Marking the Boundaries of Punishment: Retribution Directed at Innocents, Animals & Collectives
Marking the Boundaries of Punishment: Retribution Directed at Innocents, Animals & Collectives
批准号:
1228231
负责人:
Geoffrey Goodwin
金额:
$7.5万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2012
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2012-09-01 至 2014-08-31
中文摘要
了解是什么激发了人们惩罚的欲望,这对于建立一个有效和公平的法律体系至关重要。惩罚性动机是出于阻止未来的不法分子并更好地保护社会的愿望,还是出于对过去不良行为的违法者进行正义惩罚的报复性动机?必须存在哪些因素才能找到值得惩罚的实体?这些因素如何影响我们惩罚性反应的严重性?虽然我们的司法系统以刑法、量刑指南和其他法律规则的形式为这些问题提供了答案,但几乎没有证据表明这些规定符合人们对惩罚的直觉。此外,过去的心理学研究试图分离人们惩罚罪犯的愿望背后的动机,但由于很难区分报复性动机和一般威慑动机,因此没有定论。利用在线和实验室实验,本项目旨在提供更明确的证据,证明存在特定的报复性动机。该项目还旨在记录报复的范围。这种惩罚动机是依赖于具有成人精神状态和道德能力的行为者,还是取决于通常被认为不适合国家一级惩罚的实体--包括儿童、智力能力有限的成年人和非人类实体--是否可以成为适当的惩罚对象?该项目的数据将对一些紧迫的政策问题至关重要,包括将更多惩罚性原则纳入州和联邦刑法的运动,以及最高法院最近对死刑施加限制的举措。虽然该项目应该为学者、法官和法律政策制定者带来最直接的好处,但该项目也旨在加强对法律和心理学交叉点的下一代学者的教育、培训和指导。
英文摘要
Understanding what motivates the human desire to punish is essential for building an effective and fair legal system. Are punitive motivations informed by a desire to deter future wrongdoers and better protect society or by a retributive drive to deliver just deserts to offenders for past bad acts? What factors must be present to find an entity punishment-worthy and how do these factors impact the severity of our punitive response? While our judicial system offers answers to these questions in the form of penal codes, sentencing guidelines, and other legal rules, there is scant evidence to show that these provisions align with people's intuitions about punishment. Additionally, past psychological research that has tried to isolate the motivations underlying people's desire to punish offenders is inconclusive, owing to the difficulty of separating retributive and general deterrence motivations. Using online and laboratory experiments, the present project aims to provide much clearer evidence for the existence of a specifically retributive motive. The project also aims to document the scope of retribution. Does this motivation to punish rely on the actor having human adult mental states and moral capacities or can entities generally thought to be inappropriate targets for state-level punishment - including children, adults with limited mental capacities, and non-human entities - be appropriate recipients of punishment? The data from this project will be critical to a number of pressing policy issues, including the movement incorporating more retributive principles into state and federal criminal law, and recent moves to place limitations on capital punishment by the Supreme Court. Although the project should yield benefits most directly for scholars, judges, and legal policymakers, the project is also designed to enhance the educating, training, and mentoring of the next generation of scholars at the intersection of law and psychology.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金