Creativity in Environmental Systems Conflict Resolution

环境系统冲突解决中的创造力

• 批准号: RGPIN-2018-04345
• 负责人: Hipel, Keith
• 金额: $ 6.41万
• 依托单位: University of Waterloo
• 依托单位国家: 加拿大
• 项目类别: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
• 财政年份: 2020
• 资助国家: 加拿大
• 起止时间: 2020-01-01 至 2021-12-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nserc-crsng.gc.ca/ase-oro/Details-Detailles_eng.asp?id=712660
• 关键词: Creativity; Environmental; Systems; Conflict; Resolution

The overall objective is to develop innovative techniques for formally incorporating creativity into conflict resolution in order to obtain responsible outcomes to challenging environmental controversies, which are sustainable and fair. To operationalize the concept of creativity for resolving an actual dispute, two kinds of seminal decision technologies will be designed: learning methods for discovering how a decision maker (DM) may be thinking under conflict and creativity techniques for determining how this thinking can be purposefully directed in order to reach a win/win resolution. In a conflict in which misunderstandings may exist among DMs and for which a surprising result may occur, learning methods will be constructed for ascertaining the correct preferences and intentions of a DM. For example, an environmental agency may mistakenly think that a chemical company is environmentally responsible and is shocked to find out that the company has been discharging more pollutants than allowed into the environment due to financial concerns. When an unexpected outcome does occur, a DM learns from this experience and the conflict enters a new phase founded on a more informed understanding. Moreover, based on observable actions a DM may take in a dispute in which preferences may be largely unknown, various learning methods will be constructed for determining associated preferences. After learning as much as possible about a particular dispute, inverse engineering techniques will be built for calculating the preference changes needed by DMs to reach an attractive outcome. This type of information could be highly informative in a third party intervention in which a facilitator attempts to lead the parties in dispute over a certain issue towards a responsible resolution in which, for instance, a polluting company eventually prefers to cut back significantly in its generation of wastes by adopting more advanced production technologies so that the local community is not adversely affected. The role of introducing attractive options into a conflict to create a more positive attitude will also be addressed, such as offering tax incentives for cleansing and developing polluted land. Large strides will also be made in determining the kinds of behavior needed by DMs to cause specified outcomes to take place in a conflict given the preferences of the DMs in what is called the behavioral engine problem. The ultimate purpose of this landmark research is to make fundamental advancements in learning and creative thinking as part of the long-term goal of benefiting Canadian Society by discovering sensible resolutions to challenging complex conflicts lying at the confluence of society, technology and the environment from a systems perspective, with an emphasis on pollution controversies involving water, land and the atmosphere caused by human activities in energy production, industry and agriculture.

总的目标是开发创新技术，将创造力正式纳入冲突解决方案，以取得负责任的结果，以应对可持续和公平的环境争议。为了将创造性的概念用于解决实际争端，将设计两种开创性的决策技术：用于发现决策者(DM)在冲突中可能如何思考的学习方法，以及用于确定如何有目的地指导这种思维以实现双赢解决的创造性技术。在DM之间可能存在误解的冲突中，可能会出现令人惊讶的结果，学习方法将被构建以确定DM的正确偏好和意图。例如，环境机构可能错误地认为一家化学公司对环境负责，并震惊地发现，由于财务方面的考虑，该公司一直在向环境中排放超过允许的污染物。当一个意想不到的结果确实发生时，DM从这一经历中吸取教训，冲突进入一个建立在更知情的理解基础上的新阶段。此外，基于DM在偏好可能在很大程度上未知的争端中可能采取的可观察的行动，将构建各种学习方法来确定相关的偏好。在尽可能多地了解某一特定争端后，将建立逆向工程技术，以计算DM所需的偏好变化，以获得有吸引力的结果。这类信息在第三方干预中可能是非常有用的，在第三方干预中，调解人试图引导就某一问题发生争端的各方达成负责任的解决办法，例如，污染公司最终倾向于通过采用更先进的生产技术大幅减少废物的产生，以便当地社区不受不利影响。在冲突中引入有吸引力的选择以创造更积极的态度的作用也将得到解决，例如为清理和开发受污染的土地提供税收优惠。考虑到DM在所谓的行为引擎问题中的偏好，在确定DM所需的行为类型以在冲突中导致特定结果发生方面也将取得很大进展。这项具有里程碑意义的研究的最终目的是在学习和创造性思维方面取得根本性进展，作为造福加拿大社会的长期目标的一部分，从系统的角度寻找合理的解决方案，以挑战社会、技术和环境的交汇处存在的复杂冲突，重点关注能源生产、工业和农业中人类活动造成的涉及水、土地和大气的污染争议。