课题基金 / 基金详情

Assessing the Influence of Hazard Mitigation Planning on Disaster Recovery

Assessing the Influence of Hazard Mitigation Planning on Disaster Recovery
评估减灾计划对灾难恢复的影响
批准号:
1760183
负责人:
Ward Lyles
金额:
$39.98万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2019
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2019-03-01 至 2024-02-29

项目摘要

项目成果

Ward Lyles的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
这一研究项目填补了关于灾前减灾规划对灾后恢复的影响以及减少飓风和洪水等自然灾害的长期风险的关键知识空白。常识认为,在重大灾难发生前进行的减灾规划应有助于减少灾害影响并影响恢复,包括决策者是否利用灾后打开的机会之窗来避免重复过去的决定,例如将开发集中在增加长期风险的泛滥平原。该项目克服了以前限制对减灾规划和恢复决策之间联系的研究的两个障碍:1)缺乏关于减灾规划的全面数据集;2)现有的数据集不涵盖重大灾害受灾地区。研究小组之前在北卡罗来纳州以及飓风马修和佛罗伦萨的工作提供了独特的机会,通过首先收集关于灾后恢复决策的数据、规划文件等产出以及引导发展远离已知危险地点的决定等结果,消除这两个障碍。其次,在定量分析和案例研究中,将这些恢复数据与研究人员在本世纪初关于减灾的数据结合起来。除了新的科学知识外,研究活动还将产生及时和新颖的政策和实践相关信息,扩大纵向和比较分析所需的数据集的基础,并加强危害研究界。因此,这项科学研究贡献支持了NSF促进科学进步和增进我们国家福利的使命。从理论上讲,灾前减灾规划可以通过以下方式改进灾后决策:1)通过促进当地利益相关者的协作网络来改善当地决策过程;2)生成计划,组织信息并确定降低长期风险的优先方法;3)增加实施当地优先考虑的减灾方法,包括禁止在洪泛区重建和恢复湿地等非结构性方法。飓风马修和佛罗伦萨创造了一个自然实验,与作为2000年《减灾法》国家评估的一部分而产生的减灾规划的多维数据集相一致。该项目的主要假设是,与灾前减灾工作质量较低的社区相比,具有较高质量的灾前减灾规划和实施的社区将减少灾害影响,并将更好地利用灾后机会窗口,在恢复过程中采用非结构性减灾办法。这项拟议的研究将通过对缓解和恢复文件的内容分析、对主要利益攸关方的调查和访谈、对配对的病例县的实地访问以及从二手来源收集关于飓风恢复期间的决策、规划产出和规划结果的数据。多元回归模型将确定事前减灾和灾后恢复决策、产出和结果之间关系的强度和方向,控制外部和内部影响,如灾害强度和社会脆弱性。详细的案例研究将补充和扩展回归建模产生的知识,方法是检查当地冠军企业在促进当地利益相关者和决策者对非结构性缓解的支持方面所起的作用,并对缓解方法(例如非结构性和结构性)的事前实施中的差异是否与减少破坏和干扰相关进行细粒度分析。该奖项反映了NSF的法定使命,并通过使用基金会的智力优势和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估,被认为值得支持。
英文摘要
This research project fills a critical gap in knowledge about the influence of pre-disaster hazard mitigation planning on post-disaster recovery, and reductions in long-term risk from natural hazards like hurricanes and floods. Common sense holds that mitigation planning done before a major disaster should help reduce disaster impacts and shape recovery, including whether decision-makers leverage the window of opportunity that opens after a disaster to avoid repeating decisions from the past such as concentrating development in floodplains that increase long-term risk. This project overcomes two barriers that have previously limited research on linkages between mitigation planning and recovery decision-making: 1) lack of comprehensive datasets on hazard mitigation planning and 2) datasets that do exist do not cover areas hit by major disasters. The research team's prior work in North Carolina and with Hurricanes Matthew and Florence provide unique opportunities to resolve both barriers by first collecting data on post-disaster recovery decision making, outputs like planning documents, and outcomes like decisions to steer development out of known hazardous locations. And second, coupling these recovery data with the researchers' data on hazard mitigation from earlier in the 2000s in quantitative analysis and case studies. In addition to new scientific knowledge, the research activities will generate timely and novel policy and practice-relevant information, extend the foundation of datasets needed for longitudinal and comparative analyses, and strengthen the hazards research community. This scientific research contribution thus supports NSF's mission to promote the progress of science and to advance our national welfare. In this case, the benefits will be insights to improve community planning and mitigation for disasters which can save lives and reduce economic losses.Theoretically, pre-disaster hazard mitigation planning can improve post-disaster decision-making by 1) improving local decision-making processes by fostering a collaborative network of local stakeholders, 2) generating plans that organize information and prioritize approaches to reduce long-term risks, and 3) increasing implementation of locally prioritized mitigation approaches, including non-structural approaches like prohibiting rebuilding in floodplains and restoring wetlands. Hurricanes Matthew and Florence create a natural experiment aligning with a multi-dimensional dataset on hazard mitigation planning generating as part of a national evaluation of the Disaster Mitigation Act of 2000. The overarching hypothesis for this project is that communities with higher quality pre-disaster hazard mitigation planning and implementation will have reduced disaster impacts, and will better capitalize on the post-disaster window of opportunity to pursue non-structural mitigation approaches in recovery than communities with lower quality pre-disaster hazard mitigation efforts. This proposed research will collect data on decision making, planning outputs, and planning outcomes during hurricane recovery through content analysis of mitigation and recovery documents, surveys and interviews with key stakeholders, field visits to matched pairs of case counties, and from secondary sources. Multivariate regression modeling will identify the strength and directions of relationships between pre-event hazard mitigation and post-disaster recovery decision-making, outputs, and outcomes, controlling for the external and internal influences, such as hazard intensity and social vulnerability. Detailed case studies will complement and extend the knowledge generated from the regression modeling by examining the role of local champions in advancing support for non-structural mitigation among local stakeholders and decision-makers and conducting fine-grained analysis of whether variation in pre-event implementation of mitigation approaches (e.g. non-structural vs. structural) was associated with reduced damage and disruption.This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
CAREER: Integrated Modeling of Hazard Mitigation Stakeholder Networks for Compassionate, Sustainable Risk Reduction
海外基金