Doctoral Dissertation Research: A Sociological Analysis of the Production of Scientific Knowledge: Race and Molecular Genetics

博士论文研究：科学知识生产的社会学分析：种族和分子遗传学

• 批准号: 0727360
• 负责人: Orville Lee
• 金额: $ 0.75万
• 依托单位: The New School
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 2007
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2007-08-01 至 2008-07-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=0727360&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Doctoral; Dissertation; Research; Sociological; Analysis

Doctoral Dissertation Research: A Sociological Analysis of the Production of Scientific Knowledge: Race and Molecular GeneticsPrincipal Investigator: Orville LeeCo-Principal Investigator: Catherine BlissNew School for Social ResearchIn the wake of the human genome project, scientists are devising new strategies to classify humans and are once again debating the term ""race"" for its viability as a biological concept. This research asks: What are scientists doing with race since the mapping of the human genome? How do new institutional arrangements in the field of molecular genetics affect changes in the questions asked and the interpretations made? Do the producers of today''''s biological racial discourse share a certain set of values and conceptualizations that influence their work? The project examines all publications expressing views pertaining to the molecular debate over race. First, the concepts, terms, and arguments of this discourse will be coded and analyzed for patterns of confluence, variance, and consistency. Second, the institutional configuration of laboratories, regulatory bodies, funding agencies, pharmaceutical companies, science media, and DNA fingerprinting corporations will be analyzed for its capacity to shape this discourse on race. Finally, all participants in the debate - scientists, researchers and analysts who have authored relevant publications - will be interviewed. The interviews will draw out values and conceptualizations that scientists bring to the discourse and help us understand their own motivations for and perceptions of the work they do. Molecular genetics is fast becoming a dominant paradigm of biological science; therefore, this research will illuminate highly pertinent discussions of race. Additionally, this research will promote future ties between sociology and the natural sciences. Interviews will provide an opportunity for the co-PI to form relationships with the leading geneticists who are defining race today. These relationships will encourage dialogue and constructive critique between disciplines. The co-PI will report her findings to the National Human Genome Research Institute''''s Ethical, Legal and Social Implications (ELSI) Research Program in the hope that a critical discourse and lucid policy may be formulated.

博士论文研究：科学知识生产的社会学分析：种族和分子遗传学首席研究员：奥维尔·乐视-首席研究员：凯瑟琳·布利斯社会研究新学院人类基因组计划之后，科学家们正在设计新的策略来对人类进行分类，并再次就“种族”一词作为生物学概念的可行性展开辩论。这项研究问：自人类基因组图谱绘制以来，科学家们在种族问题上做了什么？分子遗传学领域的新制度安排如何影响所提出的问题和所作解释的变化？今天的S生物种族话语的制作人是否分享了一套影响他们作品的价值观和概念化？该项目审查了所有发表与关于种族的分子辩论有关的观点的出版物。首先，将对本文中的概念、术语和论点进行编码和分析，以确定合流、差异和一致性的模式。其次，将分析实验室、监管机构、资助机构、制药公司、科学媒体和DNA指纹公司的机构配置，以确定其塑造这一种族话语的能力。最后，辩论的所有参与者--撰写过相关出版物的科学家、研究人员和分析人士--都将接受采访。访谈将引出科学家带到话语中的价值观和概念化，并帮助我们理解他们自己对他们所做工作的动机和看法。分子遗传学正在迅速成为生物科学的主导范式；因此，这项研究将阐明关于种族的高度相关的讨论。此外，这项研究还将促进社会学和自然科学之间未来的联系。采访将为联合PI提供一个机会，与当今定义种族的领先遗传学家建立关系。这些关系将鼓励学科之间的对话和建设性的批评。联合国际将把她的发现报告给国家人类基因组研究所S伦理、法律和社会影响研究计划，希望能制定出批判性的话语和清晰的政策。