Perceptions of Trust and Procedural Justice as Sources of Receptivity and Resistance to Video Surveillance
Perceptions of Trust and Procedural Justice as Sources of Receptivity and Resistance to Video Surveillance
批准号:
1625808
负责人:
Terance Miethe
金额:
$27.6万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016-09-15 至 2018-12-31
中文摘要
前所未有的对警察与公民之间负面冲突的视频报道引发了内乱,并引发了公众对警察和刑事司法系统信任的质疑。 当警察被积极看待时(例如,公平、公正、值得信赖),以前的研究表明,公众对他们的支持很强。 然而,在过去的十年里,美国主要社会变革的趋同(例如,视频技术的广泛应用,以捕捉警察暴力和滥用权力的图像,日益扩大的种族分歧,以及对社会机构的信心下降)挑战了公平和信任足以产生积极的警察-公民关系的概念。 拟议的研究将进行一次大规模的全国性调查和全市范围的采访,以测试这些想法的影响,公众对官员的行为,制度失范,程序正义和警察的合法性的警察-公民关系和支持“视频警务”活动,通过使用随身携带的相机和空中无人机。 在后弗格森时期的种族仇恨和紧张的警民关系中,所获得的调查结果将提供“最佳做法”的直接证据,以改善公众对各种警察做法的支持,并制定一种更细致入微的社区警务方法,更有效地控制犯罪,促进更好的警民关系,特别是在少数族裔社区,对警察的基本信任可能是最成问题的。通过探讨当代美国社会公众对程序正义和警察合法性的看法对他们支持视频警务活动的影响,所提出的研究与现存的研究不同之处在于其(1)关注公众对警察使用发展中的视频技术的支持(例如,佩戴在身上的摄像机,空中无人机),(2)对警察公平性和合法性的看法的影响是否受到一个人的种族,与警察的直接经历和他们的负面视频图像,警察活动的类型(例如,主动与被动警务)和制度失范的感觉,以及(3)分析方法(即,使用合取分析来研究这种因果复杂性)。 这项研究的结果将通过确定警察可以使用移动的视频技术的特定条件(即,身体摄像机和空中无人机),以提高社区安全和支持,降低公众阻力。 它还将确定视频技术被视为侵入性,无效和/或选择性(错误)使用的条件,从而侵蚀这种公共安全和支持。
英文摘要
Unprecedented video coverage of negative police-citizen encounters has fueled civil unrest and questions about the public trust in police and the criminal justice system. When the police are viewed positively (e.g., fair, impartial, trustworthy), previous research reveals strong public support for them. Over the last decade, however, the convergence of major social changes in the U.S. (e.g., the wider availability of video technology to capture images of police violence and abuse of power, the growing racial divide, and declining confidence in social institutions) challenge this notion that fairness and trust are enough to produce positive police-citizen relations. The proposed study will conduct a large national survey and citywide interviews to test these ideas about the impact of public perceptions of officer conduct, institutional anomie, procedural justice, and police legitimacy on police-citizen relations and support for "video policing" activities through the use of body-worn cameras and aerial drones. In this post-Ferguson period of racial animus and strained police-citizen relations, the obtained survey results will provide direct evidence of the "best practices" for improving public support for various police practices and developing a more nuanced approach to community policing that is more effective in crime control and fosters better police-citizen relations, especially in minority neighborhoods where basic trust in police may be most problematic.By exploring the impact of public perceptions about procedural justice and police legitimacy on their support for video policing activities in contemporary American society, the proposed study departs from extant research by its (1) focus on public support for police use of evolving video technology (e.g., body-worn cameras, aerial drones), (2) empirical evaluation of whether the influence of perceptions of police fairness and legitimacy are highly contextual, mediated or moderated by one's race, direct experiences with police and negative video images of them, the type of police activity (e.g., proactive versus reactive policing) and feelings of institutional anomie, and (3) analytic methods (i.e., the use conjunctive analysis to study this causal complexity). The results of this study will provide direct social benefits by identifying particular conditions under which police can use mobile video technology (i.e., body cameras and aerial drones) to increase community safety and support with lower public resistance. It will also identify conditions under which video technology is viewed as invasive, ineffective and/or selectively (mis)used, thereby eroding this public safety and support.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Public Evaluations of Legal Disputes: A Study of Causes andConsequences
-
批准号:9121940
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$0.0万
-
财政年份:1992
-
负责人:Terance Miethe
-
依托单位:
Public Evaluations of Legal Disputes: A Study of Causes andConsequences
-
批准号:9296170
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$6.54万
-
财政年份:1992
-
负责人:Terance Miethe
-
依托单位:
Opportunity, Choice, and Social Control: Testing an Integrated Theory of Criminal Victimization
-
批准号:8821407
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$19.04万
-
财政年份:1989
-
负责人:Terance Miethe
-
依托单位:
海外基金