Fundamental Studies on the Judgment and Reasoning of the International Court of Justice as Viewed from its Judgment Formation Process

从判决形​​成过程看国际法院判决与推理的基础研究

• 批准号: 17203005
• 负责人: OKUWAKI Naoya
• 金额: $ 20.47万
• 依托单位: The University of Tokyo
• 依托单位国家: 日本
• 项目类别: Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (A)
• 财政年份: 2005
• 资助国家: 日本
• 起止时间: 2005 至 2007
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://kaken.nii.ac.jp/en/grant/KAKENHI-PROJECT-17203005/
• 关键词: International Adjudication; International Court of Justice; International Dispute Settlement; Law of International Adjudication; Judgment Formation Process; 国際司法裁判所; 国際裁判手続法; 国際紛争; 判決理由; 多数意見; 反対意見

The objective of the present research was to invite Shigeru Oda, former Judge of the International Court of Justice, and to study the process of how judgments of international tribunals are formed. In pursuit of this aim, through case studies, we have studied the procedure of the court from the “inside", so to speak, focusing on how the Judges perceived the context of the conflict, how the perception was maintained/modified by collegial deliberation, how this was reflected in the operative part of the judgment, and how this has lead the ICJ to a conclusion that would have a large possibility of substantially contributing to the settlement of the dispute. Moreover, we reached many findings and common understandings on how the arguments of the conflicting parties(arguments of Agents and Counsels) and the manner the judges digested them has influenced the preparation of the judgment in each cases. As of the present, we are preparing our contributions by reorganizing the result of our case studies according to topics in judicial procedure. A book with the provisional title of “The Law and Procedure of International Tribunals" is planned for publication this year, and the deadline for the contribution is set at July 30th of this year. The book will include a case-by-case analysis section that will briefly organize the result of the case studies, to provide greater understanding of the multifaceted aspects of the judgment formation processes of international tribunals. As byproducts of the study, much of the findings gained from the research activities of the study group have already been published as research presentations and articles by individual members.

本研究的目的是邀请前国际法院法官小田茂，研究国际法庭的判决是如何形成的过程。为了实现这一目标，我们通过案例研究，从“内部”研究了法院的程序，也就是说，侧重于法官如何感知冲突的背景，这种感知如何通过合议维持/修改，这如何反映在判决的执行部分，以及这如何导致国际法院得出一个有很大可能对解决争端作出实质性贡献的结论。此外，我们就冲突各方的论点（代理人和律师的论点）以及法官消化论点的方式如何影响每个案件的判决准备达成了许多结论和共同理解。截至目前，我们正在根据司法程序的主题重组我们的案例研究结果，以准备我们的贡献。一本暂定名为《国际法庭的法律与程序》的书计划于今年出版，投稿截止日期为今年7月30日。这本书将包括一个个案分析部分，将简要地组织案例研究的结果，以提供对国际法庭判决形成过程的多方面的更深入的了解。作为这项研究的副产品，从研究小组的研究活动中获得的许多发现已经作为研究报告和个人成员的文章发表。

项目成果

国際司法裁判所の紛争解決機能に関する-考察

关于国际法院争端解决职能的考虑

• 发表时间: 2008
• 期刊: 大沼保昭先生還暦記念論文集 (掲載確定)
• 作者: 徐 勝;松野周治;夏 剛編;奥脇直也;村瀬信也;河野真理子;河野真理子;河野真理子
• 通讯作者: 河野真理子

国際法へのコモン・ロー法律家的アプロウチと9.11後のアラカルト多国間主義

普通法律师对待国际法和 9/11 后单点多边主义的态度

• 发表时间: 2007
• 期刊: アメリカ法 2006年号
• 作者: 小寺彰;奥脇直也;植木俊哉;植木俊哉;植木俊哉;河野真理子;クレィグ・グリーン(佐藤義明訳);佐藤義明
• 通讯作者: 佐藤義明

元国際司法裁判所裁判官・小田滋先生に聞く(3)

前国际法院法官小田茂访谈（3）

• 发表时间: 2006
• 期刊: 『書斎の窓』(有斐閣) No. 553
• 作者: 小田滋;河野真理子;酒井啓亘
• 通讯作者: 酒井啓亘

Kokusaishihousaibansho: Cameroon-Nigeria Riku-Kaiyo Kyokai Jiken

Kokusaishihousaibansho：喀麦隆-尼日利亚Riku-Kaiyo Kyokai Jiken

• 发表时间: 2006
• 期刊: Syuyou na Ryouikikizoku Kyokaifunsou ni kansuru Kokusaihanreishiryo
• 作者: 小田滋;河野真理子;酒井啓亘;Naoya OKUWAKI;Naoya OKUWAKI
• 通讯作者: Naoya OKUWAKI

Toushikyoutei no Shinkyokumen to Nihon (1)

东京都新京门至日本 (1)

• 发表时间: 2006
• 期刊: Kokusai Shouji Houmu vol. 34, no. 8
• 作者: 小田滋;河野真理子;酒井啓亘;Naoya OKUWAKI;Naoya OKUWAKI;Naoya OKUWAKI;Shinya MURASE;Akira KOTERA (co-authored)
• 通讯作者: Akira KOTERA (co-authored)