United States and English University Responses to Student Disclosures of Sexual Violence
United States and English University Responses to Student Disclosures of Sexual Violence
批准号:
ES/X005801/1
负责人:
Erin Shannon
金额:
$11.86万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Fellowship
财政年份:
2022
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2022 至 --
中文摘要
性暴力在美国和英国的大学中仍然是一个重要的问题,因为20%-25%的女高等教育学生在完成本科学业之前会经历性暴力。尽管被害率很高,但关于大学应对性暴力的学术研究仍然有限。然而,现有的学术研究表明,机构--包括大学--对性暴力报告的反应往往会对幸存者造成再创伤;因此,至关重要的是,不仅要研究这种对进一步学术调查的反应,而且要加强对幸存者的支持。我的博士论文通过比较美国和英国的10所大学如何应对学生性暴力的披露,有助于我们对制度反应的理解。尽管美国和英国的学生人数和受害比例相似,但他们对大学性暴力的应对模式存在显著差异:美国通过第九条建立了一个全国性的法律框架,通常是惩罚性的,而英国在英国大学发布的《改变文化报告》的指导下鼓励个人做出回应。我在三个层面分析了这些不同的回应模式:结构层面,通过对2011年美国亲爱的同事信函第九章指南和2016年英国大学改变文化报告进行政策话语分析;制度层面,通过对美国和英国10所大学的26名教职员工(如福利顾问、政策领导、学生学科经理)进行1-2个小时的深入采访;以及主观层面,通过采访两国19名学生幸存者。通过研究这个问题的国家、机构和个人层面,我能够在国家政策和那些试图报告大学性暴力的人的情绪反应之间建立联系。我的论文认为,美国和英国的大学对学生披露性暴力的回应是,将大学声誉置于学生幸存者福祉之上,这反映了它们运作的新自由主义政策议程。虽然主流叙事将这种再创伤反应定位为大学未能遵守政策的结果,但我的论文证明,对幸存者的再创伤反应确实符合国家政策指导,并表明当前的反应框架本身是站不住脚的。在我的样本中,大多数大学都遵守了国家指导方针,但这种遵循并没有阻止对幸存者的进一步伤害。事实上,这些大学经常给人以积极的印象,因为它们完成了政策建议,正是这些大学正在通过这些过程给幸存者带来创伤。这一奖学金将使我能够出版和传播这项研究,不仅将进一步从学术上了解这一紧迫问题,而且还将改善对幸存者的机构应对措施。通过三篇同行评议的文章,我将发表我的发现,挑战现有的制度权力动态的理解;我还将提交一份独家撰写的手稿提案以及一个样本章节。为了加强我的研究网络,我将组织一个为期一天的研究研讨会,与会的有大学性暴力方面的顶尖学者。我还将与大学应急工作人员组织两次知识交流讲习班,以产生一份面向公众的报告,提出改进对幸存者的应对措施的建议。最后,这一奖学金将为我的研究生涯奠定基础,因为我将提交一份为期3年的Leverhulme早期职业奖学金的建议。成功地完成这些目标将使我成为一个新兴的学者,对机构中性暴力的知识和实践做出很大贡献。
英文摘要
Sexual violence in US and English universities remains a significant issue, as 20-25% of female higher education students will experience sexual violence before finishing their undergraduate studies. Despite these high rates of victimisation, scholarship on university responses to sexual violence remains limited. What scholarship does exist, however, indicates that institutional-including university-responses to sexual violence reports can often be retraumatising to survivors; it is therefore vital to study such responses to not only further scholarly inquiry, but also improve support for survivors. My doctoral thesis contributes to our understanding of institutional responses by comparing how a selection of 10 universities in the United States and England respond to student disclosures of sexual violence. Although the US and England have similar student populations and victimisation rates, their response models for sexual violence in universities differ significantly: The US has a national legalistic, often punitive framework through Title IX, while England encourages individual responses following Universities UK's Changing the Culture report guidance. I analysed these different response models at three levels: the structural level through policy discourse analysis of the 2011 Dear Colleague Letter Title IX guidance in the US and the 2016 Universities UK Changing the Culture report; the institutional level through in-depth, 1-2-hour-long interviews with 26 staff members (e.g. wellbeing advisors, policy leads, student discipline managers) across 10 universities throughout the US and England; and the subjective level of lived experience through interviews with 19 student survivors across the two countries. By examining national, institutional, and personal levels of this issue, I was able to make connections between national policy and the emotional responses of those trying to report sexual violence in universities.My thesis argues that US and English universities respond to student disclosures of sexual violence by prioritising university reputation over student survivor wellbeing, which reflects the neoliberal policy agenda in which they operate. While mainstream narratives position such retraumatising responses as the result of universities failing to comply with policies, my thesis demonstrates that retraumatising responses for survivors are genuinely compliant with national policy guidance, and suggests that the current response frameworks themselves are untenable. Most universities in my sample were complying with national guidance, yet that compliance did not prevent further harming survivors. In fact, the universities often presented in a positive light because they accomplished policy recommendations are the same universities that are traumatising survivors through those very processes. This Fellowship will enable me to publish and disseminate this research that will not only further scholarly understanding of this urgent issue, but also improve institutional responses for survivors. Through 3 peer-reviewed articles, I will publish my findings that challenge existing understandings of institutional power dynamics; I will also submit a proposal for a sole-authored manuscript along with a sample chapter. In order to strengthen my research network, I will organise a day-long research symposium featuring the leading scholars of sexual violence in universities. I will also organise 2 knowledge exchange workshops with university response staff that will lead to a public-facing report with recommendations to improve responses for survivors. Lastly, this Fellowship will create the groundwork for a research career as I will submit a proposal for a 3-year Leverhulme Early Career Fellowship. Successful completion of these aims will position me as an emerging scholar with much to contribute to knowledge and practice around sexual violence in institutions.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金