Collaborative Research: Dealing with Disruption: Investigating the Micro-level Underpinnings of City Response to the Climate Crisis

合作研究：应对破坏：调查城市应对气候危机的微观基础

• 批准号: 2049917
• 负责人: Rachel Krause
• 金额: $ 20.39万
• 依托单位: University of Kansas Center for Research Inc
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Continuing Grant
• 财政年份: 2021
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2021-04-01 至 2025-03-31
• 项目状态: 未结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=2049917&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Collaborative; Research; Dealing; Disruption; Investigating

Municipalities are grappling with myriad complex challenges linked to the changing climate. Their responses to anticipated but uncertain disruptions exist on a continuum, from inaction to transformative change that fundamentally alters an urban system. We do not know enough about the factors leading cities to more or less transformative responses, inhibiting efforts to tackle such disturbances. To address this challenge, we propose the networked micro-decision context (NMDC), an arena where individuals involved in determining a policy response confer, negotiate, and act. This research assesses how two key dimensions of the NMDC—the composition of its actors and the flexibility of its structure—affect the transformative potential of governance. Via the administration and analysis of a nation-wide survey, qualitative cases studies, and social network analyses, this research yields insight into the potentially nuanced ways composition and structure affect the transformativeness of a city’s approach to disruptions linked to the climate crisis. Climate-induced disruptions share similarities with other mounting social challenges in that they are highly complex, affect multiple economic and governmental sectors, and are characterized by substantial resource interdependencies. As such, lessons this research produces can help understand and improve governance responses to other societal disruptions. This research examines and predicts when and how local governments pursue decision processes theoretically linked to a greater likelihood of transformative policy outcomes. In so doing, the research establishes the networked micro-decision context, which constitutes the micro-level, relational underpinnings of aggregate government behavior. The diversity of NMDC participants, the flexibility of its structure, and the presence of policy entrepreneurs are hypothesized as determinants of transformative governance, which is characterized by learning-focused, proactive, and risk-accepting processes. The research team leverages a mixed-methods approach to develop theory and test its generalizability, proceeding in three phases: (1) a large-n quantitative analysis, involving a nationwide survey and collection of secondary-source data; (2) in-depth case studies of 16 cities, employing interviews and archival analysis; and (3) a detailed social network analysis of the interactions that comprise the NMDC within those 16 cities. The network analysis is be coupled with the survey and interview-based findings to evaluate how a city’s likelihood of pursuing transformative governance processes around climate-related disruptions is affected by the NMDC’s balance between diversity and social cohesion; the position of climate policy entrepreneurs in the NMDC; and the NMDC’s diversity (organizationally and individually) and flexibility (operationalized as trust and fungibility).This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.

各国正在努力应对与气候变化有关的无数复杂挑战。他们对预期但不确定的破坏的反应是连续的，从不采取行动到从根本上改变城市系统的变革性变化。我们对导致城市做出或多或少变革性反应的因素了解不够，这些因素阻碍了应对此类干扰的努力。为了应对这一挑战，我们提出了网络化的微观决策环境（NMDC），一个竞技场，参与确定政策反应的个人进行协商，谈判和行动。本研究评估了NMDC的两个关键方面-其行为体的组成和结构的灵活性-如何影响治理的变革潜力。通过管理和全国范围内的调查，定性案例研究和社会网络分析的分析，本研究产生洞察到潜在的细微差别的方式组成和结构影响城市的方法与气候危机中断的转变。气候引起的破坏与其他日益严重的社会挑战有着相似之处，因为它们非常复杂，影响到多个经济和政府部门，并且具有资源相互依赖的特点。因此，这项研究产生的经验教训可以帮助理解和改善对其他社会破坏的治理反应。本研究探讨和预测地方政府何时以及如何追求决策过程，理论上与更大的可能性变革性的政策结果。在这样做的过程中，研究建立了网络化的微观决策环境，它构成了微观层面，关系基础的总体政府行为。NMDC参与者的多样性，其结构的灵活性，以及政策企业家的存在被假设为变革性治理的决定因素，其特点是以学习为中心，积极主动，并接受风险的过程。研究团队采用混合方法，分三个阶段进行理论发展和检验其可推广性：（1）大规模的定量分析，包括全国范围的调查和二手资料的收集;（2）深入16个城市的案例研究，采用访谈和档案分析;以及（3）对这16个城市中NMDC的互动进行详细的社会网络分析。网络分析与基于调查和访谈的结果相结合，以评估一个城市围绕气候相关中断追求变革性治理过程的可能性如何受到NMDC在多样性和社会凝聚力之间的平衡的影响;气候政策企业家在NMDC中的地位;和NMDC的多样性（组织和个人）和灵活性该奖项反映了NSF的法定使命，并通过使用基金会的知识价值和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估，被认为值得支持。

项目成果

What is the Future of Survey-Based Data Collection for Local Government Research? Trends, Strategies, and Recommendations

地方政府研究基于调查的数据收集的未来是什么？

• DOI: 10.1177/10780874231175837
• 发表时间: 2023
• 期刊: Urban Affairs Review
• 影响因子: 2.1
• 作者: Krause, Rachel M.;Fatemi, S. Mohsen;Nguyen Long, Le Anh;Arnold, Gwen;Hofmeyer, Sarah L.
• 通讯作者: Hofmeyer, Sarah L.