Escaping the boom-bust cycle: Identifying sustainable governance strategies for shale-dependent communities

摆脱繁荣-萧条周期：为依赖页岩的社区确定可持续治理战略

• 批准号: 1658962
• 负责人: Gwen Arnold
• 金额: $ 20.87万
• 依托单位: University of California-Davis
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 2017
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2017-06-01 至 2022-05-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1658962&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Escaping; boom; bust; cycle; Identifying

The project studies how communities affected by boom-bust cycles in natural resource extraction - specifically shale oil and gas drilling - try to reduce the cycle's local negative consequences and extend its positive impacts. In a boom-bust cycle, communities rich in natural resources experience rapid economic growth when demand spikes, then rapid economic decline when resources are exhausted or demand dissipates. Both trends are often accompanied by increases in crime, infrastructure damage, and environmental degradation, and reduced quality of life. There is little research on how communities use the tools of county and city-level governance - such as public investment, subsidies, taxes, and zoning - to manage societal problems linked to boom-bust cycles and perpetuate positive impacts, such as increases in local employment, after a boom ends. The project identifies governance strategies used by localities in three U.S. states (Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia) affected by the recent shale drilling boom and bust. It examines how community characteristics and local and regional networks of information and resource-sharing among policymaking participants may influence the strategies communities adopt. Finally, it studies how citizens and stakeholders perceive these strategies and which factors encourage communities to deploy more successful governance approaches. This project is a mixed-methods investigation of the strategies that local governments pursue to mitigate adverse impacts and leverage positive aspects of the shale drilling boom-bust cycle. By conducting interviews and analyzing survey data with social network and statistical techniques, the research team examines how Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia communities overlaying the Marcellus and Utica Shales have tried to manage the boom-bust cycle. Specifically, the researchers investigate: how pressures from citizens, stakeholders, and government actors affect whether cities and counties adopt boom-bust governance strategies, which strategies they choose, and how strategies diffuse among jurisdictions; whether systematic differences exist between jurisdictions that fail to consider a given approach, fail to adopt it, or adopt it successfully; and how the composition of and strength of ties within local governance networks influence the strategies jurisdictions adopt and how successful citizens, stakeholders, and decision makers view the strategies. The project brings a cross-sectional, quantitative approach to issues typically studied with qualitative, small-n techniques, building theoretical micro-foundations for and testing key assumptions in the policy diffusion and adoption, sustainability, and boom-bust literatures. The research aims to produce actionable insights for communities currently experiencing pernicious boom-bust effects.

该项目研究受自然资源开采（特别是页岩油和天然气钻探）繁荣-萧条周期影响的社区如何努力减少周期对当地的负面影响，并扩大其积极影响。在繁荣-萧条周期中，自然资源丰富的社区在需求激增时经历快速经济增长，然后在资源枯竭或需求消失时经历快速经济衰退。这两种趋势往往伴随着犯罪增加、基础设施破坏、环境退化和生活质量下降。关于社区如何利用县和市一级的治理工具--如公共投资、补贴、税收和分区--来管理与繁荣-萧条周期相关的社会问题并保持积极影响（如在繁荣结束后增加当地就业）的研究很少。该项目确定了受最近页岩钻探繁荣和萧条影响的美国三个州（俄亥俄州、宾夕法尼亚州、西弗吉尼亚州）地方政府使用的治理策略。它审查了社区特点以及决策参与者之间的地方和区域信息和资源共享网络如何影响社区采取的战略。最后，它研究了公民和利益攸关方如何看待这些战略，以及哪些因素鼓励社区部署更成功的治理方法。该项目是对地方政府为减轻页岩钻探繁荣-萧条周期的不利影响和利用其积极方面而采取的战略的混合方法调查。通过使用社交网络和统计技术进行访谈和分析调查数据，研究小组研究了覆盖马塞勒斯和尤蒂卡页岩的俄亥俄州、宾夕法尼亚州和西弗吉尼亚州社区如何试图管理繁荣-萧条周期。具体来说，研究人员调查：来自公民，利益相关者和政府行为者的压力如何影响城市和县是否采取繁荣-萧条治理策略，他们选择的策略以及策略如何在司法管辖区之间扩散;司法管辖区之间是否存在系统差异，未能考虑给定的方法，未能采用它，或成功采用它;以及地方治理网络的组成和联系强度如何影响辖区采取的战略，以及成功的公民、利益相关者和决策者如何看待这些战略。该项目带来了一个横截面，定量的方法，通常与定性，小n技术研究的问题，建立理论微观基础和测试的政策扩散和采用，可持续性和繁荣-萧条文献的关键假设。该研究旨在为目前正在经历恶性繁荣-萧条效应的社区提供可操作的见解。

项目成果

A review of community impacts of boom-bust cycles in unconventional oil and gas development

非常规油气开发繁荣-萧条周期对社区影响的回顾

• 发表时间: 2022
• 期刊: The journal of energy research and social sciences
• 作者: Klasic, Meghan;Schomburg, Madeline;Arnold, Gwen;York, Abigail;Baum, Melissa;Cherin, Maia;Cliff, Sydney;Kavousi, Parisa;Tillett Miller, Alexandria Jordan;Shajari, Diana
• 通讯作者: Shajari, Diana

Boom, bust, action! How communities can cope with boom‐bust cycles in unconventional oil and gas development

繁荣，萧条，行动！

• DOI: 10.1111/ropr.12490
• 发表时间: 2022
• 期刊: Review of Policy Research
• 影响因子: 2.1
• 作者: Arnold, Gwen;Klasic, Meghan;Schomburg, Madline;York, Abigail;Baum, Melissa;Cherin, Maia;Cliff, Sydney;Kavousi, Parisa;Miller, Alexandria Tillett;Shajari, Diana
• 通讯作者: Shajari, Diana