Investigating the Effects of Socioscientific Argumentation Development on Student Academic Success
Investigating the Effects of Socioscientific Argumentation Development on Student Academic Success
批准号:
1623371
负责人:
Hector Torres
金额:
$34.99万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016-07-01 至 2021-06-30
中文摘要
白求恩-库克曼大学正在研究社会科学论证学习和发展对学生在STEM领域取得成功的影响。该研究的总体目的是研究如何培养具有论证专业知识的STEM毕业生,以解决结构不良的问题,这些问题需要科学的、基于证据的推理来为决策提供信息。研究人员将围绕以科学问题为重点的生物和环境科学课程单元构建干预,并进行三阶段的研究。第一阶段试点将确定STEM学生目前的论证水平,并分析试点数据,以确定有效的社会科学论证发展的差距。在第二阶段,研究人员将为学生开发和调整社会科学论证学习训练系统。第三阶段将是一项实验研究,以调查社会科学论证训练对学生成绩的影响。这项研究的意义在于,研究结果可用于为学生提供研究生院或STEM劳动力所需的技能和能力;也就是说,证据的评估,论点的构建,和竞争性论点的评估。研究人员将使用准实验设计来回答三个研究问题:1)学生目前使用什么社会科学论证策略?2)有效的社会科学论证存在哪些差距?3)社会科学论证教学是否影响学生的学习成绩?在第一阶段,他们将在食物、能源和水的关系中使用社会科学问题进行问卷调查、书面报告和辩论,以收集有关学生决策过程、参与辩论的倾向、辩论水平和辩论结构质量的数据。研究人员将使用几种规则和社会科学论证模型来分析第一阶段收集的数据。然后,他们建议对干预组和对照组之间关于社会科学问题的争论的质量进行前后比较。学生学业成功的衡量标准将从学业成就、职业成功、学习成果的获得、坚持、技能和能力的获得以及满意度等方面进行评估。该研究将提供开发干预模型所需的信息,以提高STEM学生的科学论证技能发展。本项目由历史上的黑人学院和大学本科项目(HBCU-UP)扩大参与教育研究项目支持。该项目支持创建和研究STEM教学和学习的新模式和创新的想法,调查影响代表性不足群体学生的差异参与和成功率的潜在问题,并为STEM教育实践和干预提供知识。
英文摘要
Bethune-Cookman University is examining the effects of socioscientific argumentation learning and development on student success in STEM. The overarching purpose of the research is to investigate how to produce STEM graduates with argumentation expertise to address ill-structured problems that require scientific, evidence-based reasoning to inform decisions. The researchers will structure an intervention around units of biology and environmental science courses focused on scientific issues and conduct a three-phase research study. The Phase I pilot will determine the current argumentation level of STEM students and analyze the pilot data to identify gaps in effective socioscientific argumentation development. In Phase II, the researchers will develop and adapt a socioscientific argumentation learning training system for students. Phase III will be an experimental study to investigate the effect of socioscientific argumentation training on student outcomes. The significance of the study is that the findings can be used to provide students with skills and competencies needed for graduate school or the STEM workforce; namely, evaluation of evidence, construction of arguments, and evaluation of competing arguments.The researchers will use a quasi-experimental design to answer three research questions: 1) What socioscientific argumentation strategies do the students currently use? 2) What gaps exist in effective socioscientific argumentation? 3) Does socioscientific argumentation instruction influence student outcomes? In Phase 1, they will use socioscientific issues at the nexus of food, energy, and water for questionnaires, written reports, and debates to collect data on students' decision-making process, tendency to engage in arguments, argumentation levels, and quality of argumentative structures. The researchers will use several rubrics and socioscientific argumentation models to analyze data collected in Phase 1. They then propose to conduct a pre- and post- comparison of the quality of arguments on socioscientific issues between intervention and comparison groups. Measures of student academic success will be assessed from the dimensions of academic achievement, career success, attainment of learning outcomes, persistence, acquisition of skills and competencies, and satisfaction. The research will produce information needed to develop intervention models for improving scientific argumentation skills development of STEM students. This project is supported by the Historically Black Colleges and Universities Undergraduate Program (HBCU-UP) Broadening Participation Research in Education track. This program track supports ideas to create and study new models and innovations in STEM teaching and learning, investigate the underlying issues affecting the differential participation and success rates of students from underrepresented groups, and produce knowledge to inform STEM education practices and interventions.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Collaborative Research: Developing Online Laboratories for Computer Science Students to Learn How to Build Accessible Software and to Use Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning
-
批准号:2111108
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$7.89万
-
财政年份:2021
-
负责人:Hector Torres
-
依托单位:
国内基金
海外基金
Dynamic Credit Rating with Feedback Effects
-
批准号:--
-
项目类别:外国学者研究基金项目
-
资助金额:--
-
批准年份:2024
-
负责人:Christian Martin Hilpert
-
依托单位:
水环境中新兴污染物类抗生素效应(Like-Antibiotic Effects,L-AE)作用机制研究
-
批准号:21477024
-
项目类别:面上项目
-
资助金额:86.0万元
-
批准年份:2014
-
负责人:李丹
-
依托单位: