Sensitivity to reward change: a novel cognitive approach to understanding and measuring affective state in animals

对奖励变化的敏感性：一种理解和测量动物情感状态的新颖认知方法

• 批准号: BB/J00703X/1
• 负责人: Oliver Burman
• 金额: $ 59.26万
• 依托单位: University of Lincoln
• 依托单位国家: 英国
• 项目类别: Research Grant
• 财政年份: 2012
• 资助国家: 英国
• 起止时间: 2012 至 无数据
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=BB%2FJ00703X%2F1
• 关键词: Sensitivity; reward; change; novel; cognitive

The question as to what feelings animals might or might not experience underlies not just the assessment of animal welfare, but public concern for how captive animals are treated. As the number of animals used in agriculture, research and kept as pets continues to increase, for example over 700million chickens are farmed and killed annually in the UK for meat production alone, the belief that many animal species have the capacity to suffer drives our desire to improve the housing conditions and husbandry procedures of those animals. Yet, because such experiences are private, they cannot be accessed directly. Instead, welfare scientists use indirect measures thought to reflect animals' emotional states. These indicators are often behavioural (e.g. approaching food) or physiological (e.g. a change in heart rate). However, despite the benefits of these measures, they have critical limitations. For example, an animal's heart rate will increase in the presence of something fearful (e.g. a predator), but will also increase during the experience of something pleasurable (e.g. food), such that reliable interpretation of this measure becomes impossible. For this reason, research into developing new approaches to measuring animal emotion and mood is urgently required to allow a more accurate and targeted assessment of animal welfare. Research that underpins and advances in animal welfare science in this way will have a major impact on a captive animal population that consists of large numbers of individuals. For example, there are an estimated 10 million owned dogs in the UK (2006).The aim of this proposed research programme is therefore to develop a completely new approach to understanding and measuring emotions and moods in animals that will significantly advance our assessment of animal welfare, and this approach is based on reward evaluation.How we feel about a reward that we have been given depends not just upon its absolute value, but its value compared to what was expected. So, although you might normally be happy to receive a pay rise, you will be disappointed if you were expecting to be offered a promotion as well. This sensitivity to the contrast between what you expected and what you actually received is common to many animal species and is thought to help individuals to make appropriate decisions. It has recently been demonstrated for the first time that the mood an individual is currently experiencing can influence its sensitivity to a change in reward, with those animals in a positive mood recovering sooner from an unexpected loss of reward. This therefore provides an exciting opportunity to use sensitivity to reward change as a novel measure of animal emotion and mood. Initial research indicates that sensitivity to reward change is a quick, effective and non-invasive way of measuring moods in animals. However, this approach needs to be studied in more detail in order to determine the full extent of its potential.In this project we will be studying emotions and moods in domestic dogs, both owned (pet) dogs and those housed at rescue centres. In contrast to laboratory and farm animals, the study of emotions, moods and associated behaviour in dogs, because they share a close relationship and environment with people, can reveal valuable insights into the interaction between cognition (e.g. decision-making) and emotion that applies not just to dogs and other animal species, but also to humans themselves. Whilst the outcomes of the study will clearly have a direct impact upon the welfare assessment of dogs, resulting in ways to improve the welfare of dogs housed in rescue centres and rehoming success, it will have a far wider impact, delivering techniques that can be applied across captive animal species.

关于动物可能会或可能不会经历什么感受的问题不仅是对动物福利评估的基础，也是公众对如何对待圈养动物的关注。随着用于农业、研究和作为宠物饲养的动物数量的持续增加，例如在英国每年仅用于肉类生产的鸡就被养殖和宰杀超过7亿只，许多动物物种具有受苦能力的信念驱使我们希望改善这些动物的饲养条件和饲养程序。然而，由于这些经验是私人的，他们不能直接访问。相反，福利科学家使用间接的措施来反映动物的情绪状态。这些指标通常是行为（例如接近食物）或生理（例如心率变化）。然而，尽管这些措施有好处，但也有严重的局限性。例如，动物的心率会在恐惧的东西（例如捕食者）的存在下增加，但也会在愉快的东西（例如食物）的体验期间增加，使得对该测量的可靠解释变得不可能。因此，迫切需要研究开发测量动物情感和情绪的新方法，以便更准确和有针对性地评估动物福利。以这种方式支持和推进动物福利科学的研究将对由大量个体组成的圈养动物种群产生重大影响。例如，在英国估计有1000万只狗（2006年）。因此，这项拟议的研究计划的目的是开发一种全新的方法来理解和测量动物的情绪和情绪，这将大大促进我们对动物福利的评估，这种方法是基于奖励评估的。我们对所获得的奖励的感受不仅取决于它的绝对值，但它的价值与预期相比。所以，尽管你通常会很高兴得到加薪，但如果你也希望得到晋升，你会感到失望。这种对你所期望的和你实际得到的之间的对比的敏感性是许多动物物种所共有的，并且被认为有助于个体做出适当的决定。最近首次证明，个体当前经历的情绪可以影响其对奖励变化的敏感性，那些处于积极情绪中的动物从意外的奖励损失中恢复得更快。因此，这提供了一个令人兴奋的机会，使用敏感性奖励变化作为一种新的措施，动物的情绪和情绪。初步研究表明，对奖励变化的敏感性是一种快速，有效和非侵入性的测量动物情绪的方法。然而，这种方法需要更详细地研究，以确定其潜力的全部范围。在这个项目中，我们将研究家养狗的情绪和情绪，包括拥有的（宠物）狗和那些被安置在救援中心的狗。与实验室和农场动物相比，狗的情绪，情绪和相关行为的研究，因为它们与人类有着密切的关系和环境，可以揭示认知（例如决策）和情绪之间的相互作用，不仅适用于狗和其他动物物种，也适用于人类本身。虽然这项研究的结果显然会对狗的福利评估产生直接影响，从而改善收容在救援中心的狗的福利和成功回归的方法，但它将产生更广泛的影响，提供可应用于圈养动物物种的技术。

项目成果

Reinforcer effectiveness in dogs-The influence of quantity and quality

狗的强化物有效性——数量和质量的影响

• DOI: 10.1016/j.applanim.2018.05.016
• 发表时间: 2018
• 期刊: Applied Animal Behaviour Science
• 影响因子: 2.3
• 作者: Riemer S

Can Sleep and Resting Behaviours Be Used as Indicators of Welfare in Shelter Dogs (Canis lupus familiaris)?

• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0163620
• 发表时间: 2016
• 期刊: PloS one
• 影响因子: 3.7
• 作者: Owczarczak-Garstecka SC;Burman OH
• 通讯作者: Burman OH

Assessing the External Validity of Successive Negative Contrast - Implications for Animal Welfare

评估连续阴性对比的外部有效性 - 对动物福利的影响

• DOI: 10.7892/boris.130202
• 发表时间: 2019
• 作者: Ellis S

Housing conditions affect rat responses to two types of ambiguity in a reward-reward discrimination cognitive bias task.

• DOI: 10.1016/j.bbr.2014.07.048
• 发表时间: 2014-11-01
• 期刊: BEHAVIOURAL BRAIN RESEARCH
• 影响因子: 2.7
• 作者: Parker, Richard M. A.;Paul, Elizabeth S.;Burman, Oliver H. P.;Browne, William J.;Mendl, Michael
• 通讯作者: Mendl, Michael

Assessing the External Validity of Successive Negative Contrast - Implications for Animal Welfare.

评估连续负对比的外部有效性 - 对动物福利的影响。

• DOI: 10.1080/10888705.2019.1572509
• 发表时间: 2020
• 期刊: JAAWS
• 作者: Ellis SLH