Reply to “Comment on ‘Charge-Parity Symmetry Observed through Friedel Oscillations in Chiral Charge-Density Waves’”
Reply to “Comment on ‘Charge-Parity Symmetry Observed through Friedel Oscillations in Chiral Charge-Density Waves’”
复制标题
回复“评论‘通过手性电荷密度波中的弗里德尔振荡观察到的电荷宇称对称性’”
DOI：
10.1103/physrevb.86.247102
复制
发表时间：
2012
影响因子：
3.7
通讯作者：
M. Oda and S. Tanda
中科院分区：
文献类型：
--
作者：
J. Ishioka;T. Fujii;K. Katono;K. Ichimura;T. Kurosawa;M. Oda and S. Tanda
我们正在回应 J. Wezel 对我们论文的评论。这项研究是根据我们之前的工作 [Ishiokaet al., Phys.莱特牧师。 105, 176401 (2010)10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.176401]。在PRL论文中，首次定义了表达CDW手性的新参数。在他的评论中，他声称这是不明确的。他还声称，CDW 波函数的初始相位是表达手性 CDW 的更合适的参数，尽管我们早期介绍了 PRL 论文中描述的实验数据。然而，我们得出的结论是，可以通过其符号来区分CDW手性。此外，通过考虑不同的符号，我们成功地证明了 CDW 空间分布的差异，如 PRB 论文 [Phys. 2017] 的图 4 所示。修订版 B 84, 245125 (2011)PRBMDO1098-012110.1103/PhysRevB.84.245125]。在我们的答复中，我们讨论了其有效性。我们证明了他关于用 q 的相反符号来识别 CDW 的论点是错误的，因为该逻辑不适用于非零的波函数。我们还讨论了过渡金属二硫属化物中二维或三维 CDW 的适用性。
We are responding to the Comment by J. Wezel on our paper. This study was developed from our previous work [Ishiokaet al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 176401 (2010)10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.176401]. In the PRL paper,was defined as a new parameter for expressing CDW chirality for the first time. In his Comment, he claims thatis ill defined. He also claims that the initial phaseof the CDW wave function is a more appropriate parameter for expressing chiral CDW, despite our early introduction ofto explain the experimental data described in the PRL paper. However, we conclude thatcan distinguish the CDW chirality by its sign. Moreover, by considering differentsigns, we had succeeded in demonstrating the difference of the spatial distributions of CDWs as shown in Fig. 4 of the PRB paper [Phys. Rev. B 84, 245125 (2011)PRBMDO1098-012110.1103/PhysRevB.84.245125]. In our Reply, we discuss the validity of. We show that his argument regarding the identification of the CDW with the opposite sign of q is wrong, since the logic is inapplicable to a wave function with a nonzero. We also discuss the applicability ofto two- or three-dimensional CDWs in transition metal dichalcogenides.