Radical Right Extremism, Online Propaganda and Hybrid Human-Automated Content Removal
Radical Right Extremism, Online Propaganda and Hybrid Human-Automated Content Removal
批准号:
2284856
负责人:
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Studentship
财政年份:
2019
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2019 至 --
中文摘要
该博士学位将研究在众多社交媒体平台上发现的激进右翼图像数据(包括符号、标志、表情包和颜色的使用),以帮助刑事司法人员预防在线极端主义。该计划的关键问题是:增进知识的问题:激进右翼团体如何利用图像在网上传播宣传?这些信息的关键细微差别是什么?这些小组是如何表演的?政策相关问题:刑事司法系统如何最好地将人工和自动决策过程整合在一起,以便删除内容?在帮助反政府官员删除内容和采取预防策略打击网络极端主义方面,这种混合模式的效果如何?考虑到社交媒体平台上发布的内容数量庞大,使用技术对于有效删除恐怖主义内容至关重要。与此同时,自动化决策也有其局限性。特别是,机器处理数据和代码;他们不赋予意义(Hildebrandt 2018)。在极右翼的背景下,这些挑战更加严重。与所谓的“伊斯兰国”相关的内容不同,大多数激进右翼内容都没有烙印。此外,奥弗顿窗口也发生了变化,一些有影响力的行为者——包括国家元首、主要政党、一些传统媒体组织和广大西方公众——认同这一内容(Conway, 2020)。因此,有效性的关键在于改进人-自动化混合决策的能力(van der Vegt et al ., 2019)。除了有效性,解决与技术管理相关的各种道德问题也很重要(Brownsword, 2016)。这些措施包括:向用户提供公平的警告,告诉他们哪些内容是允许的,哪些是不允许的,这样他们就可以在知情的情况下决定是否使用该平台;如果内容被删除,确保向用户提供足够的信息,以便他们能够对决定提出上诉;审计自动化决策的结果,以检查可能的算法偏差(Macdonald et al, 2019)。本项目收集的数据将使用内容分析方法进行分析。内容分析利用定性和定量方法批判性地分析音频和视觉材料(Finch和Fafinski, 2012)。将确定具体的想法,概念,术语,主题和其他图像特征,并进行比较,以便对材料进行详细的描述,解释和分析。这些类别将通过仔细阅读数据生成,而不是预先定义,从而确保归纳方法。从内容分析中生成编码类别将产生编码手册:一份包含编码员指令的文档,从而使数据分析过程具有针对性、一致性和可重复性。当编码类别应用于数据时,将创建一个编码进度表,即包含与样本中每个项目相关的所有发现的文件。这将产生一个定量数据集,从中得出结论,并使用定性方法提出。使用这种方法有几个好处。内容分析是一种可以应用于小型和大型数据集,定量和定性研究的方法。编码手册将确保研究的可重复性,以及研究结果的健壮性和可验证性。最后,数据驱动的方法确保了所有调查结果和结论的整体性、归纳性和对话性。
英文摘要
This PhD will examine radical right image data (including symbols, emblems, memes and use of colour) found on numerous social media platforms in order to aid criminal justice operatives in their preventative approach to extremism online. The key questions of the project are:Knowledge Enhancing Questions:How do radical right groups use images to spread propaganda online?What are the key nuances of these messages?And how do the groups perform othering?Policy Relevant Questions:How best can human and automated decision-making processes be integrated for the purpose of content removal processes by the criminal justice system?How effective can a hybrid model be for aiding counter-officials in content removal and preventative tactics in combatting online extremism?MethodologyGiven the sheer volume of content posted on social media platforms, the use of technology is essential for effective removal terrorist content. At the same time, automated decision-making has its limitations. In particular, machines work with data and code; they do not attribute meaning (Hildebrandt 2018). These challenges are exacerbated in the context of the far-right. Unlike content associated with the so-called Islamic State, most radical right content is not branded. Moreover, there has been a shift in the Overton Window, such that some powerful actors - including heads of state, major political parties, some traditional media organisations and broad swathes of Western publics - identify with this content (Conway, 2020). The key to effectiveness therefore lies in the ability to improve hybrid human-automated decision-making (van der Vegt et al, 2019).As well as effectiveness, it is also important to address the various ethical issues associated with technological management (Brownsword, 2016). These include: providing users with fair warning of what content is and is not permissible, so that they can make informed decisions about their use of the platform; where content is removed, ensuring that users are provided with sufficient information to be able to appeal against the decision should they wish to do so; and, auditing the outcomes of automated decision-making in order to check for possible algorithmic bias (Macdonald et al, 2019).The data scraped for this project will be analysed using a content analysis methodology. Content analysis utilises both qualitative and quantitative methods to critically analyse audio and visual material (Finch and Fafinski, 2012). Specific ideas, concepts, terms, themes and other image characteristics will be identified, and comparisons made, to allow a detailed description, explanation and analysis of the material. These categories will be generated through a careful reading of the data, as opposed to being pre-defined, thus ensuring an inductive approach. The generation of coding categories from the content analysis will result in a coding manual: a document containing instructions for the coder, so that the process of data analysis is specific, consistent and repeatable. As the coding categories are applied to the data, a coding schedule will be created, i.e. a document containing all the findings related to each item within the sample. This will result in a quantitative dataset, from which conclusions will be drawn and presented using qualitative methods.There are several benefits to using this approach. Content analysis is a methodology that can be applied to both small and large datasets, and to quantitative and qualitative research. The coding manual will ensure the repeatability of the research and that the findings are robust and verifiable. Finally, the data-driven approach ensures the holistic, inductive and dialogic nature of all findings and conclusions.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
国内基金
海外基金
中医药应对突发公共卫生事件循证指南报告规范的研制:一项基于RIGHT框架的方法学研究
-
批准号:82104685
-
项目类别:青年科学基金项目(C类)
-
资助金额:30.0万元
-
批准年份:2021
-
负责人:倪小佳
-
依托单位: