Multiple Instrumental Case Studies of Inclusive STEM-focused High Schools: Opportunity Structures for Preparation and Inspiration (OSPrl).
Multiple Instrumental Case Studies of Inclusive STEM-focused High Schools: Opportunity Structures for Preparation and Inspiration (OSPrl).
批准号:
1118851
负责人:
Sharon Lynch
金额:
$280.27万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2011
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2011-09-01 至 2018-08-31
中文摘要
该项目的目的是研究以STEM为重点的包容性高中为学生提供的机会结构,重点是研究为代表性不足的群体的学生提供服务的学校。与高度选择性的以STEM为重点的学校相比,以STEM为重点的学校的目标是已经被确定为在STEM方面有天赋和才能的学生,以STEM为重点的包容性高中旨在开发STEM人才的新来源,特别是在代表性不足的少数民族学生中,以改善劳动力发展并培养STEM专业人员。一份新的NRC报告,成功的K-12 STEM教育(2011年),确定了最需要对以STEM为重点的学校进行研究的领域。NRC的报告指出,为科学领域代表性不足的群体提供机会的重要性,特别是黑人,西班牙裔和低收入学生,他们在K-12教育中不成比例地脱离了高成就群体。该项目专门响应了核管制委员会报告中的研究呼吁,并提供了系统的数据,以界定和澄清这类学校的性质。该项目正在研究美国各地以STEM为重点的包容性高中,以确定它们的定义。研究小组最初确定了十个候选关键组成部分,这些组成部分定义了以STEM为重点的高中,并正在通过研究来完善和进一步澄清这些关键组成部分。研究的第一阶段侧重于12所信誉良好、精心规划、社区和企业支持有力的学校,以掌握预期和实施的关键组成部分。这些高功能学校的案例研究和跨案例分析,使用一套工具来衡量STEM设计和实施,有助于为这些学校建立一个行动理论,可以更普遍地应用于STEM教育。研究的第二阶段涉及选择四种学校模式进行进一步研究,重点关注学生层面的体验,并将学生的成绩与同一地区的综合学校进行比较。正在研究的研究问题包括:1)是否有一套核心的可能的关键组成部分共享的完善,有前途的包容性STEM为重点的高中?研究中是否出现了其他成分?2)每个学校的关键组成部分是如何实施的?3)影响学校设计、实施和学生成绩的情境启示和制约因素是什么?4)这些学校的学生STEM成绩与学区和州平均水平相比如何?5)四所有前途的这样的学校如何与各自学区内匹配的综合高中进行比较,关键组成部分如何显示?6)从学生在STEM领域代表性不足的角度来看,学校的教育经验与其匹配的同行相比如何?(7)学生成绩如何比较?本研究采用多工具的案例研究设计,以描述和比较类似的现象。作为关键案例的学校是通过专家提名程序选出的,然后根据关键设计维度进行筛选和分类。数据来源包括:学校文件和公共数据库信息;调查,然后是电话访谈,调查详细信息,提供候选组成部分的系统概述;对每所学校的现场访问提供了关于学校课堂观察的数据;与重点小组中的学生、教师和行政人员进行访谈;并与学校社区的关键成员进行讨论,提供独特的学习机会,如导师,商界领袖,以及提供校外学习经验的高等教育社区成员。该项目还收集了各种学校层面的学生成果指标的数据,并跟踪了学生的STEM课程轨迹,毕业率,以及包容性STEM学校学生的大学录取率,与同一管辖区的其他学校相比。对研究第一阶段的分析旨在开发丰富的描述,展示学校的特点,使用轴向和开放编码,以确定一个行动理论,说明背景,设计,实施和结果元素之间的相互联系。研究的第二阶段的分析涉及四个层面的类似过程:学校,学生,数据库,以及三者的综合。项目评价由一个内部咨询委员会和一个外部咨询委员会组成,这两个委员会主要提供关于研究程序的形成性反馈。研究结果、案例研究、工具和标题的开发和使用记录、年度报告、会议提案和论文都在一个网站上提供,以便为教育领导人、研究人员和决策者提供即时和持续的资源,了解关于这些学校和特定模式的研究。此外,还在努力讲述第二阶段研究中所研究的四对高中的高中生的经历。研究结果还通过更传统的方式传播,例如在同行评审的期刊上发表论文和在会议上发言。
英文摘要
The aim of this project is to examine opportunity structures provided to students by inclusive STEM-focused high schools, with an emphasis on studying schools that serve students from underrepresented groups. In contrast to highly selective STEM-focused schools that target students who are already identified as gifted and talented in STEM, inclusive STEM-focused high schools aim to develop new sources of STEM talent, particularly among underrepresented minority students, to improve workforce development and prepare STEM professionals. A new NRC report, Successful K-12 STEM Education (2011), identifies areas in which research on STEM-focused schools is most needed. The NRC report points out the importance of providing opportunities for groups that are underrepresented in the sciences, especially Blacks, Hispanics, and low-income students who disproportionately fall out of the high-achieving group in K-12 education. This project responds specifically to the call for research in the NRC report and provides systematic data to define and clarify the nature of such schools. The project is studying inclusive STEM-focused high schools across the United States to determine what defines them. The research team initially identified ten candidate critical components that define STEM-focused high schools and is refining and further clarifying the critical components through the research study. The first phase of the study is focusing on 12 well-established and carefully planned schools with good reputations and strong community and business support, in order to capture the critical components as intended and implemented. Case studies of these high-functioning schools and a cross-case analysis using a set of instruments for gauging STEM design and implementation are contributing toward building a theory of action for such schools that can be applied more generally to STEM education. The second phase of the study involves selecting four school models for further study, focusing on student-level experiences and comparing student outcomes against comprehensive schools in the same district. Research questions being studied include: 1) Is there a core set of likely critical components shared by well-established, promising inclusive STEM-focused high schools? Do other components emerge from the study? 2) How are the critical components implemented in each school? 3) What are the contextual affordances and constraints that influence schools' designs, their implementation, and student outcomes? 4) How do student STEM outcomes in these schools compare with school district and state averages? 5) How do four promising such schools compare with matched comprehensive high schools within their respective school districts, and how are the critical components displayed? 6) From the points of view of students underrepresented in STEM fields, how do education experiences at the schools and their matched counterparts compare? And 7) How do student outcomes compare? The research uses a multiple instrumental case study design in order to describe and compare similar phenomena. Schools as critical cases are being selected through a nomination process by experts, followed by screening and categorization according to key design dimensions. Data sources include school documents and public database information; a survey, followed by telephone interviews that probe for elaborated information, to provide a systematic overview of the candidate components; on-site visitations to each school provide data on classroom observations at the schools; interviews with students, teachers and administrators in focus groups; and discussions with critical members of the school community that provide unique opportunities to learn such as mentors, business leaders, and members of higher education community that provide outside of school learning experiences. The project is also gathering data on a variety of school-level student outcome indicators, and is tracking the likely STEM course trajectories for students, graduation rates, and college admission rates for students in the inclusive STEM-focused schools, as compared to other schools in the same jurisdiction. Analysis of the first phase of the study aims to develop rich descriptions that showcase characteristics of the schools, using axial and open coding, to determine a theory of action that illustrates interconnections among context, design, implementation, and outcome elements. Analysis of the second phase of the study involves similar processes on four levels: school, student, databases, and a synthesis of the three. Evaluation of the project consists of an internal advisory board and an external advisory board, both of which provide primarily formative feedback on research procedures. Research findings, as well as case studies, records of instrument and rubric development and use, annual reports, and conference proposals and papers are being provided on a website, in order to provide an immediate and ongoing resource for education leaders, researchers and policymakers to learn about research on these schools and particular models. An effort is also being made to give voice to the experiences of high school students from the four pairs of high schools studied in the second phase of the study. Findings are also being disseminated by more traditional means, such as papers in peer-reviewed journals and conference presentations.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Examining the Effects of Highly Rated Science Curricula on Diverse Student Populations
-
批准号:0115637
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$11.14万
-
财政年份:2001
-
负责人:Sharon Lynch
-
依托单位:
海外基金