Interdisciplinary studies of decision-making and motor planning

大多数心理学理论旨在理解人类认知的高级方面。例如，对决策的研究通常涉及我们如何做出抽象的选择，如选择职业或买房。这通常会产生一些理论，认为决策是在认知系统中做出的，然后再传递给运动系统来执行所需的动作——这是一个由感知、思考、然后行动组成的系列体系。然而，人类的大脑是长期进化历史的产物，在历史的大部分时间里，动物面临的挑战与抽象决策任务非常不同。特别是，动物生活中的大多数决定都是在实时、动态变化的环境中做出的，没有时间进行仔细考虑，然后制定行动计划。我曾提出，在这种动态情况下，为了有效的行为，大脑使用了一种并行架构，在这种架构中，多个潜在的动作可以同时被指定，其中一个是根据当前的感官信息选择的，即使在执行过程中，如果情况突然发生变化，其他选项也会被考虑在内。这被称为“功能竞争假说”。我的研究计划旨在测试和进一步发展这一总体框架，我希望续借NSERC的发现基金，以支持这一努力的三个具体方面。项目1旨在确定变化的感官信息与不断增长的冲动和行动需要相结合的机制。本文将利用人类行为研究进一步探讨我们最近提出的“紧急门控模型”。项目2将开发一个分布式网络的计算模型，该网络在灵长类动物的前额叶、前运动皮层和运动皮层以及基底神经节中执行动作选择。它将基于对我们在实验室的神经记录实验中收集的数据的新颖分析。我相信这个分析揭示了控制决策的动力系统的特性，我们可以将这些特性整合到一个复杂而现实的皮层和皮层下决策系统的数学模型中。项目3将启动一个新的实验范式，用于研究在已经进行的行动中做出决策的情况。这将涉及人类持续跟踪一个移动目标，而新目标偶尔出现的研究。虽然任务对被试来说是连续的，但新的目标将以这样一种方式呈现，以测试经典的“决定-然后-行动”范式的具体预测。通过这种方式，我们将研究哪些在静态实验室环境中发展起来的现有理论可以推广到现实世界中的行为

Most psychological theories are aimed at understanding advanced aspects of human cognition. For example, studies of decision-making usually address how we make abstract choices such as selecting a career or buying a house. These often lead to theories suggesting that decisions are made within a cognitive system prior to being transmitted to the motor systems for executing the required movements – a serial architecture of sensing, thinking, and then acting. However, the human brain is the product of a long history of evolution, and during most of that history, animals were faced with challenges very different from those of abstract decision tasks. In particular, most decisions in animal life are made in a real-time, dynamically changing environment that does not allow time for careful deliberation followed by action planning. I have proposed that for effective behavior in such dynamic situations, the brain uses a parallel architecture in which multiple potential actions can be specified simultaneously, one selected on the basis of current sensory information, and even during its execution other options remain under consideration in case circumstances suddenly change. This is called the “affordance competition hypothesis”.***My research program is aimed at testing and further developing this general framework, and I hope to renew my NSERC Discovery Grant to support three specific aspects of that endeavor. Project 1 will aim to determine the mechanism by which changing sensory information is integrated with the growing urge and need to act. It will further explore our recently-proposed “urgency gating model” using human behavioral studies. Project 2 will develop a computational model of the distributed network implementing action selection in the primate prefrontal, premotor, and motor cortex, as well as the basal ganglia. It will be based on a novel analysis of data we have collected during neural recording experiments in my lab. I believe that this analysis reveals the properties of the dynamical system that governs decision-making, and that we can incorporate these properties into a sophisticated and realistic mathematical model of the cortical and subcortical decision-making system. Project 3 will launch a new experimental paradigm for studying situations in which decisions are made during already ongoing actions. This will involve studies in which humans continuously track a moving target while new targets occasionally present themselves. Although the task will appear continuous to the subjects, the new targets will be presented in such a way as to test specific predictions from classic decide-then-act paradigms. In this way, we will investigate which of our existing theories, developed in static laboratory situations, generalize to behavior in the real world.***