What 'if'? A Modal Analysis of Indicative Conditionals
What 'if'? A Modal Analysis of Indicative Conditionals
批准号:
2284913
负责人:
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Studentship
财政年份:
2019
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2019 至 --
中文摘要
几乎所有的哲学家都使用“如果”的物质解释,这样指示性条件在除了真前提和假结论之外的任何子句真值组合下都为真。然而,大多数人是带着沉重的心情这样做的——许多看似错误的指示性条件句(例如“如果月球表面有液态水,月球将会爆炸”)在这种解释下是正确的(考虑到它们的先行词是错误的)。因此,指示性条件句是否暗示了先行句和后句之间的模态关系?这是我的主要研究问题,我将捍卫一个肯定的答案。为了做到这一点,我的目标是给出这样一种模态关系的解释,以及它如何控制所讨论的现象的行为。我还将与虚拟条件句进行比较,以确定其情态分析是否可以帮助我们理解指示性条件句的情态。此外,我将问这种观点是否与我们对科学方法的理解相一致。似乎,指示性条件句的范式案例是经验法则的陈述;因此,一种理论或许可以为另一种理论提供信息。
英文摘要
Almost all philosophers use the material interpretation of 'if' such that indicative conditionals are true given any combination of subsentential truth-values except a true antecedent and false consequent. Most, however, do so with a heavy heart - many indicative conditionals that are seemingly false (such as 'If there is liquid water on the moon's surface, the moon will explode') are true on this interpretation (given that their antecedents are false).Does the indicative conditional, therefore, imply a modal relationship between antecedent and consequent? This is my main research question, and I will be defending an affirmative answer. To do so, I will be aiming to give an account of what it would take for such a modal relationship to obtain, and how it would govern the behaviour of the phenomena in question. I will also draw comparisons to the subjunctive conditional to determine whether its modal analysis can help us understand the modality of indicative conditionals. Furthermore, I will ask whether this view coheres with our understanding of the scientific method. Plausibly, the paradigm case of the indicative conditional is the statement of empirical law; hence, theory of one can perhaps inform theory of the other.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金