Collaborative Research: Characterizing Best Practices of Instructors who Have Narrowed Performance Gaps in Undergraduate Student Achievement in Introductory STEM Courses

该项目旨在通过提高本科学生在STEM入门课程中的成绩来服务于国家利益。它将通过确定课堂实践来实现这一目标，使更多的学生在这些课程中茁壮成长。一个人是否完成四年制本科学位是收入水平的主要驱动因素。因此，在美国，获得学位的障碍对社会经济流动构成了重大障碍。其中一个障碍是成功完成STEM入门课程。即使在STEM学科中，来自代表性不足群体的学生进入这些专业的比例也与大多数同龄人相同。学生的坚持受到教师教学方式的影响。例如，在STEM入门课程中加入主动学习方法可以提高学生的成绩，缩小成绩差距。然而，并非所有主动学习的实施都能同样有效地支持这些结果。一项针对4.6万多名STEM课程学生的荟萃分析比较了授课型课堂和主动学习型课堂的学生成绩。主动学习将考试成绩差距平均缩小了40%，不及格率差距减少了75%。令人惊讶的是，一些积极的学习干预扩大了成绩差距，引发了为什么存在差异的问题。文献中的发现指出了课堂体验的两个互补要素，这是缩小成就差距所必需的：(1)一个包容的环境，所有学生都相信他们可以成功，这使他们有意义地参与；(2)遵循人们学习方式的最佳实践的主动学习。该项目团队旨在识别和测试课堂文化和课程设计中有效缩小成绩差距的特定元素的影响。该项目有三个目标：(1)通过识别和测量一组关键因素来产生一个成绩差距的解释模型，这些因素可以缩小或扩大成绩差距，并在荟萃分析中确定12门课程；(2)通过培训和验证一种预测模型，从各种类型的机构中抽取40门额外的入门课程作为全国样本，建立成就差距关键要素的普遍性；(3)开发、评估和推广从业者工具包，以缩小成就差距。该工具包将包括教师和学生的问卷，这些问卷直接提供给适合独特教室预测模型的数据处理应用程序。此外，该工具包将包括自我反思活动，以促进对预测模型的个性化结果的参与，以及解释每个关键元素实现的改进指南。因此，这个项目打算制作一套新颖的工具，教师可以用它来提高学生在高等教育中的表现，帮助所有学生都能获得四年制学位。该项目开发的工具将在网上免费提供，并通过应邀举办的研讨会、讲习班和在国家会议上的演讲进行传播。NSF IUSE: EHR计划支持研究和开发项目，以提高所有学生STEM教育的有效性。通过机构和社区转型轨道，该计划支持高等教育机构和学科社区的STEM教育转型和改善。该奖项反映了美国国家科学基金会的法定使命，并通过使用基金会的知识价值和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估，被认为值得支持。

This project aims to serve the national interest by improving undergraduate student achievement in introductory STEM courses. It will do so by identifying classroom practices that enable a greater number of students to thrive in these courses. Whether or not a person completes a four-year undergraduate degree is a primary driver of income levels. Thus, barriers to earning degrees can present significant obstacles to socioeconomic mobility in the United States. One such barrier is successful completion of introductory STEM courses. Persistence in these courses varies even in STEM disciplines in which students from under-represented groups enter the major at the same rates as their majority peers. Persistence of students is affected by how their instructors teach. For example, incorporating active learning methods in introductory STEM courses can increase student achievement and lower performance gaps. However, not all implementations of active learning are equally effective for supporting these outcomes. A meta-analysis of over 46,000 students in a wide array of STEM courses compared student outcomes in lecture-based versus active learning classrooms. Active learning reduced achievement gaps in exam scores by an average of 40% and the gap in failure rates by 75%. Surprisingly, some active learning interventions widened achievement gaps, raising questions about why the variation exists. Findings from the literature point to two complementary elements of the classroom experience that are necessary to close achievement gaps: (1) an inclusive environment where all students believe they can be successful, which primes them to meaningfully engage; and (2) active learning that follows best practices for how people learn. This project team aims to identify and test the impact of specific elements of classroom culture and course design that effectively narrow achievement gaps.This project has three aims: (1) Generate an explanatory model of achievement gaps by identifying and measuring a set of critical elements for closing these gaps in 12 courses identified in a meta-analysis that either narrowed or widened achievement gaps; (2) Establish generalizability of critical elements on achievement gaps by training and validating a predictive model on a national sample of 40 additional introductory courses from a wide array of institution types; (3) Develop, evaluate, and promote a Practitioner’s Toolkit for Closing Achievement Gaps. This Toolkit will include instructor and student questionnaires that feed directly to a data processing application that fits the predictive model for unique classrooms. In addition, the Toolkit will include self-reflection activities to promote engagement with the personalized results of the predictive model and a guidebook for improvement that explains implementation of each critical element. Thus, this project intends to produce a novel set of tools that instructors can use to enhance student performance in higher education, helping to make a four-year degree attainable by all students. The tools developed by the project will be freely available online and disseminated through invited seminars, workshops, and presentations at national meetings. The NSF IUSE: EHR Program supports research and development projects to improve the effectiveness of STEM education for all students. Through the Institutional and Community Transformation track, the program supports efforts to transform and improve STEM education across institutions of higher education and disciplinary communities.This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.