Standard: Developing a Value Literate Culture in Science
Standard: Developing a Value Literate Culture in Science
批准号:
1835366
负责人:
Scott Tanona
金额:
$35.43万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2019
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2019-01-01 至 2022-12-31
中文摘要
该项目探讨了研究中负责任行为(RCR)的一个未被充分研究的文化方面-科学的目标和价值观(GVS),为日常科学实践提供信息。这种做法的例子包括确定一个研究主题,设计一个研究计划,将产生强有力的证据,并选择和招募研究参与者。相比之下,RCR培训课程通常侧重于狭隘的、基于规则的禁令,这种方法的范围和影响有限。这个项目很重要,因为它超越了制度化、基于规则的道德禁令的限制,进入了科学家思考和价值的核心。在这个方向上移动有可能打开一个新的研究路线之间的科学哲学与教育研究的RCR。 在操作上,该项目涉及两个研究领域。Strand I涉及创建一套指导性审议,将用于15名科学教师的队列。这些讨论探讨了GVS如何更好地激励科学家参与RCR,进行道德推理,并将GVS融入他们的教学,研究和指导中。指导审议将被检查,以评估其对科学家的动机和推理的RCR和他们的识字有关GVS主题的影响。这些因素之间的关系也将被审查。在这项工作的基础上,研究链2涉及到一个调查工具的开发,以研究更广泛的教师,博士后研究人员,研究生和本科生群体对GVS的态度。该调查工具的初始版本将由40名STEM专业人员试用。小组将与这些参与者进行访谈,了解他们对调查的解释。调查的修订版将分发给大约300名STEM专业人员和学生。分析将检查对GVS主题的态度是否在不同领域和群体之间存在差异,并查看GVS态度是否与参与RCR的动机相关。该奖项反映了NSF的法定使命,并通过使用基金会的知识价值和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估,被认为值得支持。
英文摘要
This project explores an underexamined cultural aspect of Responsible Conduct in Research (RCR) -- the Goals and Values of Science (GVS) that inform everyday scientific practice. Examples of such practices include identifying a research topic, designing a research plan that will yield robust evidence, and selecting and recruiting research participants. By contrast, RCR training courses typically focus on narrow, rule-based prohibitions, an approach which has been shown to have limited scope and impact. This project is important because it moves beyond the limits of institutionalized, rule-based ethical proscriptions and into the heart of what scientists think and value. Moving in this direction has potential to open a new line of research between philosophy of science with educational research on RCR. Operationally, the project involves two research strands. Strand I involves the creation of a set of guided deliberations that will be used with a cohort of 15 science faculty. These deliberations explore how GVS might better motivate scientists to engage in RCR, to reason ethically, and to integrate GVS into their teaching, research, and mentoring. The guided deliberations will be examined to evaluate their effects on scientists' motivation and reasoning about RCR and their literacy about GVS topics. Relations among these factors will also be examined. Building on this work, Research Strand 2 involves the development of a survey instrument to study attitudes towards GVS among a much wider group of faculty, post-doctoral researchers, graduate students, and undergraduates. An initial version of the survey instrument will be piloted with 40 STEM professionals. The team will conduct interviews with these participants about their interpretations of the survey. A revised version of the survey will then be disseminated to approximately 300 STEM professionals and students. Analyses will examine whether attitudes regarding GVS topics differ across fields and groups, and to see if GVS attitudes correlate with motivations to engage in RCR.This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
期刊论文(4)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Examining Physicists' Ethical Reasoning: A New Methodology
检查物理学家的道德推理:一种新方法
DOI:
10.1119/perc.2022.pr.garcia
发表时间:
2022
期刊:
2022 Physics Education Research Conference
影响因子:
--
作者:
[Garcia, Tyler, Solis, Caitlin, Linville, Caleb, Bridges, Bill, Jones, Wyatt, Herington, Jonathan, Tanona, Scott, Laverty, James T.]
通讯作者:
Laverty, James T.
The Social Risks of Science
科学的社会风险
DOI:
10.1002/hast.1196
发表时间:
2020
期刊:
Hastings Center Report
影响因子:
3.3
作者:
[Herington, Jonathan, Tanona, Scott]
通讯作者:
Tanona, Scott
A phenomenographic study of scientists’ beliefs about the causes of scientists’ research misconduct
对科学家的现象学研究——对科学家科研不端行为原因的信念
DOI:
10.1177/17470161211042658
发表时间:
2021
期刊:
Research Ethics
影响因子:
1.7
作者:
[Cairns, Aidan C, Linville, Caleb, Garcia, Tyler, Bridges, Bill, Tanona, Scott, Herington, Jonathan, Laverty, James T]
通讯作者:
Laverty, James T
海外基金