S: Identifying Critical Characteristics of Effective Feedback Practices in Science and Mathematics Education
S: Identifying Critical Characteristics of Effective Feedback Practices in Science and Mathematics Education
批准号:
0822373
负责人:
Min Li
金额:
$25.93万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2009
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2009-01-01 至 2012-03-31
中文摘要
虽然有大量的证据表明反馈的积极影响,一个主要的缺乏是系统的知识,什么样的反馈是需要不同的学生,在什么形式,以及哪些类型的学习任务。这个项目将定义和综合有效的反馈策略,可以链接到日常课堂评估实践的具体功能。而不是提供有关有效性的一般证据,该项目将总结,整合和解释一系列的反馈研究,这些研究在概念上是基于参与反馈实践的特定中介者和主持人的可比性。这些中介者和调节者将包括,例如,教学任务的难度、任务所利用的认知需求(例如,陈述性、程序性、示意性或策略性知识),或学生特征(例如,低或高成就者,低或高动机。该项目将由三个研究问题指导:(1)在科学和数学教育中研究的反馈策略的范围是什么?(2)什么构成了反馈实践的关键中介者和主持者(例如,学习目标和学生特点)的反馈策略已经实施?以及(3)经验证明对学生学习有积极影响的反馈策略的关键特征是什么?该项目将制定一个框架,包括一个概念链,将考虑到内在和背景方面的反馈做法概念化,以及一个方法链,将用于描述和评价反馈研究和有待综合的结论。拟议的框架将提供一种语言,可以在不同学科的多种形式的研究内部和之间共享,以描述反馈做法。框架和研究问题也将导致纳入和排除标准,用于识别合格的文章和报告的综合。基于该框架,我们将开发和应用一个两级编码系统,以指定和评估每个合格研究的结果。最后,编码的信息将被总结,以确定模式和趋势的研究,这反过来将被用于一个叙述性的审查和定量摘要的形式的荟萃analysis.Intellectual优点:该项目将导致一个更完整和详细的理论框架比目前存在的有效的反馈策略在科学教育的特点。 这一理解将有助于(1)完善解释反馈过程及其质量的理论框架,(2)为科学教师在日常工作中有效和形成性地使用评估提供具体、易于应用的建议。该研究将帮助专业开发人员和教师了解有效实施对学生产生积极影响的反馈实践所需的内容学习这项研究还将为改进、评估和监测教师在日常教学中的反馈做法以及为科学和数学的职前和在职教师设计专业发展制定更明确的标准。该项目的结果还将填补研究空白,为形成性评估文献做出贡献,并帮助确定研究和发展议程。 该项目将为从业人员创建一个工具包,并编写供出版的文章。
英文摘要
Although there is substantial evidence about the positive effects of feedback, a major lack is systematic knowledge about what kinds of feedback are needed by different students, in what forms, and for which types of learning tasks. This project will define and synthesize effective feedback strategies that can be linked to specific features of daily classroom assessment practices. Instead of providing general evidence about effectiveness, the project will summarize, integrate, and interpret a range of feedback studies that are conceptually comparable based on particular mediators and moderators involved in feedback practices. These mediators and moderators would include, for example, difficulty of instructional tasks, cognitive demands tapped by tasks (e.g., declarative, procedural, schematic, or strategic knowledge), or student characteristics (e.g., low or high achievers, low or high motivation.The project will be guided by three research questions: (1) What constitutes the range of feedback strategies that have been studied in science and mathematics education?; (2) what constitutes the critical mediators and moderators of feedback practices (e.g., learning goals and student characteristics)in which such feedback strategies have been implemented?; and (3) what are the critical characteristics of feedback strategies that empirically have proved to have a positive impact on student learning? The project will develop a framework, including a conceptual strand that will conceptualize feedback practice considering intrinsic and contextual dimensions and a methodological strand that will be used to describe and evaluate the feedback studies and findings to be synthesized. The proposed framework will provide a language that can be shared within and across multiple forms of research in various disciplines to portray feedback practices. The framework and research questions will also lead to criteria for inclusion and exclusion to be used to identify eligible articles and reports for the synthesis. Based on the framework, we will develop and apply a two-level coding system to specify and evaluate the findings from each eligible study. Finally, the coded information will be summarized to identify patterns and trends across the studies, which in turn will be used for a narrative review and a quantitative summary in the form of a meta-analysis.Intellectual Merit: The project will result in a substantially more complete and detailed theoretical framework than what currently exists for characterizing effective feedback strategies in science education. This understanding will allow for (1) refinement of a theoretical framework that explains the feedback process and its quality, and (2) concrete, easy-to-apply recommendations for science teachers to effectively and formatively use assessments in their daily work.Broader Impacts: The study will help professional developers and teachers understand what is required to effectively implement feedback practices that have a positive impact on student learning. The research will also produce clearer criteria for improving, evaluating, and monitoring teachers' feedback practices in daily teaching as well as for designing professional development for pre- and in-service teachers of science and mathematics. Results from the project will also fill in the research gap, contribute to the literature on formative assessment, and help define research and development agendas. The project will create a toolkit for practitioners as well as articles for publication.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Automatic profiling of science assessment items to model item parameters: A natural language processing approach
-
批准号:1920512
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$50.0万
-
财政年份:2019
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
Exploring Differences Between Instructors' Exams and How These Differences Produce Scores that Could Inaccurately and Inequitably Represent Student Understanding
-
批准号:1709423
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$5.0万
-
财政年份:2017
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
Doctoral Dissertation Research: Examining Sequence of Contextualized Items in Science
-
批准号:1461431
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$1.6万
-
财政年份:2015
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
Collaborative Research: Examining Formative Assessment Practices for English Language Learners in Science Classrooms
-
批准号:1118951
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$12.22万
-
财政年份:2011
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
CAREER: Investigating classroom assessment practices in science
-
批准号:0644435
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$67.36万
-
财政年份:2007
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
Linking Assessment to Science Achievement
-
批准号:0310360
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$28.75万
-
财政年份:2003
-
负责人:Min Li
-
依托单位:
海外基金