权益分类	功能权益	普通用户	{{item.name}}会员
{{category.name}}	{{benefitItem.name}}

Transformative Justice in Tunisia and Egypt

突尼斯和埃及的变革性司法

基本信息

批准号：
ES/K013181/1
负责人：
Paul Gready
金额：
$ 61.23万
依托单位：
University of York
依托单位国家：
英国
项目类别：
Research Grant
财政年份：
2014
资助国家：
英国
起止时间：
2014 至无数据
项目状态：
已结题

来源：
https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=ES%2FK013181%2F1
关键词：
Transformative Justice Tunisia Egypt

项目摘要

The Arab world was shaken in 2011 by a series of popular movements, collectively known as the 'Arab spring(s)', that have challenged long established authoritarian regimes. What will be the medium and long term impacts of these uprisings? Who is driving (and contesting) change, and what kind of change is being sought? This study addresses these issues in the context of the contested transitions in Tunisia and Egypt. It is based on the following premise: for these uprisings to deliver on their potential will require transformative change that emphasises local agency and resources, the prioritization of process rather than pre-conceived outcomes, and the challenging of unequal power relationships and structures of exclusion. Such change is here named transformative justice. The overarching research question is: How is transformative change defined and delivered in the context of political transition (in Tunisia and Egypt), and which actors, institutions and structures drive and contest such change? The study's aim is to analyse the agendas of those driving and contesting change using an actor-oriented perspective. Field research about 'drivers of change' - agents, formal and informal institutions, structures - and the four key areas of contestation (elections, constitutions, transitional justice, economic policy), will provide insights to local understandings of transformation and agendas for change. Actors interviewed will be as follows: the old political guard, military and police, economic and judicial elites, Islamic groups, youth, women, human rights organisations, trade and labour unions, and the urban and rural poor. A large interview data set (over 700 interviews) will be complemented by focus groups and basic quantitative analysis. The research will look at changing attitudes over time (conducting two sets of interviews, one year apart) and document a range of voices and perspectives (urban/rural, supporters/opponents of the revolutions).The research will reach diverse audiences and maximise impact by using appropriate languages (Arabic, French, English) and media e.g. a project website; workshops and conferences; official, social and citizen media; public events; policy briefings, a tool kit and academic outputs; etc. In addition to conventional academic outputs such as peer reviewed articles and books, the research project will deliver three policy briefings -'Defining and Operationalising Transformative Justice'; 'Securing Transformation through Transitional Justice'; and 'Expanding the Scope of Transitional Justice' - and a transformative justice toolkit, outlining concrete strategies and entry-points for policy makers and practitioners. As such, the research will benefit policy-makers and practitioners (donors, inter-governmental agencies, policy think tanks, NGOs and civil society groups, etc.), as well as academics.Research of this kind speaks to several ESRC strategic priorities, notably security, conflict and justice ('competing ideas of justice', 'changing patterns of conflicts'), and social diversity and population dynamics ('how diverse communities can minimise violent conflict while sustaining rights for all').The research will represent a partnership between a White Rose (Universities of Leeds, Sheffield, York) and Worldwide Universities Network (WUN) research collaboration on transformative justice on the one hand, and the American University in Cairo (AUC) on the other. The research is multidisciplinary in range and methods and includes specialists in fields such as transitional justice, human rights, democratisation, development and political economy. Members of the Advisory Board have shaped the proposal and will engage with all parts of the research process. Local members of the Board will be particularly important in securing access to interviewees, advising on security, and framing dissemination and outreach strategies.

2011年，阿拉伯世界被一系列被统称为“阿拉伯之春”的民众运动所震撼，这些运动挑战了长期建立的独裁政权。这些起义的中期和长期影响是什么？谁在推动（和竞争）变革，以及寻求什么样的变革？本研究在突尼斯和埃及有争议的过渡的背景下解决这些问题。它基于以下前提：这些起义要发挥其潜力，就需要进行变革，强调地方机构和资源，优先考虑进程而不是预先设想的结果，以及挑战不平等的权力关系和排斥结构。这种变化在这里被称为转型正义。首要的研究问题是：如何在政治过渡的背景下（在突尼斯和埃及）定义和交付转型变革，以及哪些行为体，机构和结构驱动和竞争这种变化？这项研究的目的是从面向行动者的角度分析那些推动和反对变革的人的议程。关于“变革驱动力”-代理人、正式和非正式机构、结构-以及四个关键的变革领域（选举、宪法、过渡时期司法、经济政策）的实地研究，将有助于地方对变革和变革议程的理解。受访者将包括：旧的政治卫队、军队和警察、经济和司法精英、伊斯兰团体、青年、妇女、人权组织、贸易和工会以及城乡穷人。一个大型访谈数据集（超过700次访谈）将辅之以焦点小组和基本的定量分析。这项研究将着眼于随着时间的推移而改变的态度（进行两组访谈，间隔一年）并记录一系列声音和观点（城市/农村，革命的支持者/反对者）。研究将接触不同的受众，并通过使用适当的语言来最大限度地发挥影响力（阿拉伯语、法语、英语）和媒体，例如项目网站;研讨会和会议;官方、社交和公民媒体;公共活动;除了传统的学术成果，如同行评审的文章和书籍外，该研究项目将提供三个政策简报-“定义和实施转型正义”;“通过转型正义确保转型”;和“扩大过渡时期司法的范围”-以及一个改革性司法工具包，为决策者和从业人员概述了具体战略和切入点。因此，这项研究将使决策者和从业人员（捐助者、政府间机构、政策智囊团、非政府组织和民间社会团体等）受益，这类研究涉及ESRC的几个战略优先事项，特别是安全、冲突和司法（“相互竞争的正义观念”、“不断变化的冲突模式”）以及社会多样性和人口动态（“不同的社区如何在维护所有人权利的同时最大限度地减少暴力冲突”）。这项研究将代表一个白色玫瑰（利兹大学、谢菲尔德大学、约克大学）和全球大学网络（WUN）在变革性司法方面的研究合作，以及开罗美国大学（AUC）。该研究在范围和方法上是多学科的，包括过渡时期司法，人权，民主化，发展和政治经济学等领域的专家。咨询委员会的成员已经制定了该提案，并将参与研究过程的所有部分。委员会的当地成员在确保接触受访者、提供安全咨询以及制定传播和外联战略方面将特别重要。