课题基金 / 基金详情

Doctoral Dissertation Research: The Judicial Politics of Land Disputes

Doctoral Dissertation Research: The Judicial Politics of Land Disputes
博士论文研究:土地纠纷的司法政治
批准号:
1560623
负责人:
Marcus Kurtz
金额:
$2.31万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016-05-15 至 2018-04-30

项目摘要

项目成果

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
PI试图通过分析土地纠纷的出现、诉讼和解决,了解公民为什么选择利用正式的法律的机构作为专制政权的纠纷解决机制。PI认为,决定利用正式的法律的机制来解决争端是令人惊讶的,因为个人关系严重影响法律在实践中的运作。共同PI使用调查数据和法院统计数据来解决三个关键问题:1)存在什么争议; 2)哪些争议进入法院(以及为什么);以及3)如何解决这些争议。本研究通过收集、结合和分析两种类型的数据来解决这些问题:对土地所有者和律师的原始调查,以及案件统计。通过法院裁决追踪这些土地纠纷在人口中的普遍发生率,有助于阐明非民主国家的公民如何为自己的利益调动法律和法院。鉴于发展中国家为改善法治和公民诉诸司法的机会而获得的大量援助,更好地理解这一问题具有广泛的政策意义。技术摘要本项目旨在解决比较司法政治学中一个持续存在的难题:在司法腐败、依赖性强的专制政权中,为什么我们看到民事法院被广泛使用,特别是在涉及国家官员的纠纷中?在非民主国家,法律的适用往往是有选择性的或主观的。在非政治性案件中,人们期望法院履行其预期职能。然而,如果案件是政治性的,则假定非正式影响占主导地位。PI通过分析哈萨克斯坦土地纠纷的出现、诉讼和解决来研究这一难题。PI认为,决定利用正式的法律的机制来解决争端是令人惊讶的,因为个人关系严重影响法律在实践中的运作。共同PI使用调查数据和法院统计数据来解决三个关键问题:1)存在什么争议; 2)哪些争议进入法院(以及为什么);以及3)如何解决这些争议。本研究通过收集、结合和分析两种类型的数据来解决这些问题:对土地所有者和律师的原始调查,以及案件统计。通过法院裁决追踪这些土地纠纷在人口中的普遍发生率,有助于阐明非民主国家的公民如何为自己的利益调动法律和法院。鉴于大量援助专门用于改善发展中国家的法治和公民诉诸司法的机会,加深对这一问题的了解具有广泛的政策影响。
英文摘要
General SummaryThe PI seeks to understand why citizens choose to utilize formal legal institutions as a mechanism for dispute resolution in authoritarian regimes through analysis of the emergence, litigation and resolution of land disputes. The PI argues that the decision to utilize formal legal mechanisms for dispute resolution is surprising given the authoritarian context in which personal ties heavily influence how the law works in practice. The co-PI uses survey data and court statistics to address three key questions: 1) what disputes exist; 2) which ones make it to the courts (and why); and 3) how these disputes are settled. The research addresses these questions by collecting, combining, and analyzing two types of data: original surveys of landholders and attorneys, and case statistics. Tracing these land disputes from their general incidence in the population through court rulings helps to illuminate how citizens in non-democracies mobilize law and courts in their interests. Given the large amount of aid earmarked for improving rule of law and citizens' access to justice in developing countries, developing a better understanding of this issue has broad policy implications.Technical Summary This project addresses an ongoing puzzle in comparative judicial politics: in authoritarian regimes with corrupt, dependent judiciaries, why do we see widespread use of civil courts, particularly for disputes involving state officials? In non-democracies, law is often applied selectively or subjectively. Where cases are non-political, there is some expectation that courts will fulfill their intended functions. However, if cases are political, informal influence is assumed to prevail. The PI examines this puzzle through analysis of the emergence, litigation and resolution of land disputes in Kazakhstan. The PI argues that the decision to utilize formal legal mechanisms for dispute resolution is surprising given the authoritarian context in which personal ties heavily influence how the law works in practice. The co-PI uses survey data and court statistics to address three key questions: 1) what disputes exist; 2) which ones make it to the courts (and why); and 3) how these disputes are settled. The research addresses these questions by collecting, combining, and analyzing two types of data: original surveys of landholders and attorneys, and case statistics. Tracing these land disputes from their general incidence in the population through court rulings helps to illuminate how citizens in non-democracies mobilize law and courts in their interests. Given the large amount of aid earmarked for improving rule of law and citizens' access to justice in developing countries, developing a better understanding of this issue has broad policy implications.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金