Urban planners, their daily routines and decisions. The empirical analysis of everyday action of urban planners as theoretical approach to reflect on the understanding and conception of planning and to advance planning theories
Urban planners, their daily routines and decisions. The empirical analysis of everyday action of urban planners as theoretical approach to reflect on the understanding and conception of planning and to advance planning theories
批准号:
317345591
负责人:
Professor Dr.-Ing. Frank Othengrafen
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位国家:
德国
项目类别:
Research Grants
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
德国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2015-12-31 至 2019-12-31
中文摘要
城市规划者在日常工作中往往不得不做出决策,而这些决策并不总是透明、客观和理性的考虑的结果。与此相反,个人价值观和经验、体制规范和环境以及社会经济和社会人口状况在磋商进程中发挥着重要作用-例如,在城市规划必须保障和维护哪些公共和非营利产品的问题上。然而,城市规划师在日常工作中执行哪些任务、角色和职能,他们在实践中如何做出决策,以及他们如何(在道德或伦理上)证明这些决策的合理性,在很大程度上仍然没有得到探索。到目前为止,只有很少的基于实践的研究集中在城市规划师的日常工作和实践,同时导致当前的规划理论的反思。这尤其适用于德语国家城市规划的理论思考。其结果是,规划理论不再对应于规划实践,有不同的想法和看法是什么区分城市规划作为一门学科,什么任务或活动的城市规划师在规划过程的各个阶段执行和什么是“核心”的城市规划和规划决策构成。城市规划作为一个概念或学科,因此被解释得非常不同,其结果是,没有共同的理解术语“规划”和学科内的自我认知,其中包括来自科学和实践的代表,是渐行渐远。这可以被解释为规划理论的弱点,因为它无法解释城市规划的效果或“行动模式”,无法理解业主和用户的反应,无法考虑规划机构、规划过程和“规划文化”之间的关系,也无法解释咨询过程中的行动、价值观和利益的协调,这仍然是一个“黑箱”。在此背景下,它是研究项目的目标,以促进(批判性)的反思和城市规划的自我概念的分化,通过实证分析规划实践和城市规划师的日常工作。这是基于三个维度:(1)规划师作为代理人;(2)城市规划师在规划过程中的任务和角色;(3)规划作为城市规划师的务实决策和情景判断的总和。这导致了理论方法的演变,这些方法不仅是理想的典型或理想主义的衍生,而且是基于经验和测试(定量和定性)的,并且可能对当地规划实践产生更大的影响。
英文摘要
Urban planners often have to make decisions in their daily work which are not always the result of transparent, objective and rational considerations. In contrast, personal values and experiences, institutional norms and settings as well as socio-economic and sociodemographic conditions play a major role particularly in consultation processes - for example with regard to the question which public and non-profit goods have to be secured and maintained by urban planning and which not. However, it is still largely unexplored which tasks, roles and functions urban planners perform in their daily work, how they come to decisions in practice and how they justify those (morally or ethically). Until now there are only very few empiricallybased studies focusing on the daily routines and practices of urban planners that simultaneously lead to reflections of current planning theories. This especially applies to theoretical considerations on urban planning in the German-speaking countries. The results are that planning theory no longer corresponds to planning practice, that there are different ideas and perceptions what distinguishes urban planning as a discipline, what tasks or activities urban planners perform at various stages of the planning process and what the 'core' of urban planning and planning decisions constitutes. Urban planning as concept or discipline is thus interpreted quite differently, with the consequence, that there is no common understanding of the term 'planning' and that the self-perception within the discipline, which includes representatives from science and practice, is drifting apart. This can be interpreted as a weakness of planning theory, as it is not able to explain the effects or 'modes of action' of urban planning, to understand the reactions of stake-holders and users, to consider the relationship between planning institutions, planning processes and 'planning cultures' or to explain the coordination of actions, values and interests during the consultation processes which remains kind of a 'black box'. Against this background, it is the objective of the research project to contribute to a (critical) reflection and differentiation of the self-conception of urban planning by empirically analysing planning practices and daily routines of urban planners. This is based on the three dimensions: (1) planners as agents; (2) the tasks and roles of urban planners in the planning process; and (3) planning as the sum of pragmatic decisions and situational judgements of urban planners. This leads to the evolvement of theoretical approaches, which are not only ideal-typically or idealistic derived, but empirical based and tested (quantitative and qualitative) and which might have a stronger impact on local planning practices.
期刊论文(1)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Stadtplanung als Disziplin. Alltag und Selbstverständnis von Planerinnen und Planern
城市规划作为一门学科、规划者的日常生活和自我形象
DOI:
10.2478/rara-2019-0018
发表时间:
2019
期刊:
Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning
影响因子:
--
作者:
[Levin-Keitel, Othengrafen, Frank , Behrend]
通讯作者:
Behrend
海外基金