Patient Perspectives on the Ethical Implementation of an Oncology Learning System
Patient Perspectives on the Ethical Implementation of an Oncology Learning System
批准号:
9975750
负责人:
Reshma Jagsi
金额:
$36.74万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016-08-15 至 2022-07-31
关键词:
AgeAmerican Society of Clinical OncologyAreaAttitudeAwarenessCancer PatientCaringCharacteristicsCollaborationsComplexComputerized Medical RecordConsentDataDevelopmentDiagnosisDisclosureDiseaseEducationEnsureEnvironmentEthicsEthnic OriginEtiologyEvolutionExposure toGenderGenomicsGleanHealthHealth systemHealthcareHealthcare SystemsIndividualIndustryInformed ConsentInstitute of Medicine (U.S.)InterventionInvestigationJudgmentKnowledgeLearningLifeMalignant NeoplasmsMeasuresMedicalMethodsMinorityMissionNonmaleficenceNotificationOncologyParticipantPatientsPerceptionPersonsPositioning AttributePreventionPrevention strategyPrivacyProcessProviderQuality of CareRaceRecommendationResearchSiteSubgroupSurveysSystemTestingTimeTranscriptTrustWorkcancer therapycancer typeclinical careclinical practicedeliberative democracyexpectationexperienceimprovedinfancyinnovationinsightneoplasm registrypatient subsetsprecision medicinesatisfactionsocial implicationsurvivorshiptreatment strategy
中文摘要
摘要:学习型卫生系统的发展正在引起环境的根本性变化
NCI在其中履行其使命;理解这些变化的伦理和社会影响是
非常重要。在快速学习系统(RLS)中,常规收集的患者数据推动了
发现,这反过来成为临床护理的自然副产品。正如医学研究所所指出的,
这样的系统对提高护理和研究的质量以及最终的价值有很大的希望
在医疗保健方面。随着这些系统的发展,目前临床实践、质量
护理和研究需要仔细考虑伦理影响。由于RLS还处于初级阶段,它
对于进行研究以产生知情和经过深思熟虑的患者对伦理的看法是至关重要的
实施这类制度,特别是关于如何确保尊重病人自主权和
隐私,包括通知参与者的最佳方法和数据使用的治理,以实现
这些系统的潜在好处。因此,我们提出了一项创新的研究,使用尖端技术
协商民主的方法,以产生癌症患者经过深思熟虑和知情的意见,
利用一个独特的机会,在推出真实的RLS期间评估患者的体验。
具体地说,美国临床肿瘤学会(ASCO)已经开发了一种真实世界的肿瘤学RLS
被称为CancerLinQ。CancerLinQ将在明年的15个先锋实践中实施,
在该系统中,患者通知/同意和数据治理的方法正在积极发展。我们建议
与ASCO及其先锋合作的两种不同方法和目标的实证调查
练习。首先,我们将采用协商民主的方式,确定知情和
考虑了癌症患者的个人和团体的意见和建议,提出了治疗癌症的最佳方法
获得同意并适当使用在医疗过程中常规收集的信息,作为
旨在提高质量和推进研究的RLS。第二,在CancerLinQ推出后,我们将
对体验此RLS实际实施的患者进行调查,以评估他们的知识
以及对这一体系的看法。在开发真实世界的同时开展拟议的工作
RLS提供了一个机会,直接为国家学习的发展和实施提供信息
最终将影响数万名患者的系统,它还允许考虑真正的-
而不是纯粹的假设情景,从而增加了这些调查将
提供可直接应用于其他环境的见解。这些发现将与
NCI的研究任务,因为肿瘤学学习系统正在从根本上改变研究的背景
涵盖癌症病因、诊断、预防、治疗和生存护理的各个领域。
英文摘要
Abstract: The development of learning health systems is causing radical transformation of the environment
within which the NCI pursues its mission; understanding the ethical and social implications of these changes is
of paramount importance. In rapid learning systems (RLS), routinely collected patient data drive the process of
discovery, which in turn becomes a natural outgrowth of clinical care. As the Institute of Medicine has noted,
such systems have substantial promise for improving the quality of care and research, and ultimately the value
of health care. As such systems develop, the blurring of the current distinction between clinical practice, quality
of care, and research necessitates careful consideration of ethical implications. As RLSs are in their infancy, it
is critical to conduct research to generate informed and considered patient perceptions of the ethical
implementation of such systems, particularly regarding ways to ensure respect for patient autonomy and
privacy, including best approaches for informing participants and governance of data use, in order to realize
the potential benefits of these systems. Therefore, we propose an innovative study that uses cutting edge
methods of deliberative democracy to generate considered and informed opinions of cancer patients,
leveraging a unique opportunity to evaluate patient experiences during the roll-out of a real-world RLS.
Specifically, the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) has developed a real-world oncology RLS
known as CancerLinQ. CancerLinQ is being implemented in 15 vanguard practices over the next year, and the
approach to patient notification/consent and data governance in this system is actively evolving. We propose
an empirical investigation with two distinct approaches and aims, in collaboration with ASCO and its vanguard
practices. First, we will use a deliberative democracy approach to determine the range of informed and
considered individual and group opinions and recommendations of cancer patients on the optimal approach for
obtaining consent and appropriate uses of information routinely collected in the course of medical care as part
of a RLS that seeks to improve quality and advance research. Second, following CancerLinQ roll-out, we will
survey patients experiencing the real-world implementation of this RLS in order to evaluate their knowledge
and perceptions of that system. Conducting the proposed work in parallel with the development of a real-world
RLS provides an opportunity to directly inform the development and implementation of a national learning
system that will ultimately impact tens of thousands of patients, and it also allows for the consideration of real-
life rather than purely hypothetical scenarios in ways that increase the likelihood that these investigations will
yield insights that are directly applicable in other settings. The findings will have substantial relevance to the
research mission of the NCI, as oncology learning systems are fundamentally altering the context for research
across the spectrum of cancer causation, diagnosis, prevention, treatment, and survivorship care.
期刊论文(6)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
DOI:
10.1186/s12909-020-02072-x
发表时间:
2020-06-03
期刊:
BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION
影响因子:
3.6
作者:
[Perumalswami, Chithra R., Takenoshita, Shinichi, Nomura, Kyoko]
通讯作者:
Nomura, Kyoko
DOI:
10.1200/jco.19.01693
发表时间:
2019-12-01
期刊:
Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology
影响因子:
--
作者:
[Jagsi, Reshma, Griffith, Kent A, Bradbury, Angela R]
通讯作者:
Bradbury, Angela R
Michigan Program for Advancing Cultural Transformation (M-PACT) in Biomedical and Health Sciences
-
批准号:10661214
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$46.68万
-
财政年份:2023
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Peer Mentoring to Overcome Obstacles for Midcareer Women Clinician-Scientists in Academic Medicine
-
批准号:10093329
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$34.32万
-
财政年份:2020
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Peer Mentoring to Overcome Obstacles for Midcareer Women Clinician-Scientists in Academic Medicine
-
批准号:10267186
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$34.32万
-
财政年份:2020
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Peer Mentoring to Overcome Obstacles for Midcareer Women Clincian-Scientists in Academic Medicine
-
批准号:10731630
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$25.6万
-
财政年份:2020
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Individualization of Locoregional Management for Early-Stage Breast Cancer
-
批准号:8374168
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$32.97万
-
财政年份:2012
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Examining How Gender Differences in Outcomes Develop Among Physician Researchers
-
批准号:8286916
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$25.39万
-
财政年份:2009
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Examining How Gender Differences in Outcomes Develop Among Physician Researchers
-
批准号:7708282
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$25.65万
-
财政年份:2009
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Examining How Gender Differences in Outcomes Develop Among Physician Researchers
-
批准号:7925684
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$19.24万
-
财政年份:2009
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Examining How Gender Differences in Outcomes Develop Among Physician Researchers
-
批准号:8098968
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$16.03万
-
财政年份:2009
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Individualization of Locoregional Management for Early-Stage Breast Cancer
-
批准号:8554994
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$29.01万
-
财政年份:--
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Individualization of Locoregional Management for Early-Stage Breast Cancer
-
批准号:8726339
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$30.55万
-
财政年份:--
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
Individualization of Locoregional Management for Early-Stage Breast Cancer
-
批准号:9142049
-
项目类别:
-
资助金额:$23.28万
-
财政年份:--
-
负责人:Reshma Jagsi
-
依托单位:
海外基金