课题基金 / 基金详情

Representing Biology as Process

Representing Biology as Process
将生物学表示为过程
批准号:
AH/P007457/1
负责人:
John Dupre
金额:
$42.74万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Research Grant
财政年份:
2017
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2017 至 --

项目摘要

项目成果

John Dupre的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
这个问题--我们是否应该认为世界是由由本质属性(即哲学术语中的“物质”)静态定义的实体组成的,还是应该认为世界是由于变化而经历并持续存在的过程--这是一个根本的形而上学二分法,自前苏格拉底以来就一直在争论。自17世纪原子论兴起以来,实体观一直主导着以科学为基础的哲学。约翰·杜普雷的S研究中心资助的项目--当代生物学的过程本体论--提出了这样的论点,即至少对于生物学来说,这是一个深刻的错误(杜普雷2012:尼科尔森和杜普雷正在出版中)。杜普雷认为,生命系统总是在多个空间和时间尺度上是动态的,它们的持久性远非仅仅是基本属性的持续拥有,而是多个过程精细地相互作用的结果。视觉表现对于科学的实践和交流都是必不可少的。然而,尽管过去绘画在形态学和胚胎学等领域发挥着核心作用,但摄影和数字技术的兴起,以及对分子而不是整个生物体的日益重视,使绘画实践越来越边缘化。在全过程生物学的发展中面临的一个严重问题是,大多数视觉表现强烈地让人联想到静态事物的领域。例如,生物体的呈现将处于特定的发育‘阶段’,通常是成熟的成体,这混淆了这样一个事实,即这是发育过程的一个短暂的临时阶段。例如,即使表示像新陈代谢这样明显动态的东西,也会包括代表时间的箭头,自然读数也会是固定的事物阵列(化学种类的实例)之间的过渡。此外,虽然科学上的视觉图像或“视觉解释”(Tufte 1997)依赖于各种图形设备,从使用视频和摄影到使用计算图形软件、模拟和手绘,但这些制作图像的手段在很大程度上依赖于已经与其生产方法交织在一起的机械模型(用于或关于其对象)。韦克菲尔德的研究领域、细胞分裂和有丝分裂是绘画在科学实践中衰落的一个缩影。20年前,作为一名博士生,他的学习主要集中在直接参与,通过基于显微镜的观察和绘制细胞,而他自己的博士生现在更远了,他们在计算机屏幕上观看细胞的2D表示,并打印出屏幕截图。在过去的5年里,他对这一区别的兴趣与日俱增,导致了与PI的探索性合作,并通过这项申请,与Co-I进行了探索性的合作。安德森多年来的工作突显了生命科学中图形技能下降的认知成本。她研究了科学家如何将绘画作为一种深入洞察其主题的方式,并在她自己的实践中,在“同构学”的范畴下,开发了分类方法,突出了跨越动物、矿物和植物传统界限的形式上的相似之处。这项工作是与不同的科学家和博物馆馆长合作进行的,并产生了驻场、展览、讲座和工作室。在同构学项目的基础上,她最近的工作在一定程度上受到与杜普雷的广泛讨论的指导,开始探索在同构学的新准则下表示生物过程的方法。随着人们对以过程为中心的生物学理解的兴趣与日俱增,本项目将通过艺术、生物学和哲学之间的创新合作,解决对新的图像制作做法的需要,以提供对生命系统的更直观的动态表现。
英文摘要
The question - whether we should think of the world as consisting of entities statically defined by essential properties (i.e. in philosophical jargon, "substances"), or as processes, that undergo and persist precisely because of change - is a fundamental metaphysical dichotomy, debated since the pre-Socratics. Since the rise of atomism in the seventeenth century the substance view has dominated scientifically grounded philosophy. John Dupré's ERC-funded project, A Process Ontology for Contemporary Biology, develops the thesis that for biology, at least, this has been a profound mistake (Dupré 2012: Nicholson and Dupré, in press). Dupré argues that living systems are always dynamic at multiple spatial and temporal scales and their persistence, far from being merely the continued possession of essential properties, is the result of the finely articulated interplay of multiple processes.Visual representation is essential both to the practice and the communication of science. However, whereas drawing in the past played a central role in fields such as morphology and embryology, the rise of photographic and digital technologies and the growing emphasis on molecules as opposed to whole organisms have increasingly marginalized drawing practices. A serious problem faced in the development of a fully processual biology is that most visual representation strongly suggests a realm of static things. For example, the presentation of an organism will be of a particular developmental 'stage', typically the mature adult, which confounds the fact that this is a momentary temporal stage of the developmental process. Even where representation of something as plainly dynamic as metabolism, for example, will include arrows representing time, the natural reading will be of transitions between a fixed array of things (instances of chemical kinds). Moreover, while visual images or 'visual explanations' (Tufte 1997) in science depend on a variety of graphic devices ranging from the use of video, and photography to the use of computational graphic software, simulation and hand-drawing, these means of making images largely depend on mechanistic models (for, or of, their objects) which are already intertwined with their methods of production. The decline of drawing in scientific practice is epitomised by Wakefield's research field, cell division and mitosis. Whereas 20 years ago, as a PhD student, his learning was centred around direct participation, through microscope-based observation and drawing of cells, his own PhD students are now further removed, watching 2D representations of cells on computer screens and printing out screen-shots. For the last 5 years, his interest in this distinction has grown, leading to an exploratory collaboration with the PI and, through this application, the Co-I. Anderson's work over a number of years has highlighted the epistemic costs of the decline of graphic skills in the Life Sciences. She has researched the ways in which scientists have used drawing as a way of developing deep insights into their subject matters, and in her own practice, under the rubric of 'Isomorphology', she has developed classificatory methods that highlight formal parallels cutting across the traditional boundaries of animal, mineral and vegetable. This work has been carried out in collaboration with a variety of scientists and museum curators and has resulted in residencies, exhibitions, talks and workshops.Building on the Isomorphology project, her more recent work, guided in part by extensive discussions with Dupré, has begun to explore ways of representing biological process, under the new rubric of Isomorphogenesis. In line with the growing interest in process-centred understandings of biology, the present project will address the need for novel image-making practices to provide more intuitively dynamic representations of living systems through an innovative collaboration between art, biology and philosophy.
期刊论文(7)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Dynamic form: Klee as artist and morphologist
动态形式:克利作为艺术家和形态学家
DOI: --
发表时间: 2019
期刊: The Journal of Nature in Visual Culture
影响因子: --
作者: [Gemma Anderson]
通讯作者: Gemma Anderson
Post-Specimen Encounters Between Art, Science and Curating
艺术、科学与策展之间的后标本相遇
DOI: --
发表时间: 2021
期刊:
影响因子: --
作者: [Gemma Anderson]
通讯作者: Gemma Anderson
Drawing Processes of Life: Molecules, Cells, Organisms
绘制生命过程:分子、细胞、有机体
DOI: --
发表时间: 2023
期刊:
影响因子: --
作者: [Anderson-Tempini Gemma]
通讯作者: Anderson-Tempini Gemma
Forking paths: depicting mitosis through process-based diagramming
分叉路径:通过基于过程的图表描绘有丝分裂
DOI: 10.1080/14702029.2021.1951585
发表时间: 2021
期刊: Journal of Visual Art Practice
影响因子: --
作者: [Anderson G]
通讯作者: Anderson G
ESRC Centre for Genomics in Society (Egenis)
  • 批准号:
    ES/F024738/1
  • 项目类别:
    Research Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $519.02万
  • 财政年份:
    2007
  • 负责人:
    John Dupre
  • 依托单位:
Philosophical issues in genomics
  • 批准号:
    119263/1
  • 项目类别:
    Research Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $12.39万
  • 财政年份:
    2006
  • 负责人:
    John Dupre
  • 依托单位:
Stem Cell Research in Context
  • 批准号:
    ES/D002656/1
  • 项目类别:
    Research Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $31.26万
  • 财政年份:
    2006
  • 负责人:
    John Dupre
  • 依托单位:
国内基金
海外基金
Journal of Integrative Plant Biology
  • 批准号:
    31024801
  • 项目类别:
    专项基金项目
  • 资助金额:
    24.0万元
  • 批准年份:
    2010
  • 负责人:
    贺萍
  • 依托单位: