Behavior in the Balance
Behavior in the Balance
批准号:
0424103
负责人:
Helen Longino
金额:
$4.27万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2004
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2004-08-01 至 2006-07-31
中文摘要
该项目有两个方面:对人类行为科学中四种方法的比较认识论分析,以及对工作的社会和文化影响的分析。认识论分析的要点是通过分析这些方法的方法和探究的前提,来理解这些方法所提供的关于人类行为的各种知识。社会文化分析的重点是了解科学研究在更大的背景下对社会和文化关注的反应方式,以及在该背景下研究的方式。这项研究的重点是旨在了解个人行为的近因的研究,以及通常与生物学研究形成对比或被视为竞争的生物学方法或方法。因此,本研究涵盖了1)行为遗传学(经典和分子),2)行为解剖学和生理学,3)发展心理学,以及4)发展和动态系统理论。这些方法与当代版本的先天/后天之争最为密切相关。除了确定本研究涉及的直接社会问题外,该研究还将研究人类行为和行动的一般哲学概念是如何被科学研究加强或破坏的。实证研究分析了地址攻击与性取向的关系。在先前的认识论研究阶段,研究者开发了一个分析矩阵,将特征问题、调查方法和表征不同方法的假设制成表格。这使她能够描述核心行为概念的操作方式,方法(可以)调查的不同问题,每种方法的方法和数据特征,支持数据解释的独特和共享假设。她计划在第二阶段进行社会和文化分析,包括研究行为的显性和隐性价值以及研究中嵌入的人类行为和意志的哲学概念。这些可以在总结和评论文章中找到,这些文章表明了工作的感知意义,并将行为作为控制或鼓励的目标。在选择发表论文的期刊和资助研究的机构方面,他们也很容易辨别。通过观察研究人员如何向更大的公众展示他们的研究以及研究是如何被接受的,研究者将确定:1)研究中所寻求的知识所服务的社会利益;2)在研究行为的特定思考方式中隐含的关于人类行为和责任的更一般的概念。本研究的一个中心假设是,与行为相关的先天-后天辩论的突出性和魅力,比如它所跟踪的那些调查,使人们关注个人行为的病因学,而不是以可能不同政策含义的方式设想的现象。这一假设将通过考察1)不同话语背景下行为概念的连续性,以及2)关于人类行为实证研究的争议如何在这些背景下表现出来来进行调查。然后,通过关注和评估作者所阐述的政策含义的表述,作者将把这项研究的结果应用于与行为研究有关的社会和政治问题。
英文摘要
The project has two dimensions: a comparative epistemological analysis of four approaches in the sciences of human behavior and an analysis of the social and cultural implications of the work. The point of the epistemological analysis is to understand the kinds of knowledge of human behavior afforded by these approaches by analyzing their methods and presuppositions of inquiry. The point of the socio-cultural analysis is to understand the ways in which the scientific research is responsive to social and cultural preoccupations in the larger context and the ways in which the research is taken up in that context. The study focuses on research directed at understanding the proximate causes of individual behavior and on biological approaches or approaches that are typically contrasted or seen as in competition with biological research. Thus, this study surveys 1) behavior genetics (both classical and molecular), 2) behavioral anatomy and physiology, 3) developmental psychology, and 4) developmental and dynamic systems theories. These are the approaches most closely engaged in contemporary versions of the nature/nurture debate. In addition to identifying immediate social concerns implicated in this research, the study will examine how general philosophical concepts of human behavior and action are reinforced or undermined by scientific research. The empirical studies analyzed address aggression and sexual orientation. In the previous, epistemological, phase of the study, the investigator developed an analytic matrix to tabulate characteristic questions, investigative methodologies, and assumptions characterizing the different approaches. This enabled her to characterize the ways central behavioral concepts are operationalized, the different questions the approaches (can) investigate, the methods and data characteristic of each approach, the distinctive and shared assumptions that support interpretations of the data. The social and cultural analysis she plans to undertake in the second phase, consists of studying explicit and implicit valuations of the behavior and the philosophical concepts of human action and volition embedded in the research. These can be found in summations and review articles that indicate the perceived significance of the work and the presentation of behaviors as targets of control or encouragement. They are also discernable in choice of journals in which to publish and the institutions funding the work. By looking both at how the researchers represent their research to a larger public and how it is taken up, the investigator will identify 1) the social interests served by the kind of knowledge sought in the research and 2) the more general conceptions of human action and responsibility that are implied in particular ways of thinking about the behaviors studied. A central hypothesis of this study is that the salience and the fascination of the nature-nurture debate in connection with behaviors such as those whose investigation it follows keeps attention on the etiology of individual behavior rather than on the phenomena conceived in ways that might different policy implications. This hypothesis will be investigated by examining 1) the continuity of conceptions of behavior through different discursive contexts and 2) how controversies concerning the empirical study of human behavior are represented in those contexts. By then attending to and evaluating the representations of the policy implications articulated by the authors whose work is examined, the author will bring the results of this study to bear on social and political questions concerning behavioral research.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Collaborative Research - Discordant Models of Testosterone Function
-
批准号:1331115
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$16.11万
-
财政年份:2013
-
负责人:Helen Longino
-
依托单位:
The Fate of Knowledge
-
批准号:9730188
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$4.06万
-
财政年份:1998
-
负责人:Helen Longino
-
依托单位:
Assumptions and Argumentation in Research on Hormonal Bases of Gender Differences (History of Science)
-
批准号:8504061
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$6.7万
-
财政年份:1985
-
负责人:Helen Longino
-
依托单位:
Interdisciplinary Incentive Award
-
批准号:8018095
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$2.33万
-
财政年份:1980
-
负责人:Helen Longino
-
依托单位:
海外基金