Collaborative Research: Using Causal Explanations and Computation to Understand Misplaced Beliefs
Collaborative Research: Using Causal Explanations and Computation to Understand Misplaced Beliefs
批准号:
2146983
负责人:
Jessecae Marsh
金额:
$36.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2022
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
未结题
起止时间:
2022-06-01 至 2025-05-31
中文摘要
因果解释为事件发生的原因提供了答案。对因果解释的信念(例如,投资新技术将导致您可用于退休的资金增加)指导着未来从事哪些行为(例如,投资加密货币)。但人们可以--而且经常这样做--相信对世界的因果解释是错误的。理解不正确的因果解释的本质使其可信,对于教人们拒绝对事件的错误解释至关重要。在这项工作中,PI调查了是什么对人们感兴趣的事件做出了不正确的因果解释,以及是什么鼓励了这些错位的信念的采用。持有错误的因果解释可能会产生严重的破坏性影响,比如人们追求无效的健康治疗,或者投资于没有回报的财务策略。因此,重要的是要更好地理解是什么让不正确的因果解释具有吸引力,以便部署策略来抵消它们的采用。在这项工作中,PI进行了一系列研究,以提供对因果解释本质上使其具有吸引力的强烈理解。通过研究,PI探索了许多不同的解释原因。然后,PI利用他们的结果进行初步尝试,以减少对不正确的因果解释的认可。这项研究通过让学生参与具有很强翻译成分的研究,对科学产生了更广泛的影响。这样的研究帮助学生将科学与现实世界联系起来,培养他们对科学和批判性思维的兴趣。此外,这项拟议的工作将通过隔离科学解释中可能或多或少让人相信的东西,对科学素养产生更广泛的影响。PI使用因果解释文献中的心理学方法来研究对大量错位和不正确的因果解释的看法。这些方法包括让人们阅读解释,并对解释的说服力、满意度和可信度进行评分。此外,这些研究的参与者还对解释的因果结构做出判断,例如解释包括多少因果因素,解释有多复杂,以及解释可以解释多少事件。PI使用大量的在线参与者样本,以确保有许多不同信仰的人被包括在研究中。在每项研究中,PI让参与者对不正确的因果解释(例如,“吃糖是2型糖尿病的主要原因”)以及对相同事件的基于事实的因果解释(例如,“2型糖尿病有多种原因,包括超重和遗传易感性”)进行评级。这种比较可以隔离错位解释的独特之处。使用机器学习,研究人员调查了事实和错误信息解释的特征结构在多大程度上超越了它们被感知的方式(例如,因果结构的复杂性),这可能允许在这些解释类型之间进行更自动的区分。最后,PI利用他们的发现创建了一组行为研究,在其中他们改变了解释的呈现方式,以探索呈现对解释认可的影响程度。具体地说,PI创建了新的因果解释,操纵了最能预测早期实验中支持不正确的因果信念的因果元素(例如,复杂性、因果因素的数量)。其目的是看看通过改变这些重要的因果因素,是否可以减少对不正确信念的认可。通过这些研究,我们可以更全面地了解如何防止错误信息被吸收,以支持基于事实的解释。这一奖项反映了NSF的法定使命,并通过使用基金会的智力优势和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估,被认为值得支持。
英文摘要
Causal explanations provide answers to why an event happened. Beliefs in causal explanations (for example, investing in new technologies will cause your available money for retirement to increase) guide which behaviors to engage in for the future (e.g., invest in crypto-currency). But people can – and often do – believe causal explanations of the world that are wrong. Understanding what in the nature of an incorrect causal explanation makes it believable is critically important for teaching people to reject incorrect explanations of events. In this work, the PIs investigate what makes incorrect causal explanations of events appealing to people and what encourages the adoption of these misplaced beliefs. Holding incorrect causal explanations can have critically damaging effects, such as people pursuing health treatments that are ineffective or investing in financial strategies that do not pay out. It is therefore important to better understand what makes incorrect causal explanations appealing so strategies can be deployed to counteract their adoption. In the work, the PIs conduct a series of studies to provide a strong understanding of what in the nature of a causal explanation makes it appealing. Across studies, the PIs explore many different causal elements of explanations. Using their results, the PIs then make a preliminary attempt to reduce endorsement of incorrect causal explanations. This research has a broader impact on science by involving students in research that has a strong translational component. Such research helps students connect science to the real-world, growing their interest in science and critical thinking at large. Additionally, the proposed work will have broader impacts on science literacy by isolating what in scientific explanations may make them more or less likely to be believed. The PIs use psychological methods from the causal explanation literature to study perceptions of a wide range of misplaced and incorrect causal explanations. These methods include having people read explanations and rate how compelling, satisfying, and believable the explanations are. In addition, participants in these studies make judgments about the causal structure of the explanations, such as how many causal factors the explanations include, how complex the explanations are, and how many events the explanations can explain. The PIs use large samples of online participants to ensure that people with many different beliefs are being included in the studies. In each study, the PIs have participants rate incorrect causal explanations (e.g., “eating sugar is the main cause of type 2 diabetes”) as well as fact-based causal explanations of the same events (e.g., “type 2 diabetes has multiple causes, including being overweight and having a genetic predisposition”). This comparison allows for isolation of what is unique about misplaced explanations. Using machine learning, the researchers investigate the degree to which there are characteristic structures of factual and misinformation explanations, beyond how they are perceived (e.g., the complexity of causal structure), which may allow for more automatic differentiation between these explanation types. Finally, the PIs use their findings to create a set of behavioral studies where they alter how explanations are presented to explore the degree to which presentation impacts endorsement of the explanations. Specifically, the PIs create new causal explanations that manipulate the causal elements that were most predictive of endorsement for incorrect causal beliefs in earlier experiments (e.g., complexity, number of causal factors). The goal is to see if by changing these important causal elements, endorsement of incorrect beliefs can be reduced. Through these studies we can learn more generally how to prevent the uptake of incorrect information in favor of fact-based explanations.This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
SCH: INT: Collaborative Research: Uniting Causal and Mental Models for Shared Decision-Making in Diabetes
-
批准号:1915210
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$28.19万
-
财政年份:2019
-
负责人:Jessecae Marsh
-
依托单位:
国内基金
海外基金
登录
查看更多内容
Research on Quantum Field Theory without a Lagrangian Description
-
批准号:24ZR1403900
-
项目类别:省市级项目
-
资助金额:--
-
批准年份:2024
-
负责人:SATOSHI NAWATA
-
依托单位:
Cell Research
-
批准号:31224802
-
项目类别:专项基金项目
-
资助金额:24.0万元
-
批准年份:2012
-
负责人:程磊
-
依托单位:
Cell Research
-
批准号:31024804
-
项目类别:专项基金项目
-
资助金额:24.0万元
-
批准年份:2010
-
负责人:程磊
-
依托单位:
Cell Research (细胞研究)
-
批准号:30824808
-
项目类别:专项基金项目
-
资助金额:24.0万元
-
批准年份:2008
-
负责人:张爱兰
-
依托单位:
Research on the Rapid Growth Mechanism of KDP Crystal
-
批准号:10774081
-
项目类别:面上项目
-
资助金额:45.0万元
-
批准年份:2007
-
负责人:滕冰
-
依托单位: