Making blame avoidance newsworthy: Identifying discursive strategies of ministerial blame avoidance and exploring their influence on media narratives

使避免指责具有新闻价值：确定部长避免指责的话语策略并探索其对媒体叙事的影响

• 批准号: 2739638
• 金额: --
• 依托单位: Loughborough University
• 依托单位国家: 英国
• 项目类别: Studentship
• 财政年份: 2022
• 资助国家: 英国
• 起止时间: 2022 至 无数据
• 项目状态: 未结题
• 来源: https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=studentship-2739638
• 关键词: Making; blame; avoidance; newsworthy; Identifying

This research investigates the blame avoidance strategies employed by the Conservative Government during the COVID-19 pandemic and explores their influence on news media content during this period. It focuses on the dynamics between journalists and political actors shaping the newsmaking process, specifically in relation to the agenda setting of crises, policy outcomes and narratives of accountability. It engages with salient questions regarding the extent of media dependence on party-sponsored messaging and the susceptibility of journalism to methods such as spin, distraction and obscurantism. By investigating the recent history of Boris Johnson's premiership, during which pandemic management was the media's predominant policy focus, this study takes advantage of a unique period in British politics to further the understanding into crisis communications, the influence parties have over media agendas and the importance of structural media factors in determining party strategy.Through a content analysis of print publication and broadcast output spanning a two-year period, this research will produce statistical data showcasing the efficacy of different media strategies for blame management purposes. Measures such as the exporting of frames and the variability of issues' salience will be theorised as evidence of a strategy's success. Time-series analysis will examine flows between sources, in turn identifying influential arbiters of discursive power. In addition, interviews with party strategists, communications officers and journalists will complement content analysis to help provide a more nuanced understanding into how the 'blame game' works in practice.The hypotheses developed in conjunction with the coding scheme will draw upon existing research which finds factors such as press partisanship and incumbency to be strong determinants of media representation. Furthermore, in light of growing concerns that the Government has regularly employed divisive, populist techniques to evade accountability, this research aims to explore the role of certain methods - e.g. personal attacks, 'dead cat policies' - within the Government's wider PR arsenal. Whilst there are multiple studies which explain how populist communications can be an effective tool for insurgent parties in terms of agenda-setting and visibility-seeking, this project explores whether a broadly populist style is auspicious for a mainstream, governing party, and considers the impact it may have on the wider state of political news reporting. Lastly, it addresses questions concerning the media's ability to hold governments to account when confronted by public relations techniques, and will inform recommendations for the strengthening of regulatory frameworks and the improvement of newsroom practices.

本研究调查了英国保守党政府在新冠肺炎疫情期间采取的避责策略，并探讨了这些策略对这一时期新闻媒体内容的影响。它侧重于影响新闻制作进程的记者和政治行为者之间的动态，特别是与危机的议程设置、政策成果和问责叙述有关的动态。它涉及到一些突出的问题，比如媒体对政党赞助的信息的依赖程度，以及新闻对编造、分心和蒙昧等方法的敏感性。通过调查鲍里斯·约翰逊担任首相期间，流行病管理是媒体主要政策重点的近代史，本研究利用英国政治中的一个独特时期，进一步了解危机沟通、政党对媒体议程的影响以及结构性媒体因素在决定政党战略中的重要性。通过对跨越两年时间的印刷出版物和广播产出的内容分析，本研究将产生统计数据，展示不同媒体策略在责任管理方面的有效性。框架的输出和问题突出程度的可变性等指标将被理论化，作为一项战略成功的证据。时间序列分析将检验来源之间的流动，进而确定话语权力的有影响力的仲裁者。此外，对政党战略家、传播官和记者的采访将补充内容分析，以帮助更细微地了解“指责游戏”在实践中是如何运作的。与编码方案一起开发的假设将借鉴现有的研究，这些研究发现，媒体党派和在职等因素是媒体代表性的强大决定因素。此外，鉴于越来越多的人担心政府经常使用分裂的民粹主义手段来逃避责任，这项研究旨在探索某些方法--例如人身攻击、‘死猫政策’--在政府更广泛的公关库中的作用。虽然有多项研究解释了民粹主义传播如何在议程设置和寻求知名度方面成为反叛政党的有效工具，但该项目探索了广泛的民粹主义风格对主流执政党是否有利，并考虑了它可能对更广泛的政治新闻报道状态产生的影响。最后，它讨论了媒体在面对公关技巧时追究政府责任的能力问题，并将就加强监管框架和改进新闻编辑室做法提出建议。