Narratives of Iconoclasm. The Reception of Reformation Image Destruction in the Arts of the Southern and Northern Netherlands between 1566 and 1830
Narratives of Iconoclasm. The Reception of Reformation Image Destruction in the Arts of the Southern and Northern Netherlands between 1566 and 1830
批准号:
457138000
负责人:
Privatdozentin Dr. Esther Meier
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位国家:
德国
项目类别:
Research Grants
财政年份:
--
资助国家:
德国
项目状态:
未结题
起止时间:
中文摘要
在荷兰南部和北部发生的颠覆偶像的事件是一件极端的事件,人们记住了这一事件,并在后来的几个世纪里进行了有争议的讨论。该项目将研究如何在视觉媒体中改编和重新解释宗教改革期间的图像破坏,并将调查所进行的叙述。根据先前已知的以及大量未发表的破坏偶像的图像,将有可能获得对将意义归因于事件的变化方式的广泛概述,以及用于确定意义的解释模型。调查期间从1566年的破坏偶像行为开始,两年后是80年战争,导致北部省份独立,最后是1830年比利时建国,也就是荷兰君主制建立后不久。在几个世纪的过程中,政治、忏悔和社会局势反复变化,反映颠覆偶像的视觉媒体也是如此。在不同的背景下对同一事件的接受使我们有理由相信,没有传递统一的形象;相反,出现了不同的叙述,并在特定和更广泛的社会群体中传播。不同群体的解释模型追溯地将这一破坏性事件归因于不同的含义。虽然16世纪的破坏偶像运动确实是导致供词分离的神学冲突的一种表现,但破坏偶像运动的叙述不仅取决于天主教和新教之间的二分法,而且可能更强烈地取决于接受的不同背景。视觉接受并不局限于16世纪和17世纪,这两个世纪是艺术史研究的共同焦点,但在18世纪和19世纪初获得了极大的相关性。这一后期尤其重要,因为在1800年左右,北部和南部的政治局势以不稳定、依附和荷兰和比利时君主制的基础为特征。因此,可以假设,在不断变化的社会、忏悔和政治制度下,社会中的多层群体(忏悔者、艺术爱好者、艺术家、一个国家的公民)在不同的话语中刻下了对偶像的批判。虽然16世纪早期的描绘以大报为媒介讨论神学方面,但1600年后绘制的打破传统的场景被整合到关于艺术和文化的更广泛的辩论中。特别是在十八世纪和十九世纪,这一事件在历史书中的插图中得到了反映。这表明,当时强调了政治层面:1566年的颠覆传统被理解为民族起义和长期国家建设进程的开始。
英文摘要
The iconoclasm that took place in the Southern and Northern Netherlands was a drastic event, remembered and controversially discussed for centuries afterward. This project will examine the ways in which the destruction of images during the Reformation was adapted and reinterpreted in visual media, and it will investigate the narratives that were pursued. On the basis of previously known as well as numerous unpublished images of the iconoclasm, it will be possible to gain a broad overview of the changing ways in which meaning was attributed to the event and of the interpretative models used to establish meaning. The period under investigation begins with the iconoclastic acts of 1566, followed two years later by the Eighty Years’ War, which led to the independence of the northern provinces, and it ends with the foundation of the Belgian state in 1830, not long after the establishment of the Netherlandish monarchy. Over the course of the centuries, the political, confessional, and social situation changed repeatedly, as did the visual media in which iconoclasm was reflected. The reception of the same event in varying contexts gives reason to believe that no uniform image was passed on; instead, different narratives emerged and circulated within both particular and broader societal groups. The interpretative models of the different groups retrospectively attributed distinct meanings to the destructive event.Although the iconoclasm of the sixteenth century was indeed an expression of a theological conflict that led to the separation of the confessions, the narrative of the iconoclasm was not determined solely by the dichotomy between Catholic and Protestant but also, and probably more strongly, by the varying contexts of reception. The visual reception was not limited to the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, which are the common focus of art historical research, but gained great relevance in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. This later period is especially important because of the political situation in the north and the south, which around 1800 was characterised by instability, dependencies, and the foundation of the Netherlandish and Belgian monarchies.It can therefore be assumed that, under changing social, confessional, and political systems, the multi-layered groups within society (confessions, art lovers, artists, citizens of a nation) inscribed iconoclasm within different discourses. Whereas the early depictions of the sixteenth century discuss theological aspects in the medium of broadsheets, the iconoclastic scenes that were painted after 1600 are integrated into a broader debate about art and culture. Especially in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the event was reflected in illustrations in history books. This suggests that, by that time, the political dimension was emphasized: the iconoclasm of 1566 was understood as the beginning of a national uprising and of the long process of nation-building.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
After Iconoclasm: The Refurbishing of Catholic Churches in Augsburg, Antwerp and the Northern Netherlands. A Comparative Study
-
批准号:279720139
-
项目类别:Research Grants
-
资助金额:$0.0万
-
财政年份:2015
-
负责人:Privatdozentin Dr. Esther Meier
-
依托单位:
海外基金