psychiatrical study on quontative standard regarding to the accuseds' statements in psychiatric expert testimony

精神病学专家证言中被告人陈述定量标准的精神病学研究

• 批准号: 07459005
• 负责人: ODA Susumu
• 金额: $ 4.42万
• 依托单位: International University of Health and Welfare (1997)University of Tsukuba (1995-1996)
• 依托单位国家: 日本
• 项目类别: Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B)
• 财政年份: 1996
• 资助国家: 日本
• 起止时间: 1996 至 1997
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://kaken.nii.ac.jp/grant/KAKENHI-PROJECT-07459005/
• 关键词: statement psychology; psychiatric expert testimony; credibility of statements; MMPI; MINI; linguistical analysis; malingering; Grice's cord; 精神鑑定; 心理テスト; 供述; 虚偽; 空想傾向人格

A basic study was made on evaluation of credibility of the acuseds' statements in psychiatric expert testimony. The results were as follows. 1) On the quantatiye, objective evaluation of the accuseds' statements of the subjects which were inconsistent with Grice's Cord of the true statements were a) rejection b) protest, jeer to the examiner c) abstract statements regarding to the subjects of inquisition d) over-elabolated particulation e) correction, and restatement f) unpleasant reaction g) expression of repentance and h) expression of inference2) Regarding to the evaluation of credibility of the accuseds' statements adopting psychological tests and reaction time, MMPI and it's shortend edition MIPI,the reliability scales, L.F.K.and F-K index were proven to be effective to detect malingering and false statements.

对精神病鉴定中被告人陈述的可信度评价进行了初步研究。结果如下。1)对被控人陈述中与格赖斯陈述的真实性相矛盾的定量、客观评价是：a）拒绝B）抗议、嘲笑讯问者c）关于讯问对象的抽象陈述d）过度抽象的陈述e）纠正，和重述f）不愉快的反应g）忏悔的表达和h）推理的表达2）在采用心理测验和反应时评定被告人陈述的可信度方面，采用MMPI及其简化版MIPI、信度量表、L.F.K.和F-K指数被证明是有效的检测伪装和虚假陈述。

项目成果

小田 晋、佐藤 親次、森田 辰彰: "宗教と社会精神病理-その関連と現状-" 日本社会精神医学会雑誌. 5巻1号. 15-28 (1996)

Susumu Oda、Shinji Sato、Tatsuaki Morita：“宗教与社会精神病理学 - 它们的关系和现状”日本社会精神病学学会杂志，第 5 卷，第 1. 15-28 期（1996 年）。

小田 晋: "精神鑑定ケースブック" 青工社(単著), 1-411 (1997)

Susumu Oda：《精神病评估案例集》Seikosha（单一作者），1-411（1997）

Murakami,M Katura,T. Oda,S.: "Evaluation and promction of menta1 heceth for Industrial Hygiene" Japanese Jounal of Psychosomatic Medicine. 36巻. 161-191 (1997)

Murakami, M Katura, T. Oda, S.：“menta1 heceth 对工业卫生的评估和促进”《日本心身医学杂志》36. 161-191 (1997)。

Shinji Sato: "Bus hijacking as indirect suicide" Acta Crim Jap.62. 185-190 (1996)

佐藤真司：“巴士劫持是间接自杀”Acta Crim Jap.62。

小田 晋: "死刑廃止論の根拠と神話" 犯罪心理研究. 1巻2号. 2-28 (1998)

Susumu Oda：“废除死刑的基础和神话”《犯罪心理学研究》第 1 卷第 2.2-28 期（1998 年）。