羽至英, 大村英昭, 石井淳蔵, 吉村孝司, 鳥羽至英]
通讯作者: 鳥羽至英
共 9 条
    Independence in Appearance of the CPAs Expected in the Market-oriented Economy
    • 批准号:
      10630134
    • 项目类别:
      Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C)
    • 资助金额:
      $2.56万
    • 财政年份:
      1998
    • 负责人:
      TOBA Yoshihide
    • 依托单位: