课题基金 / 基金详情

Quantitative Judgments in Law: Studies of Damage Award Decision Making

Quantitative Judgments in Law: Studies of Damage Award Decision Making
法律上的定量判断:损害赔偿决策研究
批准号:
1536238
负责人:
Valerie Hans
金额:
$39.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2015
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2015-09-01 至 2021-08-31

项目摘要

项目成果

Valerie Hans的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
要有一个运作良好的社会,企业,保险公司和公众成员依赖于一个可靠和称职的陪审团制度。 在一个民事案件中,被告伤害了原告,必须确定损害赔偿金,民事陪审员必须将他们对原告伤害严重程度的主观定性理解转化为美元。然而,许多伤害难以估价,民事陪审团得到的指导有限。一些陪审员也很难处理数字。本研究项目探讨如何改善陪审团的损害赔偿决策,使损害赔偿是很好地匹配所造成的伤害。该项目测试了一种新的损害赔偿决策模型的预测,该模型侧重于人们从审判证据中得出的要点或潜在含义。这些预测是:(a)大多数陪审员对损害赔偿的要点有一个连贯的理解;(B)基于要点的对数值大小的理解对于连贯的判断是必不可少的;(c)这种基于要点的理解可以通过简单的干预来促进,以改善陪审团的决策。三个实验,提出了确定陪审团损害赔偿的决定过程,并测试易于实施和成本效益的解决方案,以减少不必要的不一致。公平和一致的伤害评估的问题出现在许多商业和保险的情况下,因此通过这项研究发现的有效解决方案可以证明在法庭以外的其他领域是有用的。法律的系统经常要求事实调查者将他们的定性印象转化为定量判断,如刑事判决、罚款和损害赔偿。然而,法律中定性和定量判断之间的关系研究不足,理论化不足;还没有全面的理论来解释它。拟议中的研究有望通过测试来自损害赔偿决策新模型的具体预测,推动该领域的理论向前发展。实验扩展模糊跟踪理论的损害赔偿决策,测试一些具体的预测的意义和相对要点的锚(或基准),相关和不相关的情感证据,以及实用程序的指示如何规模的损害赔偿。具体来说,第一个实验调查了潜在的陪审员如何解释案件事实的要点,如何影响损害赔偿,以及提供有意义的锚金额是否减少了赔偿金额的变化。第二个实验关注相关和不相关情绪的影响,以及映射过程-简单的问题如何帮助潜在的陪审员了解损害的程度-目的是减少裁决判决的变化。第三个实验测试我们的新模型在一个现实的模拟民事陪审团设置,包括陪审团审议。数据收集将包括计算能力的多个指标(数字能力),使研究人员能够确定计算能力如何影响民事损害赔偿中有关美元的决策。
英文摘要
To have a well-functioning society, businesses, insurance companies, and members of the public depend on a reliable and competent jury system. In a civil case in which a defendant injures a plaintiff and a damage award must be determined, civil jurors must translate their subjective, qualitative sense about the severity of the plaintiff's injury into dollars. Yet many injuries are difficult to value, and civil juries receive limited guidance. Some jurors, too, have difficulty working with numbers. This research project examines how to improve jury damage award decision making so that damage awards are well-matched to the harm done. The project tests predictions from a new model of damage award decision making that focuses on the gist or underlying meaning that people derive from trial evidence. These predictions are (a) most jurors have a coherent sense of the gist of damage awards; (b) a gist-based understanding of numerical magnitude is essential for coherent judgments; and (c) this gist-based understanding can be facilitated with simple interventions to improve jury decision making. Three experiments are proposed to identify the jury damage award decision process and to test easily implemented and cost-effective solutions to reduce unwarranted inconsistency. The question of fair and consistent evaluation of injury arises in many business and insurance contexts, so effective solutions discovered through this research could prove useful in other domains beyond the courtroom. The legal system regularly requires fact finders to translate their qualitative impressions into quantitative judgments such as criminal sentences, fines, and damage awards. However, the relationship between qualitative and quantitative judgments in law is under-studied and under-theorized; no comprehensive theory yet explains it. The proposed research promises to move theory in the field forward by testing specific predictions derived from a new model of damage award decision making. The experiments extend fuzzy-trace theory to damage award decision making, testing a number of specific predictions about meaningfulness and relative gist of anchors (or benchmarks), relevant and irrelevant emotional evidence, and the utility of instructions about how to scale damages. Specifically, the first experiment investigates how potential jurors interpret the gist of case facts, how that influences damage awards, and whether providing meaningful anchor amounts reduces variability in award amounts. The second experiment focuses on effects of relevant and irrelevant emotion, and on the mapping process--how simple questions can help orient potential jurors to the magnitude of damages--with the aim of reducing variability in award judgments. The third experiment tests our new model in a realistic mock civil jury setting, including jury deliberations. Data collection will include multiple measures of numeracy (facility with numbers), allowing the researchers to determine how numeracy influences decision making about dollars in the context of civil damage awards.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Expanding Law and Social Science Research by International Research Collaboration
  • 批准号:
    1556070
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $29.33万
  • 财政年份:
    2016
  • 负责人:
    Valerie Hans
  • 依托单位:
Transforming Cross-National Theory and Research through International Research Collaboratives
  • 批准号:
    1126004
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $17.58万
  • 财政年份:
    2011
  • 负责人:
    Valerie Hans
  • 依托单位:
Public Views of Business and Corporate Responsibility (Law & Social Science)
  • 批准号:
    9350498
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $0.0万
  • 财政年份:
    1993
  • 负责人:
    Valerie Hans
  • 依托单位:
Judgements of Responsibilities for Disaster Consequences
  • 批准号:
    9213737
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $7.65万
  • 财政年份:
    1992
  • 负责人:
    Valerie Hans
  • 依托单位:
海外基金