课题基金 / 基金详情

Using Sovereign Immunity to Examine the Effects of Tort Liability on Defensive Medicine and Health

Using Sovereign Immunity to Examine the Effects of Tort Liability on Defensive Medicine and Health
利用主权豁免来检验侵权责任对防御性医学和健康的影响
批准号:
10266836
负责人:
Kandice Ann Kapinos
金额:
$9.72万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
财政年份:
2020
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2020-09-30 至 2023-05-31

项目摘要

项目成果

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
项目摘要 研究表明,美国每年在防御性医疗上浪费数十亿美元--不必要的程序和 没有增加临床价值的治疗-最近的估计表明,防御性药物可能会解释 医疗保险支出的8%-20%和医院总支出的三分之一以上。大部分的“浪费”都发生在 医院环境(例如,低价值的成像和检测,不必要的住院),85%的住院患者 住院和53%的急诊科就诊是在45岁及以上的成年人中。虽然害怕的是 医疗事故诉讼可能有助于防止医疗差错,提高患者安全,也可能导致 过度利用和更高的医疗成本。为了努力遏制无价值诉讼的数量,以及 为了降低防御性医疗成本,一些州已经制定了侵权改革。非经济损害上限 (对“痛苦和痛苦”的奖励金额限制),已经显示出最有希望的效果,但证据是 关于这些上限是否改变了被起诉的可能性或医生的供应,情况喜忧参半。为 患者,似乎没有什么证据表明帽子会导致质量的变化,而大多数证据是没有 对利用率和成本的影响,但某些医疗保健设置或患者除外。我们对此知之甚少 除了最近一项关于军队卫生系统的研究外,更实质性的改革的影响。作者 发现了责任豁免的显著影响,但尚不清楚这种影响在多大程度上可能对 更广泛的美国人口,特别是老年人,他们比年轻患者更有可能成为 医学上复杂,有多种慢性病,需要住院治疗,在这种情况下,85%的美国人。 防御性医疗费用就会出现。此R03的总体目标是使用自然的实验设计 确定责任豁免对居民医疗费用和住院费用的因果关系 工业。2011年,佛罗里达州立法机构将该州的主权豁免权扩大到包括非营利性大学 教学医院,免除医生在六大医院执业的个人责任 约占该州医院工作量的10%。主权豁免,与损害上限或其他改革形成对比 修改付款金额,是诉讼的法律障碍。利用单级医院住院患者 出院和急诊科数据涵盖佛罗里达州10年内的所有患者,我们将使用 回归调整的差异差异策略,以比较防守练习、质量和 在法律修改后,医院的收费给予佛罗里达州其他大型医院豁免权。我们还可以 测试中介因素,包括服务类型(例如急诊科)和患者特征 (例如,年龄、诊断)。根据军队卫生系统的初步发现,我们假设 免疫将降低防御性医疗的发生率和护理质量。我们的发现具有重要的意义 有可能为医疗事故改革工作提供信息,以解决防御性做法,以确保医疗保健的效率。
英文摘要
Project Summary Research suggests that the U.S. wastes billions each year on defensive medicine – unnecessary procedures and treatment that add no clinical value—with recent estimates suggesting that defensive medicine might account for 8-20% of Medicare spending and over 1/3 of overall hospital spending. Much of the “waste” occurs in hospital settings (e.g. low-value imaging and testing, unnecessary hospitalizations) where 85% of inpatient stays and 53% of emergency department (ED) visits are among adults age 45 and older. Although the fear of medical malpractice lawsuits may help prevent medical errors and improve patient safety, it may also result in over-utilization and higher healthcare costs. In an effort to curb the number of non-meritorious lawsuits and reduce defensive medicine costs, a number of states have enacted tort reforms. Noneconomic damage caps (limits to the amount awarded for “pain and suffering”), have shown the most promising effects, but evidence is mixed on whether these caps have changed the probability of being sued or the supply of physicians. For patients, there appears to be little evidence that caps resulted in changes in quality and mostly evidence of no effects on utilization and costs, except for certain healthcare settings or patients. We know little about the effects of a more substantial reform except from a recent study on the military health system. The authors found a significant effect of liability immunity, but it is unclear the extent to which this effect might hold for the broader US population, and in particular for older adults who are more likely than younger patients to be medically complex, have multiple chronic conditions, and need inpatient care, a setting where 85% of U.S. defensive medicine costs occur. The overall objective of this R03 is to use a natural experimental design to determine the causal effect of liability immunity on inpatient care and expenditures in the civilian health industry. In 2011, the Florida legislature extended the state's sovereign immunity to cover non-profit university teaching hospitals, eliminating personal liability for physicians practicing in six large hospitals accounting for roughly 10% of the state's hospital caseload. Sovereign immunity, in contrast to damage caps or other reforms that modify payment amounts, serves as a legal bar to lawsuits. Using individual-level hospital inpatient discharge and emergency department data covering all patients in Florida over a 10-year period, we will use a regression-adjusted difference-in-differences strategy to compare changes in defensive practice, quality, and charges in hospitals granted immunity to other large hospitals in Florida following the law change. We can also test for mediating factors, including the type of service (e.g. emergency department) and patient characteristics (e.g. age, diagnosis). Based on preliminary findings in the military health system, we hypothesize that liability immunity will reduce the incidence of defensive medicine and quality of care. Our findings have significant potential to inform malpractice reform efforts to address defensive practice to ensure efficiency in healthcare.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金